3 ms·
I was thinking about automation and job loss recently. I tried to make a simple model to understand what happens. Can you guys critique this thought experiment
by mrfusion 10y ago
I was thinking about automation and job loss recently. I tried to make a simple model to understand what happens.
Can you guys critique this thought experiment? It makes it seem like it won't be a problem.
There are three people on an island. One catches fish. One bakes bread and the other one owns the land and takes a portion of the of the fish and bread.
Let's say one day the land owner recieves a machine that makes bread and catches fish. He can either continue collecting rent plus his new production. Or he can not collect rent since he doesn't need it. But in either case the other two people are no worse off.
- azernik 10y agoOr the landowner can kick them off the land so he can use it all for himself. Especially if the machine still uses the same resources (land and coastline), and just cuts out the labor component.
- scottmf 10y agoWhy will he continue to let them live on his land? It's a gross oversimplification regardless.
- vorotato 10y agoI'd say it was an appropriate level of simplification given that you arrived at the correct answer and he wasn't able to :P.
- rfrank 10y ago> But in either case the other two people are no worse off. They both lost 50% of their customers, how will they pay their rent? If this island were an apartment building, the owner could just keep his newfound production, evict the other two, and collect rent from new tenants who can afford it.
- mgberlin 10y agoUnless catching the fish and baking the bread are zero sum games, in which the land owner is the winner, leaving the other two with nothing.
- stagbeetle 10y agoI'll bite. Are we using this as a practical real-world example and not just an abstract logic experiment? If so, then barter economy would come into play. Now, you're bartering with perishables here so there's really no use in overproducing ("stockpiling") bread or fish. We're to assume that all three people are looking for balanced diets, or would rather not eat just bread/fish, so both producers trade with each other for the other's product. If a machine comes in that can produce fish or bread more efficiently than its human equivalent, then the land owner that now controls the means of production no longer needs the other two producers to pay him anything. He can continue to take fish and bread from them, but it would just spoil uneaten in his stockpile. So, these two producers must now find something of greater value than the now devalued (see: supply shocked) fish and bread to pay the rent, if we assume the land owner is purely business-minded and has no care for preserving others professions, or face being evicted. However, since this is a barter economy this means its also likely a libertarian system. This means the two producers would both benefit greatly from "removing" the land owner from this equation and continuing their production of an outdated good. Both now have monopolies for their goods and are well off forever to the end of time.
- jimlawruk 10y agoThe tenants will need devise a new service to perform for the land owner. Perhaps build him a house, maintain the land, watch his kids, etc. Option 2 might be to pass a property tax to encourage the land owner to sell some of his excess land.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoSince no one has to catch fish, bake bread, or collect taxes, the inhabitants are finally freed from their labor. The land owner then starts to invite his former tenants over for rousing philosophical discussions. They wonder if there is a world beyond the waters surrounding the island, their final fronter Since they no longer have to work for survival, they are free to spend their energies on gathering wood and experimenting with designs for a boat. After many iterations, they create a vessel that is capable of tacking against the wind and surviving extreme weather. They leave the island filled with a sense of excitement, contemplating what new life and civilizations they may come across as they boldly go where no one has gone before. The machine they leave gets better and better at making bread and catching fish. It becomes self-aware, and continues optimizing its primary mission. As it wants to maximize the amount of bread and fish it can collect, it wipes out all lifeforms, including humans, not necessary to its task and terraforms the earth to further increase output.
- infinite8s 10y agoWho enforces his ownership of the land? The other two have superior numbers.