3 ms·
It also has a continuum and value add component. Think of it like this: 1) A good idea 2) A good idea for searching the internet 3) A good idea for searching
by noonespecial 19y ago
It also has a continuum and value add component. Think of it like this:
1) A good idea
2) A good idea for searching the internet
3) A good idea for searching the internet with a certain algorithm to rank pages.
4) Using a distributed computing system to make this search scale.
5) Google.
As each order of possibility collapses into the next the idea becomes more and more the execution until its done. At each stage, the value increases as some possibilities are trimmed off and the idea becomes more concrete (or less as the wrong ones remain and the path is derailed).
The primary problem going on in the IP world right now seems to be an unhealthy focus (and over valuation) on the very early stages of the continuum. Patents should be issued at steps 3 and 4 but they are being issued at 2 instead. Thus selling stuff but on the interwebs, becomes patentable and the dissonance caused by this makes it difficult now for those at 3 and 4 trying to get value from the actual hard part.
- theorique 19y agoYou make a good point and we can see that the value of the idea increases geometrically as you move from one stage of development to the next. A great idea described in a sentence is not "worthless" - after all it could be the nucleus of the next big thing - but it's still just a few words written down. Just not much there yet. After experiment, refinement, iteration, failure, rebound from failure, small success, greater understanding of the problem, etc, etc, maybe an idea is worth something more tangible. An idea described in a few words will never be more valuable than any other few words until you take it through a process of design, engineering, and overall refinement to actually realize any intrinsic potential.
- aswanson 19y agoYeah, this guy got to stage 3, and nobody gives him credit: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/Xplore/login.jsp?url=/iel4/4236/15320/00707687.pdf?arnumber=707687 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/Xplore/login.jsp?url=/iel4/4236/1... With ideas, it's take it to the finish line or die anonymous. EDIT: 1 guy did give him credit, looking back on this is hilarious. Look at what the engine the guy was forced to use: http://groups.google.com/group/comp.infosystems.search/browse_thread/thread/a16f32297c172b70/c41c2b5c44cf29e1?lnk=st&q=rankdex&rnum=6 http://groups.google.com/group/comp.infosystems.search/brows... Also note the extraordinary business vision of Dow Jones.