7 ms·
Remember the discovery of Neptune? I mean, not directly, since everyone from that time is dead, but.... That's a nice example of a prediction being wrong, inve
by mikeash 10y ago
Remember the discovery of Neptune? I mean, not directly, since everyone from that time is dead, but....
That's a nice example of a prediction being wrong, inventing an as-yet-unobserved chunk of matter to fix it, and that invention then being correct.
Of course, there's a counter-example in the inner solar system in the form of Vulcan. It was invented to explain Mercury's orbit, but the solution ended up being Relativity. So it's not always the right answer.
If you want examples involving entirely new classes of matter, I believe neutrons and neutrinos would fit the bill. Both were invented to explain discrepancies in theories well before they were directly observed.
Remember that coming up with a new type of matter is a form of fixing the model. The model is, essentially, "what does the universe actually look like?" If adding a new type of matter gets you closer, then that's fine. If changing the equations works better, then that's fine too.
Remember that dark matter isn't just some arbitrary fudge factor that gets inserted into the observations to make the numbers come out right. It is a comprehensive theory that allows for observations and predictions. No, nobody knows just what it actually is, but there's a great deal of evidence that there is a lot of "stuff" in the universe which interacts gravitationally but not in other ways.
I see this sentiment a lot, and I'm not sure that dark matter skeptics understand just how much supporting evidence there is for dark matter, or just how difficult it is to "fix Newton." People have been trying real hard for a long time, and nobody has been able to come up with anything like a coherent modification of gravitation that explains the observations.
- corey_moncure 10y ago>particles invented before being directly observed as support of dark matter hypothesis Correct me if I'm wrong, which is quite likely, but isn't it one of the qualities ascribed to dark matter that it doesn't interact with 'ordinary' matter or photons in any way other than gravity, and therefore can't be directly observed? Or to turn the question around, is the dark matter hypothesis actually falsifiable?
- mikeash 10y agoIt obviously doesn't interact with ordinary matter very much, or else it would have been observed non-gravitationally by now. It could interact a little bit, though. Consider neutrinos: they almost don't interact with ordinary matter at all, but they can be observed with enough patience and care, and they are definitely real. Neutrinos were actually an early candidate for dark matter. The numbers didn't work out, but it's an example of something that would interact weakly. And sure, dark matter is falsifiable. If observations are made where gravity appears to deviate from what's visible and can't be explained by adding invisible mass, that would falsify it. Or if someone finally comes up with a change to the known laws of physics which explains the observations better than dark matter does, that would do it. Remember, nothing is truly "directly observed." All we can do to observe stuff is to see how it affects other stuff. Whether it's with photons or with gravity, it's all ultimately indirect.
- EGreg 10y agoHow do we know dark matter isn't just really transparent matter? Like, we can't see it in space but it's there, not reflecting or deflecting enough light for us to detect it.
- TheHegemon 10y agoLike some kind of dark matter?
- EGreg 10y agoJUST transparent to light and nothing more
- XorNot 10y agoBecause it would collide with itself. Dark matter isn't just "not visible" - it's non-electromagnetic. As observed it didn't aggregate when colliding with itself, so there aren't big dark matter made black holes around, nor gravity anomalies from dark matter nebula or the like. Two dark matter particles headed directly at each other would pass through each other and be only slightly deflected by their gravitational interaction.
- btilly 10y agoNot necessarily. Dark matter could be made of small dense objects. Because they are small, we wouldn't see absorption of light. And because they are small, they will very seldom collide. These kinds of object are called MACHOs. Based on observed dimming events while monitoring many stars, we have ruled out brown dwarfs as more than 20% of the total. Other possibilities still remain, but none have shown evidence of being sufficient to explain dark matter. However we have not ruled out the possibility of it being something that we haven't thought of yet.
- scatters 10y agoYes, that's what cosmologists mean by "dark": not interacting with light of any observable wavelength, to any detectable degree.
- T-A 10y agoThere is a (waning?) hope that dark matter interacts weakly with ordinary matter, which would make it detectable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weakly_interacting_massive_particles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weakly_interacting_massive_par...
- thechao 10y agoYou can observe it via gravitational lensing. For instance: http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2011/04/20/how-gravitational-lensing-show/ http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2011/04/20/how-gravi... .
- lngnmn 10y agoYou can observe nothing but the fact that mass distorts light. Everything else is imagination.
- chongli 10y agoWe can observe the effect of gravitational lensing. The claim that dark matter causes it is part of the same claim that dark matter is responsible for galactic rotation curves looking the way they do. Thus it does not provide any further support for the dark matter hypothesis.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 10y agoWe've seen instances already where gravitational lensing was explained through other means (very dim clusters, dust, and even camera issues), we also don't know if the space time on those scales is "smooth", if it isn't then light will not travel in a straight line which would account for the lensing effects. The spacetime curvature, mass/energy, and gravity have quite a few interesting interactions as in gravity as a force, vs gravity as a feature of spacetime, vs potential other forms of gravity. We aren't even sure at this point if a curved spacetime without mass/energy that would generate that curve, would actually produce gravity or not since we aren't able to observe this nor do we have a complete theory of gravity.
- XorNot 10y agoExcept we have good evidence that the universe is very close to flat, space-time wise. A hypothesis that there's local unexplained curvature...Well that's really what dark matter is all about. What's curving it?
- yk 10y agoThe dark matter hypothesis may not actually be falsifiable, however that is not what physicists are working on. Physicists work on dark matter models, precisely defined theories which incorporate dark matter and these are falsifiable. For example roughly ten years ago models of weakly interacting particles (that is, particles that interact via the weak force) were very popular, but they have a influence on the abundance on nucleons in the early universe. Turning the argument around, one gets a interaction probability of the particles, and that part of the parameter space was excluded a few years ago. (You can of course try to mask the signal, but then you are generating different models, the original very simple models were falsified.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 10y agoThat only is if dark matter is indeed "WIMPS" or weakly interactive massive particles. But then again there are multiple contenders for dark matter.
- wyager 10y agoThere are several ways that dark matter might exhibit detectable interactions. For example, it could undergo weak interactions with itself or with ordinary matter. (See WIMPs.) It could also undergo some antimatter-annihilation interaction, emitting e.g. a Z boson, which could decay to a detectable particle-antiparticle pair. We might be able to observe Z bosons from matter interactions decaying to dark matter pairs, which would manifest as an unexplained shortage of matter after a collision. We're still looking for any such interactions.
- zamalek 10y agoI am not a physicist. > Remember that dark matter isn't just some arbitrary fudge factor that gets inserted into the observations to make the numbers come out right. I look at dark matter/energy as a measurement of what we don't know - it is not necessarily matter or energy (although it could be). It is an effect or the sum of effects that we are not aware of. It's almost like the predictions that Mendeleev made with the periodic table. Personally, I don't like dark matter because my "hack" alarm bells start ringing. That being said, I also don't know what I don't know. > nobody has been able to come up with anything like a coherent modification of gravitation that explains the observations. There have been promising "non-matter" dark matter hypotheses[1], though these hypotheses seem to be quickly relegated to the disinterested bucket. In that way, it wouldn't hurt if slightly fewer eyes were looking at particle dark matter and slightly more at "non-matter" dark matter. [1]: https://phys.org/news/2016-11-theory-gravity-dark.html https://phys.org/news/2016-11-theory-gravity-dark.html
- breadbox 10y ago> I look at dark matter/energy as a measurement of what we don't know - it is not necessarily matter or energy (although it could be). Dark matter is called matter because it has mass, i.e. it experiences gravitational attraction to itself and to other forms of matter. Dark energy is called energy because it acts like radiation, i.e. it has negative pressure. > Personally, I don't like dark matter because my "hack" alarm bells start ringing. That being said, I also don't know what I don't know. Your second sentence is far closer to the mark than your first. Dark matter was indeed seen as a hack in the 1930s when it was first proposed, but there is now a large and remarkably consistent body of observations that show its presence. Here's one lay-friendly blog post that briefly describes some of the evidence: https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/why-dark-matter-9252bfa21a8a https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/why-dark-matter-9252bf... > In that way, it wouldn't hurt if slightly fewer eyes were looking at particle dark matter and slightly more at "non-matter" dark matter. It's kind of like quantum mechanics at this point. The only reason there aren't more eyes looking at alternatives to dark matter is because we already did that over the last few decades, and the evidence in favor of dark matter kind of became ridiculously overwhelming. If you want to float an alternative to dark matter at this point, you have to, at the very least, come up with a theory that explains all the things that dark matter explains. (Presumably you would also come up with something that dark matter doesn't explain that your theory does, but one thing at a time.)
- quantumhobbit 10y agoThe same thing happened in particle physics with neutrinos. There were two ways to get explain beta decay: conservation of mass is wrong, or pretend that the extra mass is carried away by an impossible to detect particle. It took decades for neutrinos to be actually detected.
- dogma1138 10y agoActually dark matter and dark energy are "fudge factors" that are being inserted in order to explain observations. There are multiple "contenders" for dark matter, none of them actually explain observations and measurements. Dark Energy is also in that same category especially in it's purest form as a "universal constant" that was added then removed then added back again to GR when we were sure if the universe is static, expanding at a constant pace or expanding under acceleration. As far as MOND goes the biggest "curiosity" people have with it is that it works at all, because it shouldn't, you shouldn't be able to just fudge so many factors and have a theory that works, is stable, and predictive (even tho it has various issues especially with regards to cosmology like star and cluster formations). Which might hint that there is actually something there. That gravity might not work in the same manner over distances, that maybe there is more than one gravity (there are hints that quantum gravity and what we call gravity might be different things already).
- danielweber 10y agoShouldn't there be a big lump of dark matter at the center of every planet, moon, and star? If we were to hollow out an asteroid, would there still be a blob of intangible dark matter inside of it?
- manigandham 10y agoWe don't know what dark matter is (including whether or not it's even matter).
- dogma1138 10y agoWhich type of dark matter would that be?
- wyager 10y agoNo, not if it's weakly interacting. Matter forms big balls because it collides with other matter and turns kinetic energy into heat. If dark matter is weakly interacting, it won't collide, so after falling into a star it will just shoot right back out the other side. It might form a stable orbit, but it also might just fly away and fall through some other gravity well. You can probably expect some bulk gravitational effects (e.g. Dark matter might tend to cluster along large matter distributions like galaxies), but in general it wouldn't be amenable to staying in one place.
- EGreg 10y agoIt seems a bit like Pilot Wave Theory. It postulates a wave in order to let regular mechanics apply to the quantum mechanical phenomena. Instead of postulating endless world-splitting or whatever.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> Of course, there's a counter-example in the inner solar system in the form of Vulcan. It was invented to explain Mercury's orbit, but the solution ended up being Relativity. So it's not always the right answer. If anything, the Vulcan hypothesis was not bold enough. It was a much greater leap of faith to assume that Newton's mechanics was just a low energy approximation, hence the twist in Mercury's orbit. Anyway, we don't really know what this whole dark matter business is, but for now the prevailing hypothesis is the dark-matter-as-a-new-type-of-particle. Of course, you're welcome to pursue a different line of thought, and let the truest hypothesis win. This is how science works.
- marcus_holmes 10y agoIt's how science works, but it's not how politics and human psychology work. Trying to get a paper published that directly contradicts the established theories is almost impossible because people don't like their life's work being thrown away as incorrect. This is why science advances one generation at a time.