9 ms·
A credible deterrent in 2020 is not 200k dudes with guns. It's air and naval power. Expensive and complex hi tech death machines. Of course, a 10m country will
by BurningFrog 10y ago
A credible deterrent in 2020 is not 200k dudes with guns. It's air and naval power. Expensive and complex hi tech death machines.
Of course, a 10m country will never have a really credible defense against nuclear super power Russia by itself.
- 67726e 10y ago> It's air and naval power. Expensive and complex hi tech death machines. Afghanistan would beg to differ... > Of course, a 10m country will never have a really credible defense against nuclear super power Russia by itself. Unless the goal of fighting a war is to wipe the opposing side off the face of the earth, no, it's a credible defense. You bleed the enemy until they lose the will to fight.
- 013a 10y agoHis argument isn't that you need air and naval. Its that air and naval are, generally, more cost effective.
- 67726e 10y agoNo, he flat out said that a bunch of dudes with guns are not a deterrent in this day and age. If that's not what he said, let him speak for himself.
- icambron 10y ago> Afghanistan would beg to differ. You're not looking at this from the Afghan perspective. From the American and Russian perspective, yes, occupying Afghanistan is a painful deathtrap. But for the Afghans their occupation is...also a painful deathtrap. Eventually winning (or even sort of winning) a war of low-tech attrition involves sacrificing a lot of lives, losing political control, and having foreign soldiers soldiers patrol your territory imposing their own laws. Afghanistan has to go through all this because they don't have a credible way to deter an invasion. That's why they keep getting invaded!
- mikeash 10y agoThe goal is not to get invaded in the first place. If you can make the conquest too expensive for the enemy then they won't try it, even if it's also expensive for you. Obviously this didn't work for Afghanistan, but their example can help it work for others. Edit: if you become part of a larger war then it can also be advantageous to make the occupation painful for the enemy when it happens. The more you hurt them, the easier and faster your allies will win. Consider Norway in the Second World War: they had no hope of overthrowing the German occupation themselves, but the resistance still contributed significantly to its eventual end.
- icambron 10y agoAgreed that the goal is to not get invaded. That's why a country that has been recently invaded by two different countries is a poor example of someone for whom deterrence worked. Perhaps the threat of a war of attrition is an effective way to do this in general, but supporting that argument requires identifying countries for whom it worked, not a country for whom it failed spectacularly.
- mikeash 10y agoAfghanistan succeeded in getting the Soviets out in the end. With the US they made the mistake of badly provoking a powerful nation. It may not be the best example, but it works.
- icambron 10y agoI'm having difficulty reconciling this statement > The goal is not to get invaded in the first place with this one > Afghanistan succeeded in getting the Soviets out in the end.
- mikeash 10y agoThe example of the Soviets losing is what would deter others. That's why I then had to explain away the US trying it not too long after.
- digitalneal 10y agoIts more about creating a delaying force against the "zerg rush" towards the capital than actually defeating an attacking superpower. If they can hold off the attacking force for 24-30 hours, they will have done their job.
- DamnYuppie 10y agoYou don't need massive air and naval power to be very tough to attack. All you have to do is see the Afghan wars, both Russian and American, for great examples. They had no airforce and no need for naval forces. A large armed and mobile force is very able to put up solid resistance to pretty much anything you can throw at it save for nukes which will likely never be used.
- muninn_ 10y agoWhatever military force was in Afghanistan never posed any sort of credible threat or resistance against the US military. The "resistance" that the US military faced came in terms of the US military wanting to try and recreate the society there, and having troops attacked while just driving around or facing resistance while conducting raids. If the US military wanted to, they could have easily destroyed every single living being and human structure in Afghanistan without much effort, they just didn't because they don't do that kind of stuff as a matter of policy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pm90 10y agoYou could basically say the same thing about any post WW2 engagement, but it means nothing. To wipe out all humans/buildings is an empty threat. Theoretically, the US could get rid of any country it didn't want by nuking them.
- muninn_ 10y agoRight, but that makes the parent comment to mine meaningless as well. The United States allowed a resistance only so much as it was tolerable versus something they cared about more.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThis is what Russians did in the Second Chechen War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Grozny_(1999%E2%80%932000) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Grozny_(1999%E2%80%9...
- cjslep 10y agoYou would be interested in the Winter War between Finland and Soviet Russia in 1939. Finland absolutely outperformed the Red Army to such an extreme that it convinced Hitler invading Soviet Russia was not going to be a problem at all. Nothing more entertaining in my mind than Finns chucking logs into tank treads to disable an entire armored division. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_War https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_War
- pm90 10y agoIt wouldn't pan out that well today though. I don't see how Sweden could ever stand up to a modernized Russian military without external assistance. But they would probably fare better than Ukraine.
- ptaipale 10y agoIt's not that Sweden or Finland could alone stop Russia from conquering their territory. It's that they would make it costly to achieve, and much, much costlier to maintain.
- maus42 10y agoDuring the Cold War, Sweden had one the most formidable air forces in the European theater (supported by homegrown industrial base), whatever passes for a navy in Baltic Sea and large not that badly armed conscript force, together probably quite capable of at least providing a credible hindrance to any forces the Soviets would throw against them. I always wondered how quickly that was dismantled. I guess they still have a navy.
- BurningFrog 10y agoFinland was lucky to be invaded by the Soviets when their military was at their peak of incompetency, after Stalin had killed tons of the officers. They quickly learned, and in the followup war(s), Finland was thoroughly beat, and lost 1/10 of it's territory.
- zmb_ 10y ago> 200k dudes with guns Conscript military doesn't mean that you just teach everyone to dig a hole and sit in it with a rifle. You train conscripts into every role you need in a 200k strong modern military. Including operators and maintainers of the hi-tech death machines, sigint operatives, radar operators, tank crews, missile forces, officers of all kinds, and yes, the guys that dig holes and sit in them with rifles. One of the strengths of a conscript military is that you get everyone, which includes all kinds of current and future skill sets. Modern conscript armies aim to put that expertise into the best possible use.
- pilsetnieks 10y agoYou literally cannot use conscripts for anything of "operators and maintainers of the hi-tech death machines, sigint operatives, radar operators, tank crews, missile forces, officers." First of all, most of them take at least a year to get up to speed, if not more, and they have to maintain their competence. You cannot just release a conscript after his year long stint, and call him up ten years later - the ten year old tech he was trained on will probably have been replaced, and even if not, he'd have forgotten most of his training. Oh, and officers by their very definition cannot be conscripts. So you're looking at guys to dig holes and sit in them with rifles and maybe some supporting jobs (administrative, kitchen, IT, construction, etc.)
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoWell, both the Swedish and Norwegian Armies have a long tradition for using conscripts to do a lot more than what you think. E.g. on the main battle tank (Leopard 2), everyone except the tank commander (i.e. driver, gunner, loader) is a conscript. My brother-in-law was in the forward sigint ops division as a conscript. 90% of ship crews are conscripts, as are most of the air force support personnell. To make sure these skills are not just forgotten, some portion of each years conscripts are selected for regular returns to the army for drills. (Army pays your employer for the time it takes, you get your regular dayjob salary.)
- sebcat 10y ago
- aphextron 10y ago>A credible deterrent in 2020 is not 200k dudes with guns. Modern weapons are of course necessary, but in the end wars are fought and won by soldiers on the ground with rifles in their hands. Modern combined arms operations require the effective coordination of all aspects; air, sea, and land.
- ptaipale 10y agoI wonder why you'r downvoted, because even if one were to disagree, yours would be a legitimate position civilly expressed. I happen to agree: you can win battles with air power and armored forces, but you can't keep an area without feet on the ground, hands carrying rifles, and if you can't keep an area, you won't win the war.
- anticodon 10y agoWhy would Russia want to invade Sweden? This is political fearmongering and bullshit.
- gspetr 10y agoThat's what keeps puzzling me. Everyone throws the word "Russia" around without providing any kind of reason as to why it would invade any of those countries in the first place. Do they have Russian military bases of strategic importance? No. Do they have population that is ethnically Russian? No.
- ptaipale 10y agoIt's not just what the neighbours have. It's what Russia is and has. Do they have a leader who is disconnected from regular life, poses in absurd settings and gets his information from intelligence agencies? Check. Do they have a political system that has an internally dysfunctional economy and that needs external enemies to keep people from looking at what happens domestically? Check. Do they repress internal opposition? Check. Do they despise democracy? Check. Do they have a media that is spreading propaganda about neighbours and is controlled by the government? Check. Do they think in terms of "spheres of influence"? Check. There are enough parallels to Stalin's USSR to make neighbours worried.
- gspetr 10y agoProblem with your argument is, the last thing Russia wants is more sanctions, precisely because of it's currently collapsing economy. People are not happy and it is 2017, exactly a century since the Great October Revolution of 1917. This severely limits them in search of external enemies.
- ptaipale 10y agoI'm not that worried about 2017, but where Russia is heading in the medium term. But even this year, they seem to be willing to continue to wage war in Ukraine, and with Belarus in turmoil, they may feel they have to send in some tanks to defend the friendly Lukashenko regime.
- somecallitblues 10y agoLook up Finish Russian war
- LordKano 10y agoDepends on the threat you're facing. If you're worried about NATO or former Warsaw Pact aggressors, no, men with rifles are not a deterrent. If you're worried about a neighboring region's warlords sending people to steal your food, kill the men, rape the women and conscript the children, yes, men with rifles can convince them that their activities will be more fruitful somewhere else. For a threat like Russia or the USA, your only recourse is to ally with one or the other.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zeveb 10y ago> A credible deterrent in 2020 is not 200k dudes with guns. It's air and naval power. Expensive and complex hi tech death machines. I don't know — that's certainly the reason why many nations have gotten rid of conscription, but I think it may be mistaken. Sure, in the initial stages of a force-on-force, peer conflict it's going to be all about complex, hi-tech machines, but what about sustained, low-level operations. fewer than 200,000 dudes with guns & bombs have given the U.S. a bit of a pause in Afghanistan & Iraq, after all.
- fjdlwlv 10y agoIf Iraq is your model, you don't need conscription, just widely disseminate copies of the Anarchist's Cookbook for IED
- Jach 10y agoIf the threat is annihilation, well, I guess it depends how advanced Sweden's bio- and chem-engineering is in order to quickly create weapons severe enough to counter a nuclear power. When your threat model isn't annihilation but simply being overrun and submitting to a new ruler and set of foreign laws and customs, having a population with guns and gun training works pretty well to make it difficult for an outside party to achieve that even with massively better war tech.
- dogma1138 10y agoDon't underestimate what a defensive force fighting on their own turf can achieve. Not to mention that European defensive doctrine is to hold on until allies can be rallied.