4 ms·
From the article (emphasis mine): > “As I entered the fifteenth year of working at Google, I've been asking myself the question, ‘What would you want to do for
by koolba 10y ago
From the article (emphasis mine):
> “As I entered the fifteenth year of working at Google, I've been asking myself the question, ‘What would you want to do for the next fifteen?’ The answer has overwhelmingly been: Give back to others. It has always been a priority for me to give back to people who are less fortunate, and make time for my family amidst competing work constraints — but on both fronts, I simply want to give and do more,” he wrote. “Now is a good time to make this important life change.”
> But within a year, rather than do good, Singhal had gotten a top job at Uber.
There's nothing inherently "not good" with changing jobs. If anything, you get an opportunity to make more money, make a bigger impact on new projects, and bring in others that you've worked with prior to join you. The latter can markedly improve their lives as well through the same (pay bump, new work, etc).
Implying that leaving Google for Uber is inherently not "do[ing] good" is pretty slanted.
- sjbp 10y agoIn the time since he left Google, Amit did establish the Singhal Foundation[0] which focuses on education in India. [0]: www.singhalfoundation.org/about
- Kalium 10y ago> Implying that leaving Google for Uber is inherently not "do[ing] good" is pretty slanted. In some circles, some companies are inherently evil and "do[ing] good" seen as fundamentally incompatible with private enterprise. With that in mind, leaving Google for Uber and wishing to "do good" becomes the height of hypocrisy.
- SilasX 10y agoYes, but there's a standard meaning of "do good", which refers to philanthropic work, especially the kind with a managerial role in that very work. Certainly, there are ways to "do good" by optimizing your earnings and using them to bankroll the good, but then that no longer works as an explanation for leaving -- a different job in basically the same role would be the same "work constraint"; his MO for "doing good" would be unchanged, just with possibly a bigger source of income for it. His statement makes much more sense as a cover for the bad reasons, as when you hear "resigning to spend more time with his family [and totally not because of accounting fraud that we're still untangling]".
- ASinclair 10y agoHis statement implied he would do something along the lines of philanthropy, not Making the World a Better Place™.
- hallmark 10y agoGive me a break. When a successful tech executive says, "It has always been a priority for me to give back to people who are less fortunate," the Gates Foundation or the US Digital Service come to mind. Getting another highly paid job is not at all in the same class.
- koolba 10y ago> Give me a break. When a successful tech executive says, "It has always been a priority for me to give back to people who are less fortunate," the Gates Foundation or the US Digital Service come to mind. Getting another highly paid job is not at all in the same class. Says you. If you have the opportunity to make a bunch of money moving on to a new gig, hire your old co-workers, and work on new technologies like self driving cars[1], I'd say that's going to have a much larger impact than picking up a hammer and building houses Jimmy Carter style. Also, using the Bill Gates, who's probably 2+ orders of magnitude wealthier than Singhal, as a comparison point isn't fair either. [1]: Guessing on this one as I have no clue what projects he personally oversaw at Uber.
- vacri 10y ago> Also, using the Bill Gates, who's probably 2+ orders of magnitude wealthier than Singhal, as a comparison point isn't fair either. You don't have to be Gates-wealthy to be a philanthropist. Hell, I did some philanthropy when I was earning only $35k a year - I saved up $2k and sent out an invite to a dozen friends for them to do any short course of their choosing up to $150 and I'd pay for it. And that's small potatoes - there are thousands upon thousands of people out there working long-term as volunteers for good causes despite also being on or near minimum wage. The idea that philanthropy is only the domain of the ridiculously wealthy is just bizarre.
- koolba 10y agoI'm not saying you have to be Gates-wealthy to do philanthropy, I'm saying dropping your career to do nothing but philanthropy doesn't scale or sustain if you're significantly less wealthy.
- burkaman 10y ago> give back to people who are less fortunate > I want to give and do more > life change These are not descriptions of moving from Google to Uber. The quote obviously implies some kind of philanthropic activity, not just getting a different good job.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoBe careful, you're blurring the lines between "do good" and "do well".
- st3v3r 10y agoThere's nothing inherently "not good" with switching jobs, no. There's also nothing inherently "good" with switching jobs, either. It's at best a neutral action. However, given what he said he wanted to do, the argument is that he didn't do any of that, and just took the next job that came along. That the company he took the job with doesn't have the most ethically or morally clean reputation doesn't help the situation.