5 ms·
It makes sense, I don't think anyone could realistically expect anything different. Considering it's basically a starting negotiating position, it's actually pr
by toyg 10y ago
It makes sense, I don't think anyone could realistically expect anything different. Considering it's basically a starting negotiating position, it's actually pretty good from my perspective (EU national who has formally been granted permanent residency by exercising his treaty rights).
Obviously the devil is in the details, i.e. what it will mean exactly "after the cutoff date": if one has lived in UK long enough to qualify for treaty-rights but never actually exercised them formally before the cutoff, can he still do it after that date? That's the situation most people are likely in, at the moment. A reasonable government would answer yes, of course, but recent news seem to indicate they are looking for any excuse to kick people out, so it's not a given.
If you are an EU citizen living in UK, you should absolutely ask to exercise your rights TODAY; do not delay, do not trust news reports, it's just a bit of bureaucracy but could make a big difference in your future. Make sure you send documents as recorded delivery and track each and every date.
If you are an EU citizen looking to move to the UK: just don't. This country has decided they don't need you and me, they don't deserve our labour, our ideas and our taxes.
- barrkel 10y agoMy perspective is a little bit different. If they want to kick me out, I'll go somewhere else. I am Irish; the probability is high that my nationality will be treated differently owing to history. But if they want me to ask to stay, they can go fuck themselves.
- toyg 10y agoI agree with your attitude in the long run (and am looking to move out myself), but in the immediate I think it's important for people to prepare so that they are not arbitrarily pressured into making immediate choices. Say you own a house, and the government says you don't have a right to live here anymore; you'll likely sell that house at a low price as you rush to relocate. History is full of this sort of profiteering following forced exodus (Spanish Jews, German Jews, Turkish Greeks and so on). If a bit if bureaucracy can save you from that, I think it's smart to do it.
- a3n 10y ago> (Spanish Jews, German Jews, Turkish Greeks and so on) And many more; as an American it immediately brings to mind WWII Japanese internment. Businesses and homes lost to pressure and profiteering as people were ripped out of society and dropped in open-air prisons.
- farbrortumm 10y ago"If they want me to ask to stay, they can go fuck themselves." Swede living in London here. I've got exactly the same opinion.
- kawsper 10y agoDane living in Nottingham here, I feel the exact same way. I am working remote, so my job moves with me, and it might be back home, hopefully with my british girlfriend :) but I fear the future, and how much bureaucracy we will face.
- alecco 10y ago> If they want to kick me out Did the article? This is about a cutoff date to stop a wave of last minute immigrants. Nothing about expelling current ones. Don't let clickbait headlines make you angry.
- kbart 10y ago"Nothing about expelling current ones. " Don't be so sure about that: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/feb/26/grandmother-deported-from-uk-despite-being-married-to-briton-for-27-years https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/feb/26/grandmother-...
- MLR 10y agoThis case is completely unrelated to the rights of EU citizens to live and work in the UK.
- ascorbic 10y agoThey probably won't be expelling anyone, but the UK government has explicitly said that they'll use the rights of EU citizens in the UK as a bargaining chip, so if I were an EU citizen in the UK I'd be worried.
- gadders 10y agoThey've explicitly said they don't want to use them as a bargaining chip, but would be foolish to give it up uniliaterally.
- raverbashing 10y ago> I am Irish; the probability is high that my nationality will be treated differently owing to history Yes, I think you're allowed to stay.
- CalRobert 10y agoBased on what exactly? If you have sources to cite there are many interested people. So far we've a general feeling of "people have been moving between these two countries freely since decades before the EU existed so they couldn't stop that... could they?" - could they? Then again, isn't the EU supposed to bargain as a block? Any firm comment on this by a party in a position to influence policy would be received with great interest.
- pjc50 10y agoIreland is a special case; the Ireland Act 1949 provides that "Ireland is not a foreign country", and the Good Friday Agreement requires an open border between Eire and NI. Like everything else, this is now subject to uncertainty. http://irishpost.co.uk/irish-government-attempts-calm-citizens-uk-ministers-refuse-guarantee-eu-nationals-rights-remain/ http://irishpost.co.uk/irish-government-attempts-calm-citize... (The possibility of NI rejoining Éire has now moved from "unthinkable" to "maybe". If a border gets imposed as part of Brexit that moves to "likely")
- ascorbic 10y agoThere hasn't been a word from the UK government about how this could be achieved. There seems to be no realistic way to retain an open border with the Republic of Ireland while not having an open border with the rest of the EU. The mythical Romanian could just fly to Dublin, drive to NI and catch a ferry. The only solution that I can see is to move the border to the North Sea. An open border with the Republic, but border controls between NI and GB. I imagine that will go down like a cup of cold sick with a good proportion of the population of NI.
- pjc50 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- MLR 10y agoIrish citizens in the UK hold a more favourable status than EU citizens as is, the likelyhood of this changing is practically nil.
- jaimebuelta 10y agoIt doesn't make sense at all. Until the end of the two years of the Article 50 negotiation (or before, if both the EU and the UK agree), the UK is a full member of the EU, with all the obligations that this entitles. That includes the right to live and work of citizens of other EU countries. Restricting that unilaterally is a gross violation of the treaties.
- dovdovdov 10y agoYeah, many things seem kinda bogus regarding this mess, even the PM herself.
- hackerboos 10y agoThey're not violating the treaties, they are saying if EU citizens come after a certain date then their residency is not guaranteed. EU citizens will be free to come right up until the UK exits the EU but those that came after said date will likely have to apply for visas. Those before will keep residency.
- dan1234 10y ago> If you are an EU citizen looking to move to the UK: just don't. This country has decided they don't need you and me, they don't deserve our labour, our ideas and our taxes. Well, 52% of the people who voted kinda, sorta said that. The rest of us are just being dragged along at the moment.
- yandie 10y ago> If you are an EU citizen living in UK, you should absolutely ask to exercise your rights TODAY; do not delay, do not trust news reports, it's just a bit of bureaucracy but could make a big difference in your future. Make sure you send documents as recorded delivery and track each and every date. Apparently my Dutch friend who has a PhD funded by the UK government can't apply for permanent residency because she doesn't earn enough to meet the £35k minimum earning set by the UK government. She's been here for almost 8 years. She's lucky that she's getting married and her now-fiance earns enough to make her qualify for spousal visa, but I know tons of others who are not so lucky.
- toyg 10y agoThat's wrong, the 35k threshold is for non-EU people only. I dearly hope she wasn't willingly misinformed by civil servants.
- phillc73 10y agoAnd I am pretty sure it isn't 35k, more like £18,600 without children. Nonetheless, any amount above £0 makes my life a misery. I'm British living in another EU country, with my non-EU spouse and British son. Who knows how my situation will resolve itself. This article holds out some olive branch of the offer of EU citizenship for people in my situation. However, let's play the hypothetical situation that I am forced to leave due to negotiation breakdowns or whatever. I return to the UK, right? Unfortunately, my wife can't join me until I already earn above about a £22k threshold (additional for child). It isn't that I don't believe I can earn that amount, it is the elapsed time and enforced separation. Maybe it takes me a couple of months to find a job, it will then probably take several months for my wife's Visa application to be processed (she's already randomly had one visitor visa application denied, which we appealed against and won, but it was a 12 month process). And what's her status in our current EU country of residence if I have returned to the UK? It's all a big old mess for those of us exercising our EU treaty rights.
- vilmosi 10y agoYour Dutch friend is misinformed. She doesn't need any earnings to apply for permanent residency (talking from experience).
- _yosefk 10y ago"This country has decided they don't need you and me, they don't deserve our labour, our ideas and our taxes." What about an EU citizen deciding to move to the US, Canada, Australia, Brazil or India? These countries were never in the EU. Did they therefore decide they don't need EU citizens? If not, why is the UK after it exits from the EU necessarily a less welcoming place for EU citizens than other non-EU countries?
- pavlov 10y agoThe United States is not a welcoming place for EU citizens. Immigration is strictly limited, the procedures expensive and time-consuming. If that's the bar for the UK government, the grandparent poster is right: it's not going to be worth even looking at Britain. To put it another way: if working in London, New York and San Francisco are going to be equally difficult to arrange, I'm not sure why anyone would prefer London. Housing is as expensive as NY or SF, yet wages are much lower. The weather isn't great either.
- _yosefk 10y agoThese can be valid points for some, and carry less weight for others (say, if you live in Paris and are offered a good job in London, and they help you deal with the visa stuff, for most it's probably also nice to be able to visit Paris much more easily than you could from NY or SF.) At any rate, "not sure why anyone would prefer London with the post-EU laws" is very different from "they decided they don't want me because they're not in the EU (even though there might be an otherwise nicely sounding arrangement available for me)."
- Symbiote 10y ago> if you live in Paris and are offered a good job in London, and they help you deal with the visa stuff Note that the freedom of movement in the EU means there isn't any "visa stuff" to deal with. An EU citizen moving to the UK needs to fill in a form, to get a "National Insurance" number. The same would be required of a British citizen that didn't have one, for example if they'd been born and lived overseas before moving to the UK. There are no other requirements that don't also apply to British / resident people moving within the UK.
- alecco 10y ago> If you are an EU citizen looking to move to the UK: just don't I call BS on that. UK is quite open to LEGAL worker immigration from anywhere around the world. What's the big deal? I worked in UK for years and I'm not EU. Many Americans, Asians, Australians, etc. go through these channels without issue. After a few years they give you residentship. And shortly after that they give you citizenship. It's crazy how this is all made to sound like UK is going to become Cuba or something. ALARMIST NONSENSE by radicalization and willful ignorance.
- mdekkers 10y agoUK is quite open to LEGAL worker immigration from anywhere around the world. lol, no it isn't - legal immigration from the EU is the main pillar of Brexit: "Stop all these people coming to live in our country."
- jcranmer 10y agoDidn't the Conservatives campaign in the last election about bringing legal immigration numbers down to <100K/year?
- MLR 10y agoNet migration, if you discount returning British citizens it currently sits at around 200,000 a year (500,000 gross), so it would be an approximate 20% reduction in non-British immigration. Or a 30% increase in emigration, but I doubt they're aiming for that.
- Anderkent 10y agoIt's a simple distinction: 1. You want to come work in London? Fill out all these forms, pay fees, prove that you're going to be useful, and we might allow you to stay 2. You want to come work in Berlin? Sure, come along. Do you see how the latter makes you feel much more welcome?
- Symbiote 10y ago> It makes sense, I don't think anyone could realistically expect anything different I might not expect it, but I do hope that a country that prides itself on the rule of law, and the historic influence it had in the world, would not break the terms of an international treaty. > it's actually pretty good from my perspective Are you familiar with the British expression, "I'm all right, Jack"? > exercise your rights TODAY ... it's just a bit of bureaucracy Ah, the 85 page form with the £65 fee, which many of my friends are worried they'll not be able to fill in correctly -- especially after all the stories in the British press of the long-term residents whose applications were rejected. For comparison, the Danish form for permanent residency has 6 pages in English (and 6 in Danish, it's bilingual), no fee, and only requires copies of the last few tax returns and a current job contract. Unfortunately, even if Britain remains in the UK until, say, 31 March 2019, I'll still be a few months short of the 5 year requirement.
- lukasm 10y agoIt seems the only way to execute your rights is to apply for residency and that requires 5 years.