5 ms·
> Kalanick is the CEO. And the driver is not an employee. Yeah, I know this has been discussed a lot of times, but the way Uber is set up, there's absolutely
by dragontamer 10y ago
> Kalanick is the CEO.
And the driver is not an employee. Yeah, I know this has been discussed a lot of times, but the way Uber is set up, there's absolutely no reason for Kalanick to give an Eff about the driver's situation.
And indeed: the loyalty cuts both ways. Uber drivers can immediately drop Uber and simply work for Lyft. They have complete and utter independence from the Uber company.
Its just the nature of how Uber has been set up. I understand the driver's frustration, but what more does the driver expect?
- matt4077 10y ago> the way Uber is set up, there's absolutely no reason for Kalanick to give an Eff about the driver's situation. Except, you know, "being a human" > loyalty cuts both ways. Uber drivers can immediately drop Uber and simply work for Lyft. They have complete and utter independence from the Uber company. That's actually not that different from being an employee, where you can usually quit on short notice and start working somewhere else as well – at least on the lower end of the market. But it's wrong to consider these relationships as symmetrical in terms of power. Uber (or any employer) has vastly more power over an individual driver than the other way around. That's because loss of the gig can mean financial ruin for the driver, but the company wouldn't even notice it. That's why unions are needed to create a balance of power.
- computerex 10y agoI don't know whether we need unions or not - but until we do, Uber can hardly be faulted for playing the free market. The CEO has a board to answer to and they care about maximizing profits, like any other for profit organization.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y ago>Uber can hardly be faulted for playing the free market. Why? Seems like we should be holding them responsible in any way we can (even if that's just talking bad on a message board) for their bad actions. I don't know why we need to give them a pass on actions we don't deem moral just because it's legal.
- computerex 10y agoI don't think the actions are immoral. If I were in his shoes, I'd probably do the same thing. This is how capitalism works.
- zepto 10y agoYes, and being shamed for immoral acts is how society works. Capitalists need to either take that into account, or accept the consequences.
- matt4077 10y agoEven ignoring that, by that standard, he is among the worst human being ever with around -80 billions of "profit" so far... ...and ignoring that Uber is structured specifically to make the board toothless – proof: major VCs invested in Uber have to resort to public blog posts because they can't get answers nor actions using the standard tools of corporate governance... ...there's nothing wrong with faulting people for immoral but legal actions they take. Uber and its ilk are inflicting harm on the lower middle class by driving down the income and security of taxi drivers. The spoils go to middle-class customers (now) and VCs (theoretically, someday). Is that a good deal for society overall? Nobody knows. Wal-mart has similarly driven down prices and arguably made life easier for many people. It's also killed Main Street, created an underclass of employees earning minimum wage, and led to the consolidation of power within oligopolies in many markets. It's not a sustainable solution because boycotts and other means of regulating companies without the power of law just don't work. But there's nothing wrong with it. In fact, it's probably a necessary on the way to actual regulation by laws.
- rhizome 10y agoIf you agree that the driver is not an employee, how do you think that would have played out if TravisK had blown him off on video? Do you think everybody would see it your way, and would that be fair of them to do?
- dragontamer 10y agoHonestly? If TravisK just walked away without discussion? Then there wouldn't be any story here. The story is that TravisK raised his voice while being secretly filmed by one of the drivers. There's no story about a CEO just leaving a cab.
- st3v3r 10y ago"there's absolutely no reason for Kalanick to give an Eff about the driver's situation." Considering that, without the drivers, Uber doesn't have a product, I cannot agree with that statement. "Its just the nature of how Uber has been set up. I understand the driver's frustration, but what more does the driver expect?" For the CEO of Uber to act like a human being. But given the news recently, that's far too much for anyone to expect.
- dragontamer 10y ago> For the CEO of Uber to act like a human being. For the greater majority of Human History, slaves and concubines were normal. I have very little faith in what a "human being" can and should do.
- Trundle 10y ago>For the CEO of Uber to act like a human being. I'm not sure what humans you're interacting with but the CEO of Uber acted just how I'd expect myself or any of the other people I know to act when confronted by someone being antagonistic while I'm trying to go home after an evening out. Be unhappy with him if you want but don't try to paint it as human. You either want the CEO of Uber to act like a politician or a saint, not a human.