6 ms·
I think there's a broader problem though -- the rigid coupling between a) whether you've published, and b) whether you've done something worthwhile, and c) the
by SilasX 10y ago
I think there's a broader problem though -- the rigid coupling between a) whether you've published, and b) whether you've done something worthwhile, and c) the minimal size of a publishable unit.
This forces scientists to "repurpose" the journal article to signal a lot more than "hey, we did this and something interesting is going on." Anyone who contributed wants to get their name on it, and the publication is viewed as some reward rather than a test of an ideas merit (as in the "we promise to publish even you're wrong", that you're describing).
I think it would be better if we had some fine-grained system for documenting everyone's contribution, like a git DAG. Then you could separate the question of "Alice collected this data" from "Bob proposed a great hypothesis about it" and "Charlie tried to replicate it" and "so-and-so has something publishable".