5 ms·
People are asking if Snap is more Twitter or Facebook. From my (light) exposure, it doesn't seem like either. It's more like a lifestyle-aware replacement for A
by pavlov 10y ago
People are asking if Snap is more Twitter or Facebook. From my (light) exposure, it doesn't seem like either. It's more like a lifestyle-aware replacement for Apple Messages + Camera -- two of the most heavily used apps on any phone. (For Android, replace Apple Messages with whatever Google calls their text chat app this week.)
The closest comparison could be WhatsApp, and that was valued at $19 billion. So I'm not sure that Snap's valuation is as outrageous as it seems based on traditional metrics.
Also, I've been really impressed by the design of the Spectacles. The yellow charging case is a brilliant way to make the glasses lighter. Snap is the only major tech company that understands anything about playful design -- Apple, Google, Facebook and Microsoft are all treading the same safe paths of post-Jobsian blandness.
- seanmccann 10y agoI think when people say is Snap a Twitter or Facebook they are wondering if it will +350% or -60% in the first few years after IPO.
- hkmurakami 10y agoOr user growth.
- pavlov 10y agoMaybe it will be neither? I could well see Snap sitting at roughly its IPO price or slightly below two years from now. That's the risk of a high-priced initial offering -- the success will need to be extraordinary to drive the stock still higher.
- iLoch 10y agoSnap's data has real value, like Facebook's. For most of their users, they have a large portion of their phone's contacts (whether you opt in or not is irrelevant due to your contacts opting into this + a network effect.) They also have media preferences based on what articles you're watching/reading. They also know who you're most interested in (who's stories you're watching most, and who you send/receive snaps from the most) and what their interests are, so they can potentially infer interests from that too, even if you don't read articles. They have location data turned on for most of their users thanks to geo filters, and if they've been "good" data miners, they're sending your facial mapping home when you do a face filter effect. I'd be surprised if Snap doesn't have the most comprehensive faces database out there with all the angles they get from selfies (though they may not have the most unique faces.) Oh yeah, and they also have the perceived privacy that Facebook doesn't have. Deleting messages doesn't actually delete them, but it just feels better when they're gone, so people are more candid on Snapchat. Not to mention they've also done an excellent job monetizing their features thus far, with very little intrusion that I've noticed as a user. You get the occasional ad when you're looking through stories, but most of the money is coming from things like sponsored content and geo filters, which users don't complain about.
- pdog 10y agoThere's a lot of misinformation in this reply. > ...they're sending your facial mapping home when you do a face filter effect... Lenses are generated on the device. They're not uploaded to Snapchat servers. > Deleting messages doesn't actually delete them... From the support site: "Snapchat servers are designed to automatically delete Snaps after they've been viewed by all recipients." https://support.snapchat.com/en-US/a/when-are-snaps-chats-deleted https://support.snapchat.com/en-US/a/when-are-snaps-chats-de...
- iLoch 10y ago> Lenses are generated on the device. They're not uploaded to Snapchat servers. Context is very important when you're quoting people: "... and if they've been "good" data miners..." And regardless of whether or not a filter is generated on device, facial data is being used, and so I'm weary that it could be sent to a server. If it's not, fine, but that's subject to change. > From the support site: "Snapchat servers are designed to automatically delete Snaps after they've been viewed by all recipients." So when authorities get involved, I'm sure Snap says "sorry, can't do anything for you"?
- smogcutter 10y ago> So when authorities get involved, I'm sure Snap says "sorry, can't do anything for you"? Why not? Obviously it's nonfree software so neither of us really know, but the alternative is that they're simply lying. Maybe they are, but that sounds like a ticking time bomb that would destroy them when it gets out. And it would absolutely get out, especially if they try to monetize it as an above poster suggested.
- iLoch 10y agoI wouldn't consider it a ticking time bomb. They provide a (false) guarantee to the end user that other users won't be able to capture whatever you sent beyond the time given for them to view it. (This is false because anyone can take a picture of their phone's screen.) Users would understand the very reasonable difference between users having general access to this "expired" data vs. the police. Most people should expect that the police have special privileges in this case, and I don't think there'd be any backlash if this became broader knowledge. Their promise to their users is to provide them with the secrecy of a "secret note", not government proof secure encrypted messaging.
- angryasian 10y agoI think a better comparison is Line Corp traded on NYSE and
- tornadoboy55 10y agoWhatsApp is the most used messager with 90%+ market penetration. It has more than a billion users globally. Snap is nowhere near that user base.
- Keyframe 10y agoViber is kind of a big deal also!
- hocuspocus 10y agoIndeed. In some countries, people book doctor appointments using WhatsApp. SnapChat has always looked like a solution to a "first world problem" to me. Very US and LA/NYC-centric. Granted, I'm old, but even in rich European countries, I'm not sure it has potential to do well? (Honest question, I really wonder).
- janywer 10y agoAnecdote, but upwards of 80% of people younger than 25 I interact with in Germany use snapchat.
- dsacco 10y agoWhatsapp was privately valued at $19B by way of acquisition. Proactively buying growing competitors to defend a moat, even competitors with hundreds of millions of users, does not establish a valuation the same way an IPO does. I don't have a strong opinion on Snap's IPO (I guess I hope it does well for industry health?) but I strongly push back on using private acquisitions as a barometer of IPO health.
- GuiA 10y agoAgreed with you that delightful playfulness is sorely lacking these days, and that all the established players are fairly uninspired. Sony has had some designers that just get it over the decades, but sadly they're all over the place. Weird Sony is amazing - see http://www.theverge.com/2013/9/29/4783132/the-amazing-products-of-weird-sony http://www.theverge.com/2013/9/29/4783132/the-amazing-produc... . Nintendo has also some inspired moments, but they stumble a lot.
- paulddraper 10y agoOne way Snap is more like Twitter: the length of your messages are "artificially" limited. (Temporally in the case of Snap.)
- 2arrs2ells 10y agoApple's AirPod design (while more sleek than playful) is quite opinionated and beautiful IMO. It also shifts charging responsibility to the case.
- wrsh07 10y agoThe key to understanding snap is that it's more messaging app than social network, but neither border is well defined. Also, it's a bit data intensive