9 ms·
This is a bit of a tangent, but I find it really bizarre that a site which says it's "championing freedom, smaller government" is so stridently against same-sex
by mikeash 10y ago
This is a bit of a tangent, but I find it really bizarre that a site which says it's "championing freedom, smaller government" is so stridently against same-sex marriage.
I can only conclude that some people have a radically different idea of "freedom" and "smaller government" than I do.
Bringing it back to the original topic a bit, it's sad that people's reactions are so predictable. People in favor of same-sex marriage think this study is great. People who oppose it think it sucks. How boring! Show me someone in favor of same-sex marriage who thinks this study is terrible, or someone against who thinks the study is really good.
- lisper 10y ago> some people have a radically different idea of "freedom" and "smaller government" than I do Or they are not acting in good faith.
- M_Grey 10y ago"Freedom" means, The freedom to harm others, the freedom to be the undisputed top of the political and social food chain, and the freedom to maintain that position at any cost. They want the freedom to limit the freedom of others. They see no problem with that at all.
- willvarfar 10y agoWas that not the 'freedom' the Pilgrim Fathers were chasing too?
- M_Grey 10y ago100%, absolutely, yes yes yes. Fortunately most of us aren't descended from those antisocials who were too unpleasant for period Britain to tolerate.
- judah 10y ago>> "I can only conclude that some people have a radically different idea of "freedom" and "smaller government" than I do." Small government conservative here. It's actually pretty simple: Small government: the government should stop meddling in marriage altogether. It's a social and often religious institution. Freedom: We take seriously the founders' belief that government should not infringe on religious liberty.
- mikeash 10y agoThey're not arguing that government should get out of the marriage business. I've seen that sentiment before and it's totally consistent. I might even agree with it. But these people here are arguing stridently for government-endorsed traditional marriage, and against same-sex marriage, all while having that tagline at the bottom of every page.
- sremani 10y agoNation-States life is tied to babies and for now only Heteros make babies, even the gay babies. So, there is inherent interest for any Nation state to promote hetero sex and by its extension hetero-marriages (without relying on government funding for childcare).
- mikeash 10y agoModern medical technology, or even just extramarital sex, make this bad reasoning.
- sremani 10y agoWhat about modern medical technology? how many people of the 3,978,497 of people born in US in year 2015 were born out of this modern technology ? Now if we extend that to world, that is hundreds of millions of babies. My comment was neutral about gay marriage. I was trying to tie the relationship between demographics and Nation-States and why hetero-sex is mostly overlook but important ingredient. May be in the future each of us get to have clone armies and designer babies, I do not know. But to pretend Sexuality and its outcomes have no bearing in Life and Destiny of a Nation to me is laughable.
- mikeash 10y agoDid you miss the middle part of my reply? The only technology you fundamentally need is enough alcohol for the involved parties to have sex against their preference.
- Tharre 10y ago> Stream offers a rich and lively source for breaking news, Christian inspiration and conservative commentary Seems religiously motivated to me, as you'd expect. Nothing extraordinary.
- mikeash 10y agoNothing says religious people can't be honest about their motivations. If they wish to enshrine their religious rules into law, they could say so.
- Tharre 10y agoI don't know what you're referring to, they do tell you all the time. "It's unnatural!", is probably the most common argument against same-sex marriage, and can only refer to the "natural" marriage depicted in the bible (or koran, or whatever, you get the point). Of course they also invent other reasons, and bend the facts to fit their views. But everybody does that, it's just human nature.
- mikeash 10y agoIn my brief perusal of the site's articles on marriage, I didn't see any religious arguments put forth. Please understand, I'm not attempting to make a general argument about every single person opposed to same-sex marriage. I'm specifically discussing the attitudes of stream.org, and by extension other people who hold a similar "freedom, small government, and no same-sex marriage" attitude.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patrickg_zill 10y agoThe possible answer to your view/question could be that there is a difference between "liberty" as a goal and "libertinism". Liberty in this sense as used by the site you mention, includes certain responsibilities, while the libertine is unrestrained or free of responsibility.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't understand how that answers it. How does that make "government oversight of marriage in a way that restricts who can get married" consistent with "freedom" and "smaller government"?
- patrickg_zill 10y agoI don't say this is my perspective, but I believe that the authors of the site would point to this short speech by Alan Keyes as a quick explanation... or at least, agree with it. Sorry for bad formatting, I am on my phone. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KrD8zvCUtWc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KrD8zvCUtWc
- mikeash 10y agoThat might explain why one would consider "marriage" to only be between a man and a woman, but it doesn't do anything to explain how legally enforcing that is somehow compatible with "freedom" and "smaller government."
- quasse 10y agoI think the final answer to your question might be that they're going to argue you in circles using irrelevant tangents until you get tired and stop challenging them.
- patrickg_zill 10y agoI can't give a good answer on that. I was merely giving you some background details on the alternative perspective to yours.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ckozlowski 10y agoIt's sometimes said that the Puritans coming to the colonies were not fleeing repression and seeking freedom, but seeking freedom to repress others.
- cookiecaper 10y ago>I can only conclude that some people have a radically different idea of "freedom" and "smaller government" than I do. Smaller government would be a government that does less stuff, grants status to fewer people, etc. Marriage is a legal construct that allows a couple to receive special status from the state. Same-sex marriage advocates are in favor of the government extending the benefits of that special status to an additional class of relationships. It's consistent with small government platforms to be suspicious of such expansions, regardless of one's feelings about the independent merits of the arrangement. Hypothetically, one could be the largest advocate of permanent same-sex coupling while simultaneously believing that the government doesn't need to expand the definition of marriage to include them under its umbrella. Not trying to drag this out, but no one has really said this yet. Opposing the expansion of marriage is consistent because expanding government is always met with suspicion by small government advocates.
- mikeash 10y agoSure, one could be opposed to extending the legal definition of marriage based on small-government principles, but then consistency would also demand that one be opposed to legal recognition of marriage at all. That is manifestly not the case for this site or many others.
- cookiecaper 10y ago>Sure, one could be opposed to extending the legal definition of marriage based on small-government principles, but then consistency would also demand that one be opposed to legal recognition of marriage at all. No, consistency wouldn't demand that. Small government people are not automatically "no government" people. I'm saying it's natural for them to be skeptical of the expansion of services to cover new arrangements. That's government growth; small government people are likely to take a default dubious position for almost all forms of government growth/expansion, but that doesn't mean they have to oppose every function the government currently performs. That'd make them anarchists, not conservatives. So when someone says "I want to expand a government-granted status to a new thing", the natural small government reaction is "You better have a very compelling case, because we hate the words 'expand a government-granted status'". Going beyond this, we get into an argument on the details of same-sex marriage, and this is neither the time nor the place for that, but the point is that it is conventional for a small government proponent to view proposals to expand a longstanding legal tradition with suspicion, without necessarily requiring them to be hostile to that legal tradition as it stands. Pretending like this doesn't make sense is creating a false dichotomy. The choice doesn't have to be between "same-sex marriage" or "no marriage" to be internally consistent.