6 ms·
In 2007 I crossed the border on bus going from Montreal to NY. The girl I was travelling with was accused of illegal importation of fruits because she was carry
by pier25 10y ago
In 2007 I crossed the border on bus going from Montreal to NY. The girl I was travelling with was accused of illegal importation of fruits because she was carrying an apple for the trip.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoWhat happened to her?
- jknoepfler 10y agoA minor delay and a confiscated piece of fruit, most likely.
- pier25 10y agoYes, that was it.
- areyousure 10y agoNot your parent commenter, but I was on a bus once from Toronto to NYC. One of my fellow passengers had a coconut confiscated at the border. We all felt sorry for him, but when he got back on the bus, he pulled out a second coconut from his coat. :) More interesting, my neighbor on that bus ride did not possess a passport nor even a photo ID! He was Amish and had no problems crossing the border. His papers (which I examined) included a handwritten description of his appearance.
- wyldfire 10y agoIt might seem silly to you but I think that the import controls to protect domestic agriculture make sense and preventing unintentional/incidental imports like this one is an important part of CBP's job. They should spend more time on this and less time on rejecting visitors to the US. Unfortunately government employees can be remarkably bureaucratic and power trip. They should quarantine or destroy incidental contraband like individual apples and let people get on with their business.
- jacquesm 10y ago> It might seem silly to you No, it IS silly. People carry little bits of food with them to eat while traveling, they've been doing that as long as there have been people. Clearly this has nothing to do with importing apples at a level with which the border patrol needs to be concerned, it's just some lowlife official flexing his/her muscle.
- jff 10y agohttp://jenny.tfrec.wsu.edu/opm/displaySpecies.php?pn=140 http://jenny.tfrec.wsu.edu/opm/displaySpecies.php?pn=140 They're not asking about fruit because they're worried you may sell that single apple and drive a farmer out of business. The spread of agricultural pests and diseases is a major problem.
- jacquesm 10y agoOf course that apple will end up carrying a scary agricultural pest from Canada to the USA. Really, this is totally over the top. It's not like we're talking about a an apple that you couldn't buy on either side of the border without any differences whatsoever. And it could easily be that that apple was produced in the USA to begin with (or further South). From a pest spreading perspective this makes no sense. Going through the Southern barricade on foot I could see the point, going from Canada into the USA by bus with an apple it makes zero sense, especially since the pest you so helpfully linked here is widespread on both sides of the border anyway, besides the fact that it was extremely unlikely to carry that particular pest since it was sold as fit for consumption. Or did you feel that because it came from Canada that there was some terrible risk that would not have been present had it come from any one of the other 49 states?
- mthoms 10y agoAre you arguing that agricultural controls at land border crossings are ineffectual and should be dismantled? That seems to go against (what appears to be) global scientific consensus that controls like these are helpful in slowing the spread of invasive species. Or are you just arguing there should be exemptions for small amounts?
- pvaldes 10y agoThe problem is that an apple carrying a new disease across the frontier can be the difference between having millions of loses in agriculture or not. Believe it or not, their economic impact is far much worse than carrying a bag of drugs or a bomb. The solution is easy in any case.