10 ms·
One of the things that I find interesting about Dwarf Fortress is that (to use programming jargon) it's sort of a declarative game rather than an imperative gam
by kibwen 10y ago
One of the things that I find interesting about Dwarf Fortress is that (to use programming jargon) it's sort of a declarative game rather than an imperative game. In e.g. StarCraft you select an individual unit and demand that it move to a specific point on the map; in Dwarf Fortress you configure which dwarves are allowed to perform certain tasks, then you place a task in a queue, and some dwarf somewhere will (eventually (hopefully)) take care of it (until they get distracted by a party, or decide to go fishing, or get hungry and wander off to the dining hall, or fall asleep in a stockpile, or drop anything they're carrying and run screaming from the forgotten beast hurtling down the hallway at them). It's a fascinating difference in paradigm, and I wish more games would explore the idea of actors in the world being chaotic/free agents which will only somewhat prioritize your wishes.
- TremendousJudge 10y agoI remember a strategy game called Majesty that worked in a "declarative" way as well. You didn't order your units around, you could just place bounties on things and your soldiers would go out and kill/destroy them
- digi_owl 10y agoI owned that game, but seems to have misplaced the discs it came on...
- beaconstudios 10y agothis one? https://www.gog.com/game/majesty_gold_hd https://www.gog.com/game/majesty_gold_hd
- PepeGomez 10y agoThere's a HD version on Steam.
- pc86 10y agoOkay
- iUsedToCode 10y agoyeah, i loved Majesty. You couldn't force anybody to do anything. That way it was more chaotic. Many times you could have won quickly if only the units obeyed. But they didn't ;)
- mdemare 10y agoYeah, your level 5 wizard would try to take on a vampire on his own, and quickly expire, instead of leveling up on rats like he ought to. Loved that game, and loved the voices. Don't buy the iOS version though.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoWhat do consider lacking on iOS?
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoAssuming it's the same as the Android version, it's superficially polished and internally hollow compared to the original. I posted more here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13760412 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13760412
- IgorPartola 10y agoIt is available for iOS and Android I believe. Works great on mobile.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoThe mobile version seemed like it would be fun if it was your first experience with Majesty. It doesn't hold a candle to the original, though. Fewer heroes, monsters, missions, and worst of all, dramatically simpler and less character-ful AI, with few apparent behavioral differences between classes. Also the art was entirely redone in the generic cartoony style of every other mobile RTS. I suppose it's more approachable than the original's 2000-era pixeliness, but it didn't seem like an improvement to me. It's still better than 99% of all mobile games, but that's not saying much. The original is on Steam for $10 including the expansion and various bugfixes; I played it through again last year and I think it still holds up wonderfully. http://store.steampowered.com/app/25990/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/25990/
- Fordrus 10y agoI LOVED Majesty, getting high level wizards was my favorite thing, and could honestly be quite tricky considering how blatantly suicidal they often were. XD The saddest part was encountering enemy units who had magic reflection.
- dri_ft 10y agoDungeon Keeper used to play quite a lot like this as well. It was an interesting aspect that set it apart from other strategy games that were around at the time.
- digi_owl 10y agoYep. You needed imps to dig out rooms, reinforce walls, and carry corpses (turned into zombies or something in the graveyard room) and loot (used to pay of your other monsters and cast spells, iirc) back to your dungeon. You could do things like pick up imps to make them prioritize a task, or slap them to make the work faster (took a slice of health out of them though).
- lijason 10y agoEvil Genius is similar in spirit to Dungeon Keeper and a fantastic game as well.
- digi_owl 10y agoOh dear deity i had forgotten about that one. I seem to recall now that one of the ways you could torture a captured agent was by having him being squeezed by moving bookshelves or something...
- disantlor 10y agoYour comment made me think of neural nets. My knowledge is admittedly quite surface level but there seems to be an analogy to the emergent behavior of trained network. Also, I'm thinking about the recent (latest?) SimCity with it's much discussed ability to track each individual actor, which apparently became a computational crutch that limited the size of the cities you could build. It seems like there are some interesting game mechanics possible (as you suggest) that could also benefit from the recent GPU enhancements for neural nets.
- fleetfox 10y agoInteresting point but it's not exclusive to Dwarf Fortress there is a whole category of this kind of (management, simulation) games from SimAnt to Football Manager.
- samstave 10y agoHeh, we used to call some of these games "managing a spreadsheet" -- Specifically the "Masters of Orion" series
- codesforhugs 10y agoAurora 4X is almost literally that, but a very interesting take on the epic space 4X nonetheless.
- vvillena 10y agoThe first one is pretty approachable. The hardware constraints of its time made the game very focused in comparison to other 4X games.
- samstave 10y agoHave you ever played the game "Knights and Merchants" (1997) -- it was such a fun game, as you had your little serfs who had to do all the work, but you also had your little armies that you could fight another player with. The AI was flawed, the serfs, once the population got to around 100 or so, would starve to death frequently as they couldnt figure out how to get to the inn to get food and drink... It was especially fun and funny when playing against a friend in the same room, you've built your village to the point where youre able to raise an army to smite your foe - but the AI goes bonkers, the serfs start to die off and your economy is ruined to the point that even two soldiers can show up and raze your entire town... Ill never forget the laughter we had at one's serf's death knell "HNUUGGGHHHH" as they die, and the giddy feeling you had if you could take them out with just a few soldiers. http://www.knights.de/ http://www.knights.de/
- Thiez 10y agoThere is a remake with an improved AI and online multiplayer! If you're interested: http://www.kamremake.com/ http://www.kamremake.com/ it's free, but you need to have the original game to play the remake (which you can buy on steam, if I recall correctly).
- samstave 10y agoi now have a mac........... i think you get my point
- snikeris 10y ago> It's a fascinating difference in paradigm, and I wish more games would explore the idea of actors in the world being chaotic/free agents which will only somewhat prioritize your wishes. Check out Banished.
- willismichael 10y agoI really wanted to love banished, and I did love it for a while, but I found that once you learn how to create a stable town, you can apply almost the exact same strategies in every single game played no matter what the land looks like, as well as every time you branch off to expand an existing town into a new piece of land. The mods didn't really do anything for me either, I felt like they just increased complexity and unbalance without really adding challenge or fun. I haven't ever actually played dwarf fortress, but from what I've read, the inherent unpredictability of the world, your dwarves, and other creatures seems like nothing that any other game can even dream of.
- otterpotter 10y agoPlus the AI in Banished liked to screw you over, and not because it was trying to help. When one villager is dying from cold and just needs a single piece of firewood, another villager will take the last 10 from the stockpile and hide it in their house. Never trust your neighbors.
- JoeDaDude 10y agoSeveral of Peter Molyneaux's [1] games have a similar mechanic where you set conditions for independent agents to (hopefully) do what you need done (My experience was playing Populous II Trials of the Gods [2]). His most recent creation, Godus [3], also uses this scheme. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Molyneux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Molyneux [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populous_II:_Trials_of_the_Olympian_Gods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populous_II:_Trials_of_the_Oly... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godus
- vidarh 10y agoThe first Populous game did that too. It's very simplistic in Populous, though - it's mostly about flattening terrain so they can build or calling them to battle and helping them by smiting your opponents in various ways, and their actions are similarly basic. Then again given the machines it ran on, it's not unsurprising.
- khalilravanna 10y agoBlack and White stands as one of my favorite games of all time for this reason. I'd argue it was the pinnacle of this behavior as far as Molyneux's games go because of the creature. It had a sophisticated AI that enabled it to actually be taught what was good and what was bad through experience. If it ate a villager you smacked it around and it'd learn it shouldn't do that. If it helped water your crops then you'd rub its belly and it'd know to do more of that. It was especially interesting because in order to train the creature what behavior was or wasn't desired you had to catch them in the act doing that thing. Since the creature was an independent actor who you could only influence, you had to rely on the randomness of the AI to do certain things so you could teach them what was good and what was bad. E.g. you can't teach it eating villagers is bad unless you catch them in the act and smack them around. Such a shame they almost completely did away with that teaching-through-doing part of creature-training in favor of simplifying down the creatures behaviors to basically sliders like "good vs bad" and "friendly vs aggressive" in BW2. Still waiting on a proper spiritual successor to BW1... what a brilliant game.
- 10y ago
- whatever_dude 10y agoI think it's kind of a spectrum of emergent gameplay. There are games with more than that than others, depending on how detached your commands are from the actual action that is taken.
- aero142 10y agoThere is a great and popular game called Rimworld[http://store.steampowered.com/app/294100/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/294100/] that does this. It's a colony management game where the default mode is colonists acting according to priorities and rules you set. You can override if you want but you quickly realize this is only for rare situations. It's really a fun game and a much easier learning curve than Dwarf Fortress.
- intended 10y agoMost games have a smaller learning curve than dwarf fortress. That's also the point. Dwarf fortress is actually a good study on community structuring via challenge based gating. Before the many tutorials, if you could hack df or aurora, you were a particular type of gamer, and the challenge itself was the fun. I really wish people could know themselves through the game the way I got to.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoI play both, and the communities are wonderful places to have mainstream-unbiased discussion about games and game mechanic. I'm not playing that much these days but I still frequent bay12 other games section, it's the best source for opinionated discussions about games
- taliesinb 10y agoYes. Over Christmas period I played 88 hours of RimWorld, says Steam. It is a degradingly addictive game. Edit: and I'm not a gamer.
- y4mi 10y agonow that is an expensive 2d game. holy shit.
- 1_player 10y agoI downvoted you. £23 for a game actively developed, with great replayability, tons of mods, a passionate fan base and community? Holy shit, that's a bargain.
- kruhft 10y agoDungeon Keeper was like this as well, except, IIRC where you could cast a spell and go into first person mode with a specific character for some time.
- lutorm 10y agoThe Close Combat series is entirely based on this idea. You give commands to squads, but the individual soldiers respond to the conditions on the battlefield, the orders they have being but one part of that.
- digi_owl 10y agoYeah i remember that one. You could order a squad to move somewhere only to find them hunkering down behind a wall or something because they were afraid that some sniper was out there. I think the map was even "deformable" in that if you ordered a tank to move somewhere it could break down walls and such to get there, walls that soldiers could have used as cover while moving around etc. Note though that the graphics was top down 2D, so it was "cheap" to replace a standing wall tile with a broken one.
- douche 10y agoClose Combat is one of my favorite series ever. The morale and fatigue mechanics were some of the best I've ever seen. And the graphics were fantastic for the time, really excellent aerial photography-inspired hand-made maps and sprites. There was nothing like setting up a textbook ambush, and then having your inexperienced gunner on an MG42 panic and run off when you gave the order to fire...
- poisonarena 10y agoI remember buying Close Combat a Bridge too far at Virgin Records many many years ago. All those bright red and blue tracer lines suppressing my units and launching fog. I remember how underwhelming the tanks felt sometimes
- lutorm 10y agoIt's been a couple of years now, but I still load up A Bridge Too Far every now and then! It's the only 20-year old game I know that's still fun. It's getting hard to run on current machines, though, with its hard-coded screen sizes and a scroll speed that's unusably fast.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoWhy not both? For example, the game of Risk where each battle is a game of Starcraft, and then Call of Duty at an even lower level. Maybe different players play the role of general or soldier etc.
- vtange 10y agoThe original Tropico game from the series somewhat felt like this, especially when it came to construction. Unless you were cheating, you could only declare where a building would be built - you had no power to instantly "plop" a building into existence - you had to then wait for your builder units to eat, sleep, get to the site and build. It made you careful in where you place things. Placing an airport far from home? Good luck building that!
- derefr 10y ago> Placing an airport far from home? Good luck building that! Would you have to first build a road out there with public transit service stops, and then bootstrap an increasingly-large set of airport hotels for the work crew to stay at, before attempting the airport itself? If so, that sounds like my kind of game.
- speeder 10y agoMore or less that, yes. To make large buildings in distant places you would build roads, then work crew related buildings, then whatever you wanted, including the needed housing for the new city area you ended creating in the process. Another interesting game is knights and merchants, armies are under your direct control but require supplies, that need to be physically carted off to them, so you needed to either use hit and run tactics, or build infrastructure near the frontlines. Also traffic in that game can literally kill you, as your badly designed city becomes so inefficient that people die of starvation.
- IgorPartola 10y agoSettlers is like that too! Oh the memories.
- 0xcoffee 10y agoI recently went on a hunt to find a game similar to the old Settler series, and found a game called Banished, where you have manage a small town against the elements. I put 10 hours into it so far and really enjoy it, check it out if you haven't already.
- clarry 10y agoOf course you can still buy the old Settlers games. Or check out Widelands, a free Settlers-like game.
- SN76477 10y agoI believe that we will see more games that have AI-ish systems. Randomization in games like Don't Starve is one of the mechanics that keeps the game going.
- newobj 10y agoWell, I certainly think the Sims did that, to tremendous success.
- erikb 10y agoActually in the year 2017 there are loads of games with this indirectness, even quite a few new ones. Google it and you'll find quite a few interesting ones. E.g. gnomoria, or prison architect.
- otterpotter 10y agoThis. There are plenty of games based on Dwarf Fortress and indirectness, though many of them seem to suffer from lack of depth. DF is nearly endless in terms of new content and events; once you figure out a pattern for setting up your fortress and finally feel like you're winning, something new comes along that you didn't expect. Once that feeling of "anything could happen" is lost in a game, it's tough to continue. Factorio is a good example of this. It satisfies the desire for challenge and survival like DF, but the challenge drops off drastically once you have a good setup. It's tough to match the content of Dwarf Fortress for a game that hasn't been around for 15 years though.
- erikb 10y agoYes, this lack of depth is really hard to take as a fan. But of course most of them are professional works not life long works of art.
- hyperion2010 10y agoI had hoped that this is what Spore was going to be like. I guess the good news is that I discovered Dwarf Fortress and thus have spent the rest of my gaming life quite happy. Remember kids losing is fun [0]! 0. http://dwarffortresswiki.org/images/4/40/FunComic.png http://dwarffortresswiki.org/images/4/40/FunComic.png
- WillyOnWheels 10y ago> It's a fascinating difference in paradigm, and I wish more games would explore the idea of actors in the world being chaotic/free agents which will only somewhat prioritize your wishes. Sounds like current config management software
- sushid 10y agoSticking to your StarCraft example, the Total War series is a good example of a "declarative" game. You can initially start ordering your troops to engage costly battles, but as their morale falls, they'll be less committed to an engagement and may rout (fall back) without being told to do so.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThe main reason I've pointedly avoided trying Dwarf Fortress is that it feels like a game where you can get noticeably better results through micromanagement than through high-level management. (For instance, "something bad would happen to that dwarf, but I can avoid it by reassigning that dwarf to different tasks".)
- rhlala 10y agoThats an interesting point, I think DF is more macro than you seems to think, Micro is limited at dwarf profession (you can set profesions fixes, or by skill level) Another great game was Banished, i tried when it just came out, It is still updated by developers?
- joshvm 10y agoKingdom is a beautiful game which is declarative. You run around on your (asthmatic) horse marking where you want buildings and your peasant workforce struggles to build them. It works well, but the rules are almost too simple. "Winning" the game is easy, but if you make one single wrong decision e.g. marking a wall for rebuilding at the wrong time of day your entire fortress will collapse. I believe some issues were fixed in Kingdom: New Lands, but it was a bit of a stain on an otherwise lovely game. At least in DF, usually it's your fault when things get Fun. For example, in Kingdom, you get more minions buy throwing gold to beggars. There are spawn points on either side of the map. Your fortress is symmetric and you can also pay for tools like bow/arrows or hammers. There's a tool collection point on either side of the centre. One rule you figure out in Kingdom is that minions pick up the first available tool they come across. That means that if you want archers, but you have a hammer waiting pickup (and your new recruits come from the wrong side of the map), you're going to get an engineer. Watchtowers are automatically restaffed by your soldiers. Watchtowers cannot be destroyed. If you overextend and build towers too far away from your castle, then you'll enter a vicious circle where your new archers will immediately go to man the towers and die when the hoarde arrives. As the towers are always there, and you can't mark them for demolition, it's possible to get into a situation where you can't resupply faster than your men run to their deaths.