7 ms·
> So now we know that there is atleast some appetite for shares with no controlling interest and no indication of paying out a dividend any time soon. A current
by pm90 10y ago
> So now we know that there is atleast some appetite for shares with no controlling interest and no indication of paying out a dividend any time soon. A current market cap of 30 Billion is a pretty darn big accomplishment!
This is really disturbing. I don't know if its an indicator of too much money in the market, or just the fact that the market itself has expanded so much. Why would investors be OK with losing power?
- trjordan 10y agoFor the same reason 50% of the US didn't vote in the last election. Or employees don't demand to view board decks. Most investors are buying as a way to make money off of continued success. They don't want to control the business or make decisions, and even if they did, they don't want to invest enough to make a dent in the normal 1-share-1-vote sort of model. They're looking the company and hooking their accounts to its success. In the public markets, most investors aren't in it for the control, they're in it for the returns.
- slezakattack 10y agoI think you have an interesting point but I disagree with your analogy of a presidential election. The motivations for voting in a presidential election are not always financial (even though future policies could very well determine your own financial outlook..). I think you're right about investors are in it for the returns but having control can help steer your returns. If everybody thinks the CEO is not increasing shareholder value, you vote to remove said CEO. This is not always positive either as many investors want quick returns and not always have patience for visionaries..
- trjordan 10y agoI guess my point was more that at some scale, it feels worthless to vote at all. If I disagree with Snap's CEO, my $500 of stock feels about like my vote in the presidential election. I doubt my input changes the course of anything. There's a good reason to exert control in both cases, but for many, it feels futile to do so.
- bduerst 10y agoWhy not just invest in corporate bonds then? At least then you're safer from bankruptcies.
- zardo 10y agoBecause you're also safe from huge success.
- jasode 10y agoCorporate bonds are not a slam dunk win over investing in dual class shares of an IPO. What kind of corporate bonds specifically? Is it Super safe AAA rated?[1] Or high-yield (aka "junk bonds")?[2] If an investor wants big returns like he's hoping for Snap's IPO, buying safe AAA bonds isn't going to match that. E.g. Microsoft's 10-year bond only pays 3.34%.[3] That low interest rate barely above Treasury bills is the "price you pay" for safety. If you want to take more risk with a "BB-" corporate bond from Frontier Communications[4], that will pay 11%. That still won't match the potential upside of high flying stocks and the investor has to factor in Frontier's increased potential for defaulting on that debt. (Frontier wouldn't have to pay 11% if all lenders were confident the company would pay it back.) It's not just the bankruptcies to worry about; lots of corporations default on their debts.[5][6] It's perfectly rational for some investors to calculate a risk-vs-reward and conclude that investing in shares with reduced voting power is better putting money into low-grade corporate bonds. [1] http://www.marketwatch.com/story/exxon-mobils-downgrade-leaves-just-two-aaa-rated-companies-in-the-us-2016-04-26 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/exxon-mobils-downgrade-leav... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-yield_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-yield_debt [3] https://www.ft.com/content/7d0a5618-e70d-11e6-967b-c88452263daf https://www.ft.com/content/7d0a5618-e70d-11e6-967b-c88452263... [4] http://quicktake.morningstar.com/stocknet/bonds.aspx?symbol=ftr http://quicktake.morningstar.com/stocknet/bonds.aspx?symbol=... [5] http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-07-14/global-corporate-defaults-just-hit-100-pace-surpass-financial-crisis-record http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-07-14/global-corporate-de... [6] http://www.marketwatch.com/story/company-defaults-headed-for-largest-cyclical-rise-since-recession-2016-04-11 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/company-defaults-headed-for...
- prostoalex 10y agoWell, that's where the institutional smart money is, buying up and depressing yields on high quality corporate debt. Bond market pricing also benefits large investors. A small guy buying 20-30 bonds will pay higher markup, higher commission and be quoted higher price than a large player with an 8-digit buy order. In a stock market (outside the dark pools) two players will get quoted roughly the same market price. The larger guy is likely to be at a disadvantage, as exposing a large buy order might lead to supply tightening.
- ianstormtaylor 10y ago(Disclaimer: I know nothing.) One of the things that I personally believe is that when a company IPOs their priorities become heavily skewed towards profit and earnings, often over a short term period, above all else. And I think that hurts them. I'm not sure that removing the voting rights of stockholders completely eliminates that pressure—it's probably also rooted in having to be on earnings calls, and the price fluctuations of bad earnings calls, etc.—but remove those voting rights might help to eliminate some of the negative, short-term-profit-seeking pressure. If it does, it seems reasonable for some investors to want to invest in companies that aren't as worried about voting rights takeovers.
- prostoalex 10y ago> remove those voting rights might help to eliminate some of the negative, short-term-profit-seeking pressure For every long-term success story (FB) there's also a story where investors gave the founder super-voting rights and got pretty much nothing in return (ZNGA).
- ProAm 10y agoProfit? Investors want a return, they don't really care about power (more or less). If you can get 10% over 3-5 years who cares.
- nihonde 10y agoInvestors who care about returns care about voting power. It's pretty obvious why. The fact that Snap unloaded despite their totally asymmetrical voting structure supports the conclusion that Snap's new "owners" didn't deserve a vote in the first place. Time will tell whether their gamble will pay off.
- jmharvey 10y agoIt could be an indicator that a lot of people invest without regard for foundational questions like "does this valuation make sense" or "does my ownership interest grant me any control of the company?" And I'll be the first to raise my hand on that front. On the face of it, I'm not really interested in owning a stock like this. But I've stopped picking stocks entirely, now I just invest in the stock market through index funds. And there are a lot of people like me -- enough that Vanguard funds own about 5% of just about every public company you can name. People like me are essentially saying, "We don't really care what this company does, how much it costs, or whether its stock can vote, we want to own 5% of it." (And that's just Vanguard -- there are plenty of other passive funds out there, too.) In an IPO that sells 10 or 15% of the company, these "buy at any price" investors can eat up a pretty big chunk of the available shares. So all it takes is a few investors to say, "yes, we want to buy at this valuation," and the rest of us will blindly follow.
- chimeracoder 10y agoThe $SNAP price isn't being driven by index funds. Index funds also aren't about blindly investing ("we don't really care what...") - it's about delegating that trust. For example, SPY is delegating that to a trusted entity (you're trusting that the S&P 500 will remain a meaningful measure of the US stock market).
- darkerside 10y ago"Delegating to a trusted entity" isn't different from "blindly investing"/"buy at any price". jmharvey's point stands.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> "Delegating to a trusted entity" isn't different from "blindly investing"/"buy at any price". Those are incredibly different things. If I put $5000 in SPY, even if the S&P 500 index contains $FOO today I'm not telling my brokerage firm to "buy and hold $FOO at any price", because that's not how the SPY index works, and it's also not how index fund investing works a strategy either. In addition, most indices are based on fundamentals like market cap, earnings, and price - either directly or indirectly. Putting money in an index fund is delegating the work of that research to a trusted entity, in exchange for a fee (which is usually bundled into the trading prices). Actual "blind investing" or "buy at any price" would be someone who trades on individual stocks without doing any systematic research, either directly or through a delegate.
- brentm 10y ago> Why would investors be OK with losing power? Everything is ok while everything is ok. If the company was to run into trouble these restrictions would probably be another reason (in addition to the performance) for large investors to avoid the company. Long term it remains to be seen if this will matter or not but my guess is that as long as it is sailing high many won't care.
- bjacokes 10y agoNote that Google and Facebook have effectively the same level of founder control, albeit with different implementation details. Google even had to issue a new share class in 2014 so that the company could issue more shares without the founders giving up voting control. Snap's approach seems like a more robust long-term way of telling investors that they don't have a say in things.
- pm90 10y agoYeah, that was especially shady IMO, and I was surprised back then as well. But I thought that was an exceptional case since it was the only company doing that, and it is so profitable etc. But if companies/founders can get away with this, what stops it from becoming the standard?
- donarb 10y agoNon-voting stock is nothing new, it's as old as the stock market.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 10y agoA single share of stock has historically bundled a few things: 1) A right to a pro-rata dividend 2) A right to vote on board, current executives, and strategic matters 3) A right to a pro-rata share of proceeds in case of a liquidity event, be it acquisition or a bankruptcy sale It seems that current Snap shares come with (3) and only (3), so my guess would be that those investors are betting on growth and nothing but growth. Price difference between GOOG and GOOGL provides some empirical insight into the value of a voting vs non-voting share.