3 ms·
Probably. It's basically a certain bet that anything you post here, the NSA can read, given that anything you post here, the entire Internet can read. But I t
by nostrademons 10y ago
Probably. It's basically a certain bet that anything you post here, the NSA can read, given that anything you post here, the entire Internet can read.
But I think most people overestimate how interesting they are. Hacker News is one forum on the Internet among literally millions. There are millions of other people who are also social libertarians, and millions of people worried about eroding digital rights. These characteristics do not make you interesting. Hell, digital rights in general are not that interesting to people in Washington - for the most part, our legislators vote the way that whichever lobbyist who last had their ear wants them to, and the American public just gets caught in the crossfire.
The folks that the NSA cares about are those that advocate violent overthrow of governments, or who are a credible threat to U.S. interests abroad. Hacker News readers, by and large, are not a credible threat; we talk, but few of us will get off our butts and do. And so we're just not important enough for the NSA to care.
- schoen 10y agoThat's a good argument, although "credible threat to U.S. interests abroad" is too narrow considering the degree to which allies and foreign political parties get spied on. A counterpoint: https://theintercept.com/document/2014/03/20/hunt-sys-admins/ https://theintercept.com/document/2014/03/20/hunt-sys-admins... (if you have access to other people's communications, or the ability to protect them more or less effectively or cause them to be protected more or less effectively, governments might be interested to the extent that they want to spy on other people)
- ejcx 10y agoThis is exactly right. There are a lot of forums higher on the NSA's list to target. This forum is (no offense fellow HN'ers) mostly just a bunch of angry startup people and tech news. I know for a fact many NSA employees read and enjoy participating on HN.
- remx 10y ago> I know for a fact many NSA employees read and enjoy participating on HN There's a few Palantir[0] employees here too, Palantir being one of the many tentacles of the NSA. Infact any contractor who does work for the NSA can be found lurking moar on HackerNews. If you do enough digging around you will find them. Palantir being the more obvious example. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies
- ejcx 10y agoPalantir is not a tentacle of the NSA. Not even close.
- remx 10y agoWell according to this Wikipedia piece[0] about the NSA and Palantir: A document leaked to TechCrunch revealed that Palantir's clients as of 2013 included at least twelve groups within the U.S. government, including the CIA, DHS, NSA, FBI, CDC From: http://techcrunch.com/2015/01/11/leaked-palantir-doc-reveals-uses-specific-functions-and-key-clients/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/01/11/leaked-palantir-doc-reveals... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies#cite_note-tebtecnchrun-27 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies#cite_not...
- eb0la 10y agoPlease be reasonable. Having NSA and several US agencies as customers doesn't mean you are a tentacle of the NSA. Even in the case of companies owned in part by In-Q-Tel I guess the point is to make their technology available to the US goverment. Maybe 20 years ago the goverment would fund that with DARPA or something similar, but now there is an open technology market and I guess they should be investing to get their opinion heard on the direction they need the technologies to evolve.
- stagbeetle 10y ago> Please be reasonable. Having NSA and several US agencies as customers doesn't mean you are a tentacle of the NSA. You could argue that any company that actively works with the NSA to increase their coverage is a tentacle.
- dsacco 10y agoThat's such a broad definition of "tentacle" it's meaningless. We all know what "tentacle" means in this context, and it's not satisfied just by being a government contractor or provider.
- rokhayakebe 10y agoBut I think most people overestimate how interesting they are. Gosh, thank you. I feel people here feel professionally more important than they actually are. I mean I am sure a forum of Lawyers, Physicists, Surgeons, Truck Drivers would feel just about the same.