3 ms·
I do own and build drones, and intend to use and sell them for commercial purposes. I totally support this severity of sentence, and would support an even hars
by toss1 10y ago
I do own and build drones, and intend to use and sell them for commercial purposes.
I totally support this severity of sentence, and would support an even harsher one.
This guy was a complete idiot, flying with zero regard for any potential consequences. Not only could someone get hurt, they did. Could just as easily have been killed, just for this bad operator's amusement.
Multirotor drones are inherently unstable. They cannot fly without a computer actively controlling every rotor on millisecond time scales. There are literally hundreds of items that can fail on the device that will instantly turn it into a falling brick with sharp edges (yes, I've counted them in a spreadsheet, and was astonished at the high number of potential failure points, an order of magnitude more than we expected).
Once one of those items fails, it will accelerate downwards at 9.8 meters per second per second. Physics does not care about our intentions or sentiments. From 120 feet up it will land at 60 miles/hr, from 335 feet it'll hit at over 100 mph. Even a lightweight 2-3 Lb drone would kill at those speeds.
The penalties for me driving by you at 60mph and tossing out a hard 2Lb object that happened to hit your head would be much more severe.
Just because it is sold in the toy aisle does not mean that casual or stupid operation should be tolerated. This 'operator' was an idiot, hurt somebody, deserved all he got, and he's making it much more difficult for responsible people to use these devices.
If you intend to operate these things, please be very aware of where it is going and all potential flight paths and potential falling paths. It isn't that difficult to simply do full pre-flight system checks, not fly over people or other valuable things, and take other safety measures.
(also, re. your point about restitution, he might prefer 30 days in jail to paying the hospital bills, lost pay, lost time, etc. as restitution, tho I'd argue for both)
edit: clarity, typos
- pc86 10y agoSlightly off-topic question but is a 2 pound drone capable of traveling 100mph in freefall? What determines/is its terminal velocity? As for the medical bills there is another hearing to determine how much he will need to pay the victim. I'd certainly argue for 100% of everything such that financially it's like it never happened.
- jsight 10y agoMy <.5 lb drone certainly has a terminal velocity that is well below 100mph. I've seen videos of similar ones free falling and crashing with virtually no damage to the drone itself, because the terminal velocity is relatively low. OTOH, the parent post appears to be someone who builds his own. Some race drones would likely have fairly impressive terminal velocities due to their compact, dense frames. I'm not sure what a common commercial one would fall like (Phantom, Mavic Pro, etc).
- leephillips 10y agoThe terminal velocity of a baseball is about 95 MPH. I'm guessing this drone's T.V. is at least somewhat smaller.
- pc86 10y agoA baseball is about a third of pound and relatively compact. This drone weighs something like 6-7x as much and has a lot more surface area and very different drag coefficients. I'm not sure there's really any comparison to be made.