4 ms·
Everyone would have to agree to publish their rough notes (on the web). If this was the norm, then no one would be singled out for criticism. Of course, norms w
by mtdewcmu 10y ago
Everyone would have to agree to publish their rough notes (on the web). If this was the norm, then no one would be singled out for criticism. Of course, norms would have to change.
- rspeer 10y ago> Of course, norms would have to change. Sure. How? Changing the norms of academia will take a generation, and would require some actual incentive to change them in the correct direction.
- mtdewcmu 10y agoThe article is calling for demanding more effort to get a paper published. That would be a change of norms. There's no real way to solve the reproducibility problem without changing norms. Publishing notes seems easiest. It would be like "open source" research.