9 ms·
A Look inside Russian 28nm MIPS CPU – Baikal-T1
- tutanchamun 10y agoAre the black areas in this picture [0] residue or destruction from removing the heatspreder? What about the large areas that are not as dark? Is that residue from the solder/thermalpaste? I'm especially curious because the die shot from AMD's Ryzen has smaller but kind of similiar looking areas. [1] But there they look too uniform to be damage. [0] https://s.zeptobars.com/baikal-Si-HD.jpg https://s.zeptobars.com/baikal-Si-HD.jpg [1] http://i.imgur.com/le2atYb.jpg http://i.imgur.com/le2atYb.jpg
- trsohmers 10y agoIt's a flip chip design, so the heatspreader and thermal paste does not touch the part that you are seeing in these images. The areas that I think you are referring to (the big "blob" areas) are computer place and routed standard cells (primarily transistors) that the PNR tool brute forces efficient placement under certain constraints. While it does not produce the most pretty or clean design, it does a good enough job in optimizing for speed and area for most designs.
- tutanchamun 10y agoYes, that are the areas I was reffering to. Thank you for the explanation.
- vegabook 10y agohonestly, what a piece of junk. Russia has the interests of nobody on earth but itself. What it lacks in technology, and basically, general competence (who buys anything Russian except oil and weapons?), it has corresponding geopolitical calculation in abundance. Let's not let this clever operator get anywhere near our societies, because as this chip shows, its own societal structure is unable to produce competitiveness in any objective sense of the word. And that's despite having some of the most brilliant people on earth.
- freeone3000 10y agoLooks like a completely standard chip based on open specs. What sort of "general competence" are they missing here?
- vegabook 10y agowe're closing in on 10nm in the west and this is based on a MIPS architecture designed in America. It's easily 2 generations behind. Would you honestly select one of these for your phone or computer?
- rbanffy 10y agoIt seems to be a reasonably competitive SoC for IoT applications. The ARM on a RPi is on the 40 nm range. This should have reasonably better performance and MIPS used to be a nice architecture.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PerfectDlite 10y ago> It seems to be a reasonably competitive SoC for IoT applications. You can't buy it as individual and for _organizations_ price is quite high. How it can be competitive?
- rbanffy 10y agoI was talking about the part itself, not the price.
- happycube 10y agoIt's a rather boring chip - but that's OK. Given what it costs to take a 28nm design into production, you generally do need to be conservative especially on a first go around.
- olegkikin 10y ago"Russian", as in licensed from Imagination Technologies (UK) and manufactured in Taiwan.
- mrweasel 10y agoWhich makes me wonder about the on-board ethernet, is that of their own design, or is that also licensed from someone.
- petra 10y agoIt's OK with the Russians. The performance is good enough.They probably care more about the verification against security issues, and could do interesting stuff there, but we surely won't hear about that.
- kurthr 10y agoIf they're using Imagination and other's IP I'm not sure they could really verify it... but they could definitely insert their own "issues".
- petra 10y agoI'm sure their licensing with imagination includes full source code, and there's no reason they couldn't verify and/or change that for security.
- _yosefk 10y agoHey, chipmakers deserve more credit than that! I'm a chip architect and we license from IMG and we license IP from others as well, but then there's a shitton of work and plenty of things which can go wrong, costing loads of money and big delays. For those chip makers rolling their own IPs, this is rarely the biggest risk, the biggest risk is integrating everything into a working, marketable chip delivered more or less on time and within budget. Incidentally, the reason why chip companies are worth so much more than IP companies is that the cost and risk of making chips is much larger. IP and chip companies are both fabless, if the costs and risks were about the same, then I don't see why profits wouldn't be about the same. Now it could be that in this instance, marketability, schedule and budget weren't a particularly big deal, and maybe the performance is so bad that this in itself made a lot of problems disappear. But I think it's likely that someone still sweated quite some to make it work. (TFA claims they were the first to implement this CPU in silicon, BTW - again, could be easy enough if they didn't care about performance at all, or if Imagination did all the work on the synthesis scripts and the backend or held their hand, but if they wanted high performance and had to optimize synthesis and placement themselves, that's serious work. TSMC won't do it for you, either - they want a GDS-II file, and I don't think they outsourced the actual chip design.)
- bluedino 10y agoAre these only used in supercomputers, or is it common for PC's and workstations in Russia?
- PeterisP 10y agoIt's probably only used in military technology and government devices; the only advantage is the control of supply chain, security (less risk of backdoors with manufacturer cooperation) and thus suitability for local defense industry. For example, I recall seeing some announcement about a locally designed tablet computer with this or similar CPU, designed for military map/geolocation use. Both for supercomputers and ordinary workstations they'd use the same hardware as everyone else, the price/performance is better that way due to economies of scale.
- drdaeman 10y agoMaybe someone had used a grid of those, but alone that CPU is quite weak for supercomputers ;) This CPU is used in a printer: http://katyusha-print.ru/ http://katyusha-print.ru/ (but I doubt the product is any widespread - there are no such devices in stores, anywhere) For PCs it's x86 (with a small fraction of ARM) - just like (almost) everywhere else.
- kovrik 10y agoThese are mostly for government structures, military etc. No one is using them (or, say, Elbrus) at home for PC's/workstations. Maybe only some geeks and just for fun. Usually you can't even buy them in normal computer stores (at least I have never seen any).
- ferongr 10y agoI think homegrown chips like these have many application in weapons systems. Russia wouldn't want their UAVs or missle defence systems to run with Intel CPUs or other COTS CPUs with embedded blackbox OSes for example.
- konart 10y agoNo, actually these are mainly for IoT kind of use, multimedia and network devices, CNC systems (actually some companies already have ready CNC solutions with Baikal). As for the PC (like in office PC) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elbrus-8S https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elbrus-8S is the main trend for state departmets and other places were security should be higher than your usual office. 8S will be replaced with 16S in 2018.
- rodionos 10y agoAny one of those pictures should look great on my screensaver. Getting a bit tired of all those scenic sierra and half dome pictures.
- jokr004 10y agoMan, those die images are phenomenal.
- didymospl 10y agoJudging from the title, I was expecting something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matryoshka_doll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matryoshka_doll
- maxaf 10y agoYour stereotypes aren't funny. Please check them at the door.
- didymospl 10y agoOh come on, this was supposed to be a harmless tongue-in-cheek comment. I come from a country which is far behind Russia in terms of technology and I really didn't think anyone could take it as some way of mocking. My bad
- matthewaveryusa 10y agoI thought it was funny and particularly relevant because the article is written in a macro->micro progression in the tear-down. Hackernews does tend to want to stay dry. It reminds me of my second post where I got dinged trying to be funny. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10211855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10211855
- agumonkey 10y agoAlso recursion theory. And Russian turtles. And recursion theory.
- walterbell 10y agoHow can this be purchased? Imagination claims that CPU and associated GPU both support hardware virtualization.
- konart 10y agoRight now you have to be a legal entity (hope this is a correct term) to buy them, but I'm pretty sure that their board will be available for public soon: https://habrahabr.ru/post/320840/ https://habrahabr.ru/post/320840/ (review in russian)
- patrickg_zill 10y agoInteresting chip - under 5W usage and yet powerful enough for lots of things. I wonder what one of these with 8GB RAM and 1x10Gbe, 2x SATA connectors would use for power. EDIT: the Broadcom chipset used in the Rasp. Pi 3 is still at 40nm process, according to what I can find. So not sure why people would question the 28nm process' usefulness.