3 ms·
You literally said "The more subtle problem is that in some circles, it isn't even that....it's a blanket pass." It's right up there!
by mattkrause 10y ago
You literally said "The more subtle problem is that in some circles, it isn't even that....it's a blanket pass." It's right up there!
- caseysoftware 10y agosome !== general I'm happy to argue my own points but you misrepresenting them into strawmen isn't productive.
- mattkrause 10y agoSorry! I'm not trying to, but I'm also not sure how else to interpret them. As I said, I'm willing to believe that papers occasionally slip through the cracks (the arsenic life thing from 2011 could have been caught in review, for example), but the idea that a decent number of papers papers just slide through the peer review process is totally unlike the experience I've had with my own and my friends' and colleagues' papers.