3 ms·
What if a group of conscripts decide that they'd rather "save themselves" by blowing themselves up, along with $100mm of your materiel? And then this becomes a
by derefr 10y ago
What if a group of conscripts decide that they'd rather "save themselves" by blowing themselves up, along with $100mm of your materiel? And then this becomes a meme—something other conscripts hear about and copy? I could see that happening if conscription ever returned in the US—we have an awful lot of "violent pacifists" (picture what happens if you draft some of the police-brutality protestors.)
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoWe have thousands of years of histories of armies. How often has this happened?
- derefr 10y agoWe don't have thousands of years of people thinking they're entitled to never do what anyone else tells them. That's something unique to "the Western world, post-conscription." (Or, we do have some examples: look at what happens when a country's nobles are conscripted [directly commissioned, rather] into service during wartime. Frequently they lock themselves in their mansions garrisoned with the very private standing armies they were supposed to bring to draft.)
- clock_tower 10y agoEver heard the phrase "rabble of conscripts"? Napoleon was the first to use conscripts successfully; before him, it was proverbial that a smaller force of professionals (volunteers, landowners, adventurers, or typically a mix of all three) could wipe the floor with a much larger conscript army. Conscripts could make adequate garrisons, where they'd seldom be called on to fight (and if the castle or fortress fell, everyone in it would be killed, so there was that too), but not much more than that.
- koolba 10y agoThat's called being a domestic terrorist and, IMNSHO, is a prime candidate for a long prison sentence.
- Arizhel 10y agoActual terrorists generally aren't deterred by the threat of prison. You're talking about people willing to blow themselves up; they're not worried about prison.
- koolba 10y agoI'm not saying it will deter them, I'm saying it's already a crime. There's nothing special about going after them for it. With our current volunteer system nothing stops a nut job from signing up. That's why they have psych exams and ongoing mental health monitoring. It's no different if you have a draft with everybody having to join. Heck, I'd bet you'd get less overall craziness (as a percentage) from the population of people that otherwise wouldn't join the armed forces.
- derefr 10y agoI wasn't positing psychosis; I was positing a spontaneous violent resistance movement forming as a rational response to conscription in otherwise mentally-healthy individuals: the same people who would draft-dodge, but angrier at the state and interested in seeing their country actually lose an unjust war. You know, like you'd feel if you were an Iraqi citizen under ISIS.
- koolba 10y agoAnd I'm proposing that in the event that happens, we round up those domestic terrorists, give them a swift (but fair!) trial, lock them up, and finally throw away the key. You'll find little to no sympathy from most people, including your humble commenter, for domestic terrorism and treason.
- Arizhel 10y agoSo you think people in Mosul who refuse to fight for ISIS, and violently resist them, are traitors? Nice to know that you support terrorism. And before you try the "ISIS isn't a government" BS line, the same logic applies to German citizens in the 1930s-40s. Apparently you think Germans who refuse to fight for Hitler are traitors. Interesting what kind of values you support. I think people like you should be locked up and the key thrown away. Supporting mass murder is disgusting.
- Sharlin 10y agoAs a citizen of a country with a conscription-based military, and having served myself, that "what if" question is better aimed at https://what-if.xkcd.com/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/.