3 ms·
I agree with you, but this is the reality of it. I'd much rather kids have a censored version of this book than not have it at all, which is the choice we actua
by mikeash 10y ago
I agree with you, but this is the reality of it. I'd much rather kids have a censored version of this book than not have it at all, which is the choice we actually have given how most schools are run.
And it's not like the swearing is in any way essential to the work. You're not destroying a great work of literature by replacing "fuck" with "crap." So while I agree we shouldn't be so uptight about swears, I'd say we also shouldn't be so uptight about removing them here.
- abandonliberty 10y agoFirst they came for the swears . . . We should be very concerned about a precedent where we adapt or censor potentially objectionable content. Next is content not in alignment with the schools ideologies or politics, for what is essential to a work? These aren't abstract tin-foil hat concerns either: In 1982 Texas banned a geography textbook for mentioning evolution [1]. Publishers are financially incentivized to publish. These mechanisms enable those in power to control the information presented to children and students to suit their agendas (even while their own children attend private schools not subject to their decisions). >According to Time magazine, the list of the most banned books of all time include . . . “Brave New World,” by Aldous Huxley; “1984,” by George Orwell We should be pretty uptight about censorship. https://ncse.com/cej/3/4/censorship-evolution-texas https://ncse.com/cej/3/4/censorship-evolution-texas https://www.webjunction.org/documents/webjunction/Censorship_in_Schools_Learning_Speaking_and_Thinking_Freely_The_First_Amendment_in_Schools.html https://www.webjunction.org/documents/webjunction/Censorship... https://www.lehigh.edu/~infirst/bookcensorship.html https://www.lehigh.edu/~infirst/bookcensorship.html
- mikeash 10y agoThis is a standard slippery slope argument. Is there evidence that the slope is actually slippery? Do we know that removing swear words leads to ideological censorship?
- abandonliberty 10y agoSufficient evidence was presented to demonstrate a non-fallacious usage of the slippery slope argument. Simply because it's a slippery slope argument doesn't make it fallacious - though such accusations are very good at silencing. Perhaps you can provide an example where increases in censorship do not make it easier for the types of problems listed above to occur, a place where the misuse of power is unheard of. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope#Non-fallacious_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope#Non-fallacious_...
- mikeash 10y agoYour evidence only demonstrated the existence of the bottom of the slope.
- plussed_reader 10y agoI think you can see it in self censoring of kids and adults in modern day conversation. "The F word." "The N Word." "Eff that." "Effed in the A." "They want the D." "That scene was hot af." Pick a better word, or demonstrate your lacking vocabulary. But the self-censorship makes one sound like a tool. You'd get a better reaction saying, 'They want the orange dust-encrusted phallus.'