4 ms·
I came across this while reading the article: "unlike Napoleon and the Tsars, Roman emperors before Diocletian were not absolutists" This is one of those litt
by pdonis 10y ago
I came across this while reading the article:
"unlike Napoleon and the Tsars, Roman emperors before Diocletian were not absolutists"
This is one of those little "red flag" moments when you realize the writer is either ignorant of the facts, or thinks the reader is. Just picking a few that come to mind quickly: Caligula, Nero, and Commodus would certainly have answered to the description "absolutist" (and would have been proud of it), and one could argue that all of the emperors, from Augustus on, were "absolutist" for at least some reasonable interpretations of that word.
At that point I lost interest in the article; a writer can have his own opinions, but he can't have his own facts.
(In fact, I'm even more confused by the choice of Diocletian as the starting point for absolutist emperors: he abdicated.)
- zafka 10y agoI had skipped over that, but your comment interested me as I have liked what I read by Taleb. Looking up "Absolutist" in Wikipedia gives: Moral absolutism, the position that there are absolute standards against which moral questions can be judged, and that certain actions are either good or evil, regardless of the context of the act. This definition appears to jive with what Taleb was saying. Are you using a different definition?
- pdonis 10y agoThe word "absolutist" has several possible interpretations; moral absolutism is only one, and in context I don't think it makes sense. The definition I was using, which seems far closer to how Taleb appears to be using the word, is (from dictionary.com--merriam-webster.com gives a similar definition): "the principle or the exercise of complete and unrestricted power in government." In other words, an absolutist about power, not about morals.