3 ms·
How can an experiment 'not work out'? Do you mean a negative result? Not getting evidence for your hypothesis is not 'not working'. That's a crazy way to approa
by chrisseaton 10y ago
How can an experiment 'not work out'? Do you mean a negative result? Not getting evidence for your hypothesis is not 'not working'. That's a crazy way to approach science. It is more information to adjust your hypothesis. Or do you mean a failure such as broken equipment or an infected sample meaning you have no data? Well then what would you put in the paper?
- nine_k 10y agoAssumptions proved wrong?
- chrisseaton 10y agoI don't understand - experiments only work if they prove your assumptions? If your assumption was wrong then the experiment is working if it won't confirm it.
- robotresearcher 10y agoOr your experiment was faulty. Or the effect was too small to show up in your experiment, or any of many things that cause an experiment to be inconclusive. Getting a negative result with high confidence is real work. Failing to get a positive result is not the same thing.
- Fomite 10y ago"Experiment A is based on the assumption that Y is true. Halfway through doing A, it's quite clear that Y is at the very least not true. Thus, Experiment A doesn't work." Most people I know who have experiments not work out mean something like that - there's something not successful about the experiment itself, not just that they didn't get the answer they were hoping for.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- julian_1 10y agoAn experiment doesn't 'work out', if it doesn't lead to continued grant funding.
- castle-bravo 10y agoUniversities are charging hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition, paying adjunct professors a pittance to teach classes, and researchers are dependent on grant funding for their research. Where is the money going?
- arthur_pryor 10y ago> How can an experiment 'not work out'? Do you mean a negative result? Not getting evidence for your hypothesis is not 'not working'. That's a crazy way to approach science. yes, i think this is exactly what StClair means. and i agree (and i'd guess that StClair would agree) that this is "a crazy way to approach science." i think that's the point, that far too many null results get thrown out, when those are actually useful data points for the wider world to see.