7 ms·
Ask HN: Why technology is not hot about solving real life problems?
I get it that autonomous cars are super cool, but it solves the problem of a human being not wanting to drive.
Autonomous solutions for farm vehicles is far more important and necessary and urgent, but how come driverless cars are more important than the problem of growing food?
I am really struggling with understanding some of the responses/reactions to my queries for farm robots. It all comes down to $$. Some firms won't even give me a quote. They simply tell me to wait till autonomous vehicles becomes mainstream and robotics tech would become more accessible(I don't necessarily agree with this). I don't get it. It's food! Everyone needs it. Like..literally..every single person needs to eat. Not everyone needs to own a driverless car.
I guess I understand the reasoning why farmers are less important than those who can afford 100k cars that drive themselves, but I can't grasp the logic or rationality behind it.
I have some funds but everyone wants to know how much I can spend without giving me a quote. That makes no sense to me. If I were in a farmers market and a customer walks by my stall..and wants to know how much the tomatoes cost, I don't ask them how much they have in their wallet..I tell them how much it costs and they buy if they can..yea?
But let me tell you, this doesn't happen when a farmer approaches an engineering company to design a farm bot.
What am I doing wrong?
- HammadB 10y agoI'd be curious to know what you want said robot to do
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoWeeding. For starters. That's where we use most manual labour. Followed by harvesting.
- dangrossman 10y agoThere's a huge variety of automated machinery used in agriculture already. Tilling, sowing, and harvesting grains can be done by robots. Cows can be fed and milked by robots. A "roomba for weeds" sweeps the fields scanning every plant and spraying herbicides only on the weeds, leaving the veggies untouched. Self-driving tractors have been driving themselves up and down fields for over a decade. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driverless_tractor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driverless_tractor http://smartmachines.bluerivert.com/ http://smartmachines.bluerivert.com/ http://www.precisionplanting.com/#products/ http://www.precisionplanting.com/#products/ https://shop.deepfield-robotics.com/en/deepfield-connect.html https://shop.deepfield-robotics.com/en/deepfield-connect.htm... http://www.sweeper-robot.eu/ http://www.sweeper-robot.eu/ https://www.lely.com/the-barn/milking/ https://www.lely.com/the-barn/milking/ https://www.lely.com/the-barn/feeding/vector/ https://www.lely.com/the-barn/feeding/vector/ I don't believe it's true that everyone's working on self-driving cars to the exclusion of applications of robotics to farming... I also don't believe buying a $120,000 robot is similar to buying a tomato at a farmer's market.
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoIt's not that common. I don't know even one farmer who uses autonomous tractors. Like literally.. Except..Right now, blue river tech's thinning machine in salinas but that's kinda hitched to a tractor, iirc. And here is why..1. They are hundreds of thousands of dollars and it is not accessible to smaller farmers. 2. Current tech is more useful for commodity farmers and not the kind of farmers who bring your tomatoes or kale to the kitchen. 3. Corporate farms that cultivate a couple of thousand acres will have more use for it. Small farmers like me won't do it. 4. Even large farmers will be suspicious ..because as a farmer ..if something malfunctions(large machinery and threat of malfunction is a package deal)and it is a few tonnes heavy and your entire harvest over a thousand acres is dependent on machinery you didn't tool or fashion with your own hands, you tend not to sink in a lot of money in it. 5. It beggars belief that they won't come up with smaller robots for the field that is affordable. Because it dilutes risk. Most importanly, we need it. One can harvest a couple of hundred acres of sugar beets with a small crew and machines within a short period of time but when it's time to pick tomatoes, it has to be done by hand only..only with back breaking labour..perishables must be picked right ON that day. This is important to us. Labour issues are not going to get any better. It was never in a good spot in the first place anyways.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- curuinor 10y agoYou can see why technology advances less fast in these matters from this attitude. It's borne of experience, true, but real machines are less profitable in every way, so people do the capitalist thing and follow the profit margin. Google has a margin, after paying obscene salaries to its engineers, of over 40%. Sales cycles are 10-1000x faster, except for larger companies who negotiate - but the larger companies have lots more money. Agriculture is the oldest and most essential part of civilization. However, that means we know the most about it, and therefore it is among the most unprofitable parts of it.
- coralreef 10y agoAutonomous cars solve transportation problems. Autonomous cars improve safety and saves lives. Drivers don't get tired, and drunk people don't control them. Autonomous cars increases accessibility and reduces the cost of transportation; a fleet of them can patrol the city 24/7, servicing people who would otherwise be ripped off by taxis/uber or stranded because local transportation means stop late at night (subways, buses, trains).
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoBut it's human labour in the hot sun that brings food to our table. Isn't it important to figure how to move beyond manual labour when we have tech available for creating something we need for our sustenance? We can survive without cars..self driving or not..but not without food. Which deserves a tech revolution? It's not a competition..why not both? Even if we don't have to 'break our backs' ourselves..in say..America and our vegetables come from Mexico or Guatemala or Honduras or wherever its cheap so it's plentiful for us..people are still working hard in those countries? Shouldn't this be an universally urgent issue to resolve? People die of hunger in poor countries. We send $ or clothes or someone sends aid etc..but if they are able to find a way to eat..to exploit and preserve and regenerate natural resources, they don't need any help at all, no? I would like to think that tech has a reach beyond borders and solves problems that are crippling. I don't think I am wrong in that expectation.
- inimino 10y agoThe problem is that the car market is bigger, and massive investment there hasn't yet produced a viable product. A farm robot would have added challenges and is a much smaller market. Anybody that can design robots that can do what you want at this time would not be sitting on the technology and anybody doing new R&D here is going to go for the massive, easier market before the smaller, more difficult market.
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoIt's not that difficult. Everything is open source these days. I can licence the tech. I find it worthwhile to put my own money into it. But I am baffled by the stone wall I face because no matter how earnestly I make my case..even if I pay for it, it's peanuts compared to the driverless cars or even let's say..the toy robot market.. I wanted to buy one from EU but they can't sell in US because radio frequencies used don't conform to US norms.
- inimino 10y agoMaybe it's more advanced than I thought. Maybe you can get a farmers coop to invest in it, if it is almost commercializable?
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoIt's specialized and I want a paradigm shift in how we grow food..not refine existing design. I am not even looking for investment to get the design down. I feel like I am stuck explaining to engineers because it feels like we are talking different languages. When I show a sketch that I want to be drawn technically, they immediately go back to an existing tractor or a vehicle..and we are back to a 2000lb behemoth. I can't work my way around the engineer's tendency to keep tinkering. Example: I asked a dear friend for help..now..I have known him for 20 years and I am pretty sure he can read my mind at this point. And we spoke for 5 hours..I kid you not..5 hours! And I left to take a personal call and within 20 minutes, he was excited to show me that it can now also chop wood with an elegant tweak and refining design. I almost wept. It was brilliant, yes. It worked, yes. But it is not what I needed. Sometimes simple is enough. I couldn't rein in that horse in the engineers' mind anymore. I am in awe of such cerebral dexterity but I want cunning nimbleness of smaller machines. Also..I am beginning to think it's a gendered issue. Maybe I am wrong. Or not. Every male engineer that I have spoken to wants big machines that can multitask in the field. But I want choices and smaller machines..I want to be able to mix and match with lots of options. Each task is specialized. One big machine with brute force is not going to cut it. I can't translate that philosophy into a language engineers can understand. It's very frustrating.
- CyberFonic 10y agoCustom engineering design and construction is very expensive because they cannot amortize the costs over many units. If it was like tomatoes, that is being produced by the thousands then you would be able to get a very specific price. But one-off are very hard to cost, especially in the absence of detailed design and specification. You might be better off looking at what the established farm machinery companies are doing, for example John Deere has an autonomous tractor. There are also many companies who retrofit GPS and other automation to existing farm machinery. I found thousands of different automated farm machines with a quick Google search, so I don't know where you have been looking. Another option is to contact the engineering faculty of a nearby university, they might be interested in solving a real world problem if you can produce a preliminary requirements specification.
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoI hear what you are saying. But in my opinion..it's exactly the huge farm machines that has created unsustainable conditions in agriculture. I think there is a tipping point. When population was sparse, we were able to get away with pulling a plough with buffaloes. As population exploded, we innovated by creating heavy machinery but sacrificed soil integrity and had to rely on pesticides and fertilizers etc. because of the volume, market value was also affected. We sacrificed soil. At this point, population is out of control and cultivable land is shrinking. Now we have to preserve land and change the way we farm because we can't use earth moving machines and keep ripping earth to feed people who are also taking up land for housing and land for industry. For regenerative agriculture, land has to be preserved and we have to go back to human scale farming but using smart techniques. I figured that solution is in places who are facing the problem of shrinking ag land. I think we take the swathes of land from sea to shining sea for granted. Even assuming that soil has not become useless, there aren't enough people farming and with population increasing, it's going to go away. Think China..they are buying land in Africa to grow food for their people because their aquifers are drying up. We are already only growing commodities like corn, soy..and feeding them to hogs and chicken. Which is actually more expensive in terms of water. I have started looking at countries that are ahead of the curve..where we will be in 100 years. Small countries, aging and shrinking population..yet less land. There are a few nice robotic base chassis units on alibaba. Then I am going to start cold calling universities in places like Philippines, Vietnam, India etc because if anyone needs small/autonomous, it's going to be rice growing farmers. Maybe bring it back here for collaboration with univ here for the automation part. Ag universities in the states are married to what works. Anything that hasn't been tried and tested is not taught and is frowned upon. I get it. I guess that's how academia works. I have spoken to some retired professors and current head of depts in ag colleges in the states and everyone says it can be done..but it's not worth it. One of them laughed at me. Of course..why try something new when you can suckle at the teat of almost instant credit and subsidies. A farmer I know and work with has been diagnosed with valley fever. It's prevalent in Central Valley. It's a fungal infection where spores lodge in lungs during certain seasons...it comes from the soil and farmers and their children are the sickest and are often covered by barest minimum insurance if any..that's a cost of farming too. But no one sees it. Not even farmers. I am not a generational farmer and it amazes me that they keep going at it. And fewer kids are picking up the profession of farming. New generation grew up caressing smart phone screens to swipe..not driving heavy farm machinery or knowing how to fix its mechanical innards. No way they will do what their fathers and grandfathers did.. I remember the rotary phone. And how the wires snake up from phone to wall. Smart phones are mobile and fit palm of the hand. John Deeres and heavy farm equipment are the rotary phones of farming. If we keep basing design on them, we will never figure the next best design. I do like the idea of universities. Thanks. I will mix it up a bit and try outside first. I don't believe it will happen in the states.
- bsvalley 10y agoLong story short - larger market, more money to be made in the consumer's market. Blame investors not innovators.
- RUG3Y 10y agoOne reason may be that the tech industry exists mainly in metro areas and is city-focused. These people live in the city and deal with city problems on a daily basis. Also, farming is just not sexy.
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoI think you are right. Farming doesn't get a lot of people excited. I can see that now.
- dorfuss 10y agoDo you remember that Major Major's father made a good living by not growing more alfalfa than anyone else in the county? But let's put things in order: I think your assumptions are wrong. First I would deal with the automated driving, then with the farming business. Automated cars are not only for people who don't enjoy driving their car towards the setting sun and enjoying freedom. Literally everything you can buy, eat and enjoy in life relies on transport. I would guess that none of the consumer goods you purchase are produced where you live - maybe with the exception of a bakery, restaurant and your local Starbucks. Automated trucks are simply a huge thing. You will be able to drive them non stop, distribute the traffic more reasonably etc. Passanger transport is another thing, no less important. A lot of white collar workers have to visit their clients in person and spend many hours driving. Their talents and competences are not used properly. If they don't have to focus on the road, there could be a huge boost in their productivity. Even if they would just be able to relax more during the business travells by watching films. Self driving cars are not just a matter of leisure, but of significant reduction of cost of transport that everything relies on. And why do we automate in the first place? - to free human energy. Sitting in a car and driving thousands of kilometers is just dumb. Necessary, but dumb and tremendously repetitive. Once the machines can do it, the man can focus on specialised tasks that only humans can do. I believe that is the major task of CS in general - to free human potential. I have nothing to do with farming, but I believe your diagnosis is mistaken. Food production has been automated so heavily, that a single farmer is able to produce an incredible amount of food (it means farmers invested a lot in their current technology). Moreover, as indicated in the beginning, US gov. and other governments in Europe PAY farmers for NOT growing food. And food production is often not very profitable and has to be heavily subsidized. Farmers operate on very very narrow profit margins and therefore investment has to be able to cut (already low) production costs. Robots are sophisticated machines and the maintenance cost is high. On the other hand manual labour on farms is very cheap. I believe that the benefits of automatisations in the farming industry are still not good enough to balance the cost. Moreover, there is virtually no shortage of food, especially in the west. The last big starvation (not caused by politics) in Europe was a matter of the end of 19th century. While transport is an ever growing business - we want more stuff, faster, delivered from further away, food producers are rather more concerned about governments keeping the subsidies and import tariffs to supress supply. Considering all of the above - food production is not such a big problem, and its share in the economy is very very small. Having said that, of course there is a potential market for even more machines and automation, but I am not surprised that the farmers are not interested in it at the moment.
- tgragnato 10y agoIMHO it all boils down to economic interest of some strong powers: in EU they're not cheap, but cheaper ... I would like to say a lot about this, but I am gonna redirect you to some documentaries: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_According_to_Monsanto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_According_to_Monsant...
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoThanks. They are good documentaries. I haven't seen world acc to Monsanto yet. Bayer is set to merge with Monsanto soon. Things are about to get 'interesting'. Companies that had to do with production of zyklon b gas and agent orange involved with our medicines and our food. Life and death ..two sides of the same coin..taking turns. Trippy.