4 ms·
I have no idea what the allegations made against Singhal are, or whether there is any veracity to them, but I do know that if we treat allegations as a guilty v
by oh_sigh 10y ago
I have no idea what the allegations made against Singhal are, or whether there is any veracity to them, but I do know that if we treat allegations as a guilty verdict, then allegations, whether honest or not, become an extremely powerful, career ending strike against someone.
I understand why Uber would drop him, even if just for PR purposes, but I'm curious why a forum which is so concerned with upholding of classic American values(as discussed during the recent Trump EO banning certain people from certain states) would be willing to dismiss another American virtue: innocent until proven guilty.
- jordanlev 10y agoHe resigned. So for whatever reason, he agreed to leave of his own volition. Whether that's because he is actually guilty of the accusations and knows it, or the CEO forced him to for publicity reasons (or both)... who knows. But nobody has been branded officially "guilty" of a crime in terms of the American legal system.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoHe resigned before being dismissed by Google according to the article.
- oh_sigh 10y agoMost people on the McCarthy era hollywood blacklist were not found guilty of anything - only accusations, and I don't recall a lot of people defending that episode.
- epistasis 10y ago>but I do know that if we treat allegations as a guilty verdict Your comment is extremely off base. In additions to an allegation we have: 1) An investigation that found the allegations "credible." 2) A resignation that appears to be because of these allegations, in an attempt to avoid the allegations and investigation coming to light. 3) A failure to disclose these circumstances to a new employer. While that might be fine for somebody not in a leadership position, for somebody at the SVP level, come on.
- oh_sigh 10y ago1) What were their standards for finding it 'credible'? If you concede this point, you're basically giving unlimited authority to a completely unknown institution (whoever Google hires for these things?). 2) That's one possibility. Another possibility is not wanting to deal with it. So long as there isn't an admission of guilt, I'm not sure how the public can really know these things. 3) I agree with you 100% on this one, if it really happened. What if that itself is a cover. What if Travis hired Amit knowing that he had this potential blemish on his record, but hired him on the contingent that he may fire him immediately if it ever came to light?
- zigzigzag 10y agoOr maybe Singhal resigned because despite telling his management it was untrue, they didn't side with him despite his long term loyalty to the firm. If you feel you've built the company with your own hands, and then the firm institutionally closes ranks against you because of a false accusation (or that's how you perceive it), then you'd probably be very bitter and want to leave anyway.