3 ms·
I would like to see a tax system that makes it more attractive to hire people and pay them well. I am not that versed in economics but are there any such propos
by maxxxxx 10y ago
I would like to see a tax system that makes it more attractive to hire people and pay them well. I am not that versed in economics but are there any such proposals out there? The current trend with more and more income going to the upper ranks should be stopped.
- dogma1138 10y agoWhat a lot of people miss about "upper ranks" compensation is that it's performance based and conditional (lets ignore for the moment CEOs that underperform and still get huge bonuses). Most people will not accept a performance based salary, in most jurisdictions it's also nearly impossible to do pay cuts properly. Say that you reduce the compensation of a all C level execs of a company from 10M to 2. The first thing you notice is that CEOs that say earn 10M tend to work for very large companies, so a 1000 employee company that gets 8M free cash now has 8000$ per employee for raises. Say that it had 10 C level execs earning 10M per year so now you have 80,000$ per employee for a raise, now that's money. You give all your employee a raise from 100K to 180K and they are all super happy, but then the quarterly results are not good for a few quarters cutting 80% the salary of C level execs at that point is easy, reducing the salary of every employee by 44% isn't, in many places it might not even be legal. But even this is usually a very unrealistic situation let's take Microsoft it employs over 60,000 people if you take every employee in MSFT with over 1M$ per year in compensation and you cut it by which every amount you want you won't get an amount that when divided by all employees would result in any significant increase in pay to the levels you expect. Sure if you liquidate Satya's compensation that is 1500$ increase to everyone, but after Satya the next high salary is probably the COO (and Kevin Turner which was the former COO has a total compensation of about 12M per year) but then again the majority of the compensation tends to be in equity which isn't hard cash, and the jump (or drop) between C level execs is quite big and if you count everyone that makes over 1M in MSFT you will probably will only reach 300M in total and about 100M in cash.
- maxxxxx 10y agoFact is that the income of the top 1 (or use another number) percent has increased steadily over the last 40 years. As far as I know their share of national income has doubled while the bottom 50% have seen no increase. I doubt that the performance of top management these days is much better than 40 years ago to justify that increase while the rest of the workers has been slacking off and therefore doesn't deserve a raise. In my view it would be good to create a tax system that incentivizes paying average workers more. A strong middle class is the best recipe for a healthy society.
- ucaetano 10y agoLowering the tax wedge (reducing payroll and income taxes) and making labor laws more flexible does exactly that. Lowering minimum wage and increasing earned-income tax credit (aka negative tax rate) also has a similar effect. Personally, I'm in favor of a strong earned-income program. On your second point, why should it be stopped? Actual question, interested in hearing opinions about it. Income tax by itself is highly deceptive, as it doesn't include payroll tax. Companies don't look at salaries, they look at the total cost, which includes salary, benefits, bonuses and payroll taxes/fees. The payroll taxes often aren't seen by the employees, so they feel they are being taxed less than they actually are. The impact of that can be huge. Let's compare France and Switzerland: Average yearly total cost worker: * Switzerland: 74k USD PPP * France: 63k USD PPP Average yearly gross income per worker: * Switzerland: 70k USD PPP * France: 46k USD PPP Average net income after taxes per worker: * Switzerland: 58k USD PPP * France: 33k USD PPP So out of every dollar the company spends on a worker, in France the worker gets 52% of that. In Switzerland the worker gets 78% of that. In PPP-adjusted numbers, the average worker in Switzerland makes 75% more than the average worker in France, despite costing less than 20% more. In which country do you think a company would want to hire employees? Switzerland or France? Source: OECD.