4 ms·
"stories are community property." If stories are community property, then the community and not the editors should decide whether the story submission with the
by pmoriarty 10y ago
"stories are community property."
If stories are community property, then the community and not the editors should decide whether the story submission with the title it was submitted with was valuable or not by upvoting it (or not).
"Submitting doesn't entitle you to choose for the whole site what is or isn't interesting about a story."
I don't see why they couldn't. But using the same argument, the editors shouldn't get to choose for the whole site what the title should be either.
I've run across so many, many great stories with super generic, boring titles that will never be even glanced at by most readers. Those stories deserve better, and editing the title to make it reflect what the story is actually about is helpful.
HN editors should restrict their roles to keeping the conversations civil, and let the community take care of the rest.
- dang 10y ago> I've run across so many, many great stories with super generic, boring titles that will never be even glanced at by most readers. Those stories deserve better Indeed they do, and there are other strategies for achieving that than gutting HN's approach to titles which is critical to how the site functions. If you have links to stories that fit that description and haven't had attention on HN yet, I'd love to see them.
- pmoriarty 10y agoAre you suggesting users start emailing you directly when they find such stories? Is that really practical or scalable? Also, doesn't having to run stories past a gatekeeper go against the community rating system that HN is based on? I don't see administrator interference in story titles as particularly critical to the site, but community voting on stories is. Is there maybe some way to experiment with leaving story titles unchanged from how they were submitted? What would happen if HN tried that for a week?