3 ms·
They are using Christensen's definition so "worse" means "worse by the standards of the market they are entering." Those standards will vary widely according t
by btilly 17y ago
They are using Christensen's definition so "worse" means "worse by the standards of the market they are entering."
Those standards will vary widely according to what market you're talking about. For instance in the 70s and 80s, disk drives were judged entirely on size. So a smaller size of disk was necessarily worse. And this resulted in waves of companies wiped out. In mobile devices today, people care more about portability, ruggedness, and power consumption. So a smaller disk may actually be better. Therefore whether a smaller drive is better or worse depends entirely on the context set by the market it is entering.
In the examples you are thinking of, simpler frequently does equate to worse. If the existing companies have sales pitches that are geared towards lists of checkboxes on feature sets, then I guarantee that simpler equates to worse. And yes, this is an advantage for the startup. (Assuming that it can make itself lean enough to live on the scraps at the bottom of the market.)
The underlying dynamic is that existing companies find it hard to compete at the low end of their market for a variety of reasons. One of which is that companies tend to develop infrastructures that depend on having certain profit margins. Relative to how the company is structured, the bottom of the market is always unprofitable. Conversely companies always find the top end of their market very enticing.
However technology tends to improve at a faster rate than the market's needs increase. So the crappy cheap solution naturally grows up into a sufficient solution. The providers of the cheap solution happily eat up the market, and at every step the incumbents have a hard time defending it. And so incumbents get driven out of the top of the market.
This dynamic is frequently recognized while it is happening, but for deep organizational reasons it is really, really hard to change.