5 ms·
1) eliminates unnecessary middlemen, the private insurance companies, saving beaucoup dollars [we all love our insurance companies, don't we?] The problem
by wahern 10y ago
1) eliminates unnecessary middlemen, the private insurance
companies, saving beaucoup dollars [we all love our
insurance companies, don't we?]
The problem with single player is exactly that it would put the government in the same position as insurers. It'll give people even more reason to resent government.
The fact that people still believe that both the VA and the USPS are prime examples of government gone _wrong_ should tell you everything about how well a national single-payer system would work out. Even if it was a success by the numbers, it would never be a political success. The political costs would be tremendous and perpetual.
Look at Social Security. Most conservative voters think it's a broken system, even though by the numbers it's one of the most successful and well-run programs anywhere in the world, public or private.
The baby boomer gap is easily fixed by adjusting the age of retirement, which was precisely how the system was designed to operate from the very beginning. But in the present political climate politicians 1) avoid proper maintenance while 2) simultaneously blaming "government" for the prospective short fall purely of their own creation.
The only politically viable single-payer system would be state based. There's no European Union-wide single-payer system, either.
Funding it, though, raises all sorts of problems. It's difficult for states to fund such a system independently because the Federal government soaks up so many tax dollars to spend on the military and pre-existing health programs. It's extremely difficult as a political matter to both devolve powers _and_ the requisite tax dollars back to the states. At the same time, improving the function and efficiency of federal programs is difficult given a ruling party which actively tries to sabotage those programs, even though they're politically _unable_ even among themselves to make the hard decisions that make the alternative--devolution--feasible.
- blackbagboys 10y agoI think you are overstating the persistent political difficulties a single-payer system would encounter. There has certainly been vocal conservative opposition to Social Security since its inception, but its beneficiaries form such a powerful lobby that it is effectively untouchable. I suspect that once enacted a single-payer system would be so popular among its beneficiaries (i.e. almost everyone) as to be unassailable. Something similar is happening right now with the ACA.
- ben_w 10y agoI'm in the UK (temporarily still in the EU). We have a single payer health system, much loved by the general population. However, it is also being systematically underfunded by the government, who are mostly getting away with blaming "health tourism" of foreigners rather than suffering from their own policies in elections. (This is why there was a bus with "£350 million per week" written on the side in the referendum: the NHS is really popular, and it's easy to blame outsiders). In principle, the NHS covers me when I'm anywhere in the EU, by paying for local treatment. In practice, it's not identical quality treatment, and there are edge cases. I suspect that the NHS will disintegrate under the pressure of Brexit, but on e other hand I'm extremely pessimistic about the whole thing and half the country thinks it will be great.
- BeetleB 10y ago>We have a single payer health system, much loved by the general population. While technically true, in the US, when people say "single payer" they usually mean the system Canada has, which is quite different from the UK. In Canada, doctors are still private. They merely get compensated by the government (by billing them). In the UK, doctors are public employees. Doctors don't bill the government for a procedure. They just get paid a salary.
- ben_w 10y agoInteresting, I did not realise that. I honestly don't know how the finances of different parts of the NHS are run (Hospitals, Primary Care Trusts, it's just jargon to me), has it ever been closer to the Canadian system than it is now?
- pg314 10y ago> There's no European Union-wide single-payer system, either. I think that's purely for historical reasons, though. There's no EU-wide military either.
- mamon 10y agoGovernment position as healthcare provider is exactly the opposite of private insurer. Government usually tries to limit its spending (because it already is indebted beyond reason) thus using its effective monopoly to force lower and lower prices of all drugs and medical procedures. At the same time the voters pressure (every government wants to be re-elected) forces it to provide reasonable quality of service in healthcare. At least that's how it works in most of EU. Private insurers want to maximize profits, so they charge a lot of money for their policies, while lowering overall quality of healthcare (by denying insurance to low income, high risk clients - and healthcare quality for not insured is tragic). P.S. Social Security is a flawed analogy, inner workings of Social Security and Healthcare are totaly different.
- wahern 10y agoAt least that's how it works in most of EU. But the US isn't the EU, and it sure as heck isn't as sane as a place like Germany. The US has _always_ been strongly deferential to corporate interests. It's the thing that stood out to me the most when I read the excellent book, "There is Power in a Union", a history of the American labor movement from the early 19th century to the mid 20th century. Even at the apex of the union movement--and thus the apex of a national collectivist mentality--the U.S. government and population both heavily favored corporate interests. That's not a value judgment or criticism, it's just the cold historic reality. I don't think Social Security is a flawed analogy at all. The core issue of viability isn't about the technical machinations of health care vs retirement income; it's about the politics of not only creating a national program, but _maintaining_ that program in earnest over the long-haul. And specifically the politics in the United States. Something like Social Security is the best we can hope for in terms of pervasiveness and stability. Social Security has survived precisely because it falls far short of the kind of a strong collectivist, redistributive commitment the country would need to make to enact and _sustain_ a single-payer program. In objective terms both Canada's and Japan's healthcare systems strike a decent balance between public and corporate interests, and Obamacare is tantalizingly close to them on the public/private spectrum. But I think American progressives don't appreciate how deep, strong, pervasive and _persistent_ are the conservative currents in American political culture. When progressives complain about the poor and working class voting against their own self-interest, they don't appreciate how consistent this behavior has been over the centuries. Without appreciating that, they are miscalculating the viability of their preferred options. If you examine American political history both over the long term (centuries) and short-term (decades), Obamacare was the best we could ever hope for, and even that was probably too much. And any progressive who thinks Obamacare is hopelessly flawed--because of unnecessary costs sustaining the superfluous private layers--should realize that the _only_ viable alternative is to refocus on state-based solutions. Let's imagine that Bernie Sanders won the presidency. No way in heck would he be able to champion a single-payer system. The nation didn't just elect President Trump, they gave conservatives a huge majority in _both_ Houses. So, again, the best progressives could have hoped for was tweaking Obamacare and keeping it fiscally viable. The rise of conservatism isn't going anyway any time soon; it's actually a regression to the mean for American politics. People need to keep that in mind, and stop with the wishful thinking.
- jobu 10y ago> The only politically viable single-payer system would be state based. If only that would happen. Colorado had a ballot measure last year that was soundly defeated (nearly 80% NO votes). This is in a state that went for Hillary, voted to increase minimum wage and also legalized pot a few years ago. Healthcare and health insurance have become so politicized and toxic that most people's immediate reaction is NO! to any changes or even suggestions.