4 ms·
With modern technology, it's completely unacceptable for consumer electronics to catch fire when running it on a bedspread. It should shut itself down when it g
by mikeash 10y ago
With modern technology, it's completely unacceptable for consumer electronics to catch fire when running it on a bedspread. It should shut itself down when it gets too hot. Worst case, it might break due to being too hot, but it should never catch fire.
- raarts 10y agoI don't think anyone disagrees with you on this.
- SippinLean 10y agoApparently the parent comment does as it appears to be blaming the victim
- OopsieBadidea8 10y agoNo one knows if this was truly a defective battery before overheating. The way I read it: CPU gets hot, battery damage from overheating begins, computer shuts off. User turns it on again not knowing the state of the electronics inside. Possibly weakened or damaged electronics cause the battery to blow up. Bad ventilation weakens electronics and continued use causes catastrophic failure. This is not new.
- mikeash 10y agoThe electronics shouldn't allow the computer to be turned back on if it's too hot. If they did, it's the fault of the electronics, not the user.
- spronkey 10y agoIt is highly unlikely that thermal runaway was caused by the computer overheating. It's far more likely that a defect in the battery caused this. Perhaps the laptop tried to draw too much power from the battery, and it failed.
- vlunkr 10y agoWell it did shut down according to the article, but it was probably too late.
- dx034 10y agoBecause the heat came from the battery, not the CPU. If you just block ventilation, most modern computers/laptops won't break. I had a fan problem with my computer a couple weeks back, it just shut down at some point and didn't switch on again (until it was cool enough). No damage to the CPU or any other component. But if the battery creates the heat, the sensors for CPU temp will react too late.
- bobthedino 10y agoThere are sensors for battery temperature: my 2011 MacBook Pro appears to have two battery temperature sensors and a battery charger temperature sensor. It's quite possible that in this case the System Management Controller detected the overheating battery and shut down the computer - I'm not an expert on Mac hardware, though.