3 ms·
> He seems to be claiming that it was mainly his age If the reasons he was let go were all typically legitimate reasons but also possibly directly due to age,
by sliverstorm 17y ago
> He seems to be claiming that it was mainly his age
If the reasons he was let go were all typically legitimate reasons but also possibly directly due to age, would that be discrimination?
I can't think of solid examples for programmers, but to use another field: Suppose a firefighter is let go because his age has robbed him of his ability to perform physically. Is this ageist?
- _delirium 17y agoIt's a complicated area, but I think generally the answer is that that's allowed, but with a fairly high bar for the employer to show that what they're testing really is a "bona fide occupational qualification". One of the important cases in the area is Dothard v. Rawlinson (1977), where the Supreme Court held that Alabama's height and weight requirements for prison guards, which disproportionately impacted women, were not justified, because there was no evidence that these height and weight cutoffs correlated strongly with prison safety: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dothard_v._Rawlinson http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dothard_v._Rawlinson
- roel_v 17y agoYou can't discriminate on gender either, yet someone advertising for a prostitute (in itself legal in my country) can specifically request women and prevail in court, whereas someone advertising for an accountant will not. There needs to be an objectively justifiable reason, the modalities of which have been (to an extend) worked out in hundreds of courts cases over the years. In the firefighters case, I guess that by now most fire brigades have set limits and reached agreements with union and the legislation to sort these things out, as have other fields.