3 ms·
Surely we banned it because it is highly irritating to people who don't smoke? The medical aspect was used to win the argument with selfish smokers who don't gi
by dboreham 10y ago
Surely we banned it because it is highly irritating to people who don't smoke? The medical aspect was used to win the argument with selfish smokers who don't give a crap about the well being of other people.
- squozzer 10y agoBefore you issue your fatwa, for the record, I don't smoke tobacco. Nor do I have a problem with places banning smoking -- I just believe it should never have been a law. > Surely we banned it because it is highly irritating to people who don't smoke? That part is correct. > The medical aspect was used to win the argument with selfish smokers who don't give a crap about the well being of other people. Stated another way, the second-hand smoke research was glommed onto by puritanicals who enjoy bossing people around - because the irration argument would never stand up in a legislative committee or a court of law - it would have rightfully been called a blue-nose law. Maybe the term "bossing people around" is a bit loaded but without the second-hand smoke studies, no one would have felt the need to ban smoking everywhere. Another system might have emerged where some places ban smoking and others don't. There's a restaurant in my town that banned minors instead of smokers to comply with our state law (actually not a bad trade, imo.) But that wasn't good enough for some -- smoking had to be banned everywhere -- because certain people felt entitled to walk into an arbitrary venue and not have to smell cigarette smoke -- hence the use of the terms "puritanical" and "bossing people around."