3 ms·
A much simpler theory that explains why the public doesn't trust public health pronouncements is that people have been both crying wolf in the doctor's name and
by jerf 17y ago
A much simpler theory that explains why the public doesn't trust public health pronouncements is that people have been both crying wolf in the doctor's name and declaring various unsafe things safe in doctor's names for a very long time now. The corruption of the doctor down the street may be a hobbyhorse of yours but I don't think that's what most people are thinking of when they consider a public health question; they're thinking about the fact that eggs are a mortal menace, then good for you, then eat the white but not the yolk, then eat the yolk but not the white, then good for you again, then a mortal menace, then good for you again. Then take that and multiply it across numerous issues.
Medical journalism's credibility is pretty low. (Although whether it is lower than journalism's in general I don't know... that's a high bar, or perhaps rather a low bar, to meet. And I don't mean that sarcastically, I mean that measured public trust in journalism is extremely low and sinking.) I don't think that has much to do with the stuff you talk about, which is not widely recognized.