8 ms·
> As a positive point, all the females in our cohort got dev jobs, including the only one who actually failed the class. Startups are pretty aware of the gender
by OJFord 10y ago
> As a positive point, all the females in our cohort got dev jobs, including the only one who actually failed the class. Startups are pretty aware of the gender discrepancy and actively looking to hire those with double x chromosomes. Not complaining about affirmative action, just wanted to give you as full picture as possible
You should be complaining! Especially given the rest of your story.
This kind of thing is such bull shit.
Before you down-vote me: a man passed and now works at Trader Joe's; a woman failed and got a software engineering role.
Reverse those genders, and if you're outraged, have a think about whether you should still be down-voting me.
- biznerd 10y agoHe said his cousin was female so I just wanted to highlight a positive for her. But you bring up a good point.
- Kluny 10y agoMaybe the women just hustled harder. I know that was the case in the program I went through. 30 of us passed; 3 were women. All 3 women and about 20% of the men got good industry jobs. However, I and the other two women were hustling for jobs, sending resumes, networking and going to interviews 6 months before graduation. Most of the men, assuming they were telling the truth when I casually asked them about it, didn't even start to write their resumes until the resume-writing workshop during the last week of school. Of the men who got jobs, one was given a position by his brother who had a hip startup; 3 showed up to a FAST consulting recruiting event and all three got hired there; one already had a degree in software engineering and a job waiting for him at his old employer; and several others went back to their old jobs as well.
- mannykannot 10y ago"One already had a degree in software engineering..." There's a whole other issue right there.
- Kluny 10y agoYou can conclude whatever you want from it, but in this case the gentleman in question had a good government job with the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, where he still works, as far as I know. He left his job temporarily to take a 2-year programming diploma on top of his software engineering degree. I don't think he did it to get a job since he already had one. It was more that his whole department was on the chopping block under the previous federal administration, and he thought it would be wise to get off of their payroll for a couple of years to avoid losing his job altogether. As far as I can tell it worked, as the federal administration has changed and he still has his job. I promise, there wasn't any sexism involved.
- mannykannot 10y agoSorry, I was not being clear - I wasn't thinking of sexism, but what a person with a software engineeing degree was doing at a programming boot camp. I realize that software engineering is not programming, but if the term has any meaning, I would expect anyone with such a degree to know enough about what it takes to make software as to be able to pick up common languages by self-study. Your reply hints that his attendance at boot camp might be as much about certification and documented hands-on experience as education.
- Kluny 10y agoAh, I see. Yes, you're right. I wondered what he was doing there myself. The "keeping my government job" story was reasonable, but you'd think he could have found a private industry job easily enough.
- cgriswald 10y agoIt's entirely possible that the women just hustled harder, thus explaining while all the qualified ones were hired. The problem is with the one who failed the class. What do we know about her? We know that she either was too lazy to pass the class--implying she doesn't hustle--or she is simply unable to pass the class, implying she isn't qualified. Combine this with the current political climate, in which a company looks like its trying to solve problems if it employs more women; and the fact that women joining male-dominated fields tends to cause a reduction in wages in those fields, and the fact that this seemingly unqualified and/or non-hustling woman was hired while many men were not, and its suggestive of a gender bias. That is not to say the other women who were hired aren't qualified or don't deserve those jobs. Merely that there may exist a gender bias which is problematic in that it is focusing a particular outcome (equality of gender) at the expense of economic sense and efficiency; not to mention the personal expense of the qualified men and also at the expense of the unqualified woman who, if such a bias exists, is really being exploited.
- Kluny 10y agoIt's also possible that she had qualifications in the industry she was hired for besides web design. It's not suggestive of bias at all - it simply tells us that there's something about the candidates that we don't know.
- cgriswald 10y agoAnything is possible, but gender bias seems a much likelier conclusion than that she was hired as a dev because she has skills other than dev.
- tps5 10y ago> Maybe the women just hustled harder. Doubt that explains it. I went through a large software development course, about 70 people. 60-40 male-female. Was a positive experience. The women all landed jobs instantly. As in, the day the camp ended, they all had jobs. The men, mostly, did not. It took months and multiple interviews for the men to get hired. The demand for female developers is higher than the demand for male developers. (not that the demand for male developers is low). This doesn't particularly bother me, but it does appear to be a thing. The way I look at it, most of the personal attributes that get you an entry-level job will end up having nothing to do with how well you will perform in that job. Gender is just another one of those.
- WildUtah 10y ago40% female? That's extremely high. Wonder how they accomplished that.
- lmcnish14 10y agoThat seems like a reasonable ratio considering that bootcamps are a popular way for women to break into the industry.
- abraca 10y agoNo, it is not a typical ratio. Bootcamps often have cohorts where there are 10 percent or even fewer women. For a bootcamp to have 40 percent ratio is impressive and unusual. Also - remarkable for all women to have a job at graduation. The bootcamp described sounds very unusual and the numbers are so very different from industry standard - that I encourage anyone reading to do their own research.
- discombobulate 10y agoWhich sites do you suggest for research?
- deleted 10y ago
- OJFord 10y agoMaybe so. But your experience is slightly different from what I'm objecting to most - which was a woman failing the programme and getting a development job, while men passed and no jobs or irrelevant jobs. No amount of hustle puts a candidate that failed a 'boot camp' above one that passed in a merit-based evaluation.
- Kluny 10y agoUnless she got hired in an industry where she already had experience, and the bootcamp qualification was only tangential to that.
- jen729w 10y agoIt's called "positive discrimination" for a reason. We're positively discriminating to the benefit of women (or minorities, or whomever) now, to make up for the decades of negative discrimination that these groups have suffered. Don't think it's fair? Interesting feeling, eh. Not very nice, eh. Be glad you haven't suffered it for literally your entire life.
- dsacco 10y agoSomething seems off to me intuitively about "positive discrimination", as you've described it. It doesn't really seem fair to be unfair to an individual because, in the aggregate, that individual's group has been unfair to others in the past (and even the present). Sort of feels like an emotionally charged way of righting the wrong, rather than a rational one...or even an effective one.
- owebmaster 10y agoThis remembers me of how germans has to hear quietly about their nazi grandparents.
- michaelmrose 10y agoGiven Male 1 and Female 1 wherein female 1 was unfairly discriminated against. How does it follow that if you unfairly privilege female 2 in favor of male 2 that you have somehow made up for the original injustice. A rational though process would be that this just adds to the sum of injustice in the world. I'm perhaps presuming to much but with a name that begins with Jen which is often a short or familiar form of Jennifer I would have to wonder if you yourself are in favor of "positive discrimination" because you yourself have suffered from plain old discrimination the bad and in fact only form of discrimination there is.
- jen729w 10y agoThey're my initials. I'm a 40 year old white English guy called John. I believe my life thus far has been tremendously more easy than a 40 year old black woman's would have been. Do you disagree? Edit: here's a concrete example. I've basically been offered every job interview I've gone for. I'm good at my job, no doubt, but in some of those cases I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have been the strongest candidate. But - forgive me if I sound like an asshole, I'm trying to make a point - I'm charming. I'm white, I smile, I dress well, and that makes me safe. I'm a safe option. Unsure who to hire? Hire that nice white guy. This is the systemic, subliminal discrimination that positive discrimination is trying to address. I shouldn't be the default option just because I'm the white guy. I've had my time. Let's give the "hey we're not sure, so if in doubt hire the black lady" option a go. Fuck it, it can't hurt. Now, I do absolutely disagree with PD where it favours a clearly inferior candidate just because of their race/gender/etc. That is clearly wrong, and gets people upset, and I see why and I agree. It's a nuanced issue. But if you deny that there's an issue, or try to sweep it under the carpet, I believe you're being disingenuous at best.
- gregmac 10y ago> This kind of thing is such bull shit. > Before you down-vote me: a man passed and now works at Trader Joe's; a woman failed and got a software engineering role. There's no reason to be outraged by a single anecdote. There are dozens or even hundreds of factors that qualify a person for a job beyond both their raw coding skill and gender. If someone is taking a job at Trader Joe's because they can't find a programming job, there's a good chance there's a reason for that.
- inimino 10y agoI downvoted you for being smart enough to expect downvotes, but not to see the first, most absolutely obvious rejoinder to the facile argument you presented.
- OJFord 10y agoSample size of 1 each way? Sure, I suppose the quote just encapsulated something I frequently see, and think is beyond idiotic. I'm young enough that the world I see being prepared for those not that much younger than me is, I think, going to be completely reversed from the motivation for the change. I've tried to sign up for (technical) events and talks at my university because they sounded interesting, only to be told 'this is a women-only event'. It would never even occur to me to hold a 'men-only talk on the latest foobar technique'; I suspect if I did, and refused to change my access policy, I'd be widely disparaged and perhaps kicked out! Equality - fine. Positive discrimination is just discrimination, and at some point it will be 'traditional, negative' discrimination. It's like the equality v equity cartoon - only the smaller box doesn't exist, and the middle-size child isn't short enough to qualify for a box: http://interactioninstitute.org/illustrating-equality-vs-equity/ http://interactioninstitute.org/illustrating-equality-vs-equ...
- inimino 10y ago> Sample size of 1 each way? That's not even it. Not only is it a sample size of 1, you are responding to a situation you know nothing about. Why did she fail? You have no idea, because it's not even your own anecdote. The fact that you're willing to jump in with "that is such bullshit" without even having the barest picture of the situation shows that your response is 1% motivated by the anecdote and 99% from your own biases and emotions about the issue. In other words, your response says more about you than about the story.
- dominotw 10y agoone of my female friends who is from the same class as I and is less proficient than me on almost all levels is getting inundated with offers from any tech company of her choice. Meanwhile, I barely get a callback from the recruiter, some of them pomise to call at certain time and never call, adding insult to injury. Kind of infuriating given both her parents are practising physicians and her whole education was completely paid for, unlike most people who have student debt staring them in the eye.
- emcq 10y agoI observed 3 things about women in boot camps that explain this phenomena outside of affirmative action: 1. They are self selecting to jump into the known gender gap in engineering. 2. Perhaps due to 1, they generally came from STEM backgrounds in great universities (Stanford, Michigan, UCLA, etc). 3. They had better final project presentations and projects than average. Perhaps due to 1 and 2. If they were driven, had a previous math/EE/mech E degree from a top university, and a great GitHub project why wouldn't you hire them?
- OJFord 10y ago> If they were driven, had a previous math/EE/mech E degree from a top university, and a great GitHub project why wouldn't you hire them? The woman in the example given in this thread failed; so certainly wasn't 'previous...degree from a top university' calibre. To be absolutely clear, I'm not in anyway 'against success' for any woman. The sort of merit-based hiring you described is exactly what everyone should be doing. But if candidate A is better than candidate B: hire candidate A! Whatever their gender, or fit for whatever other quota; scrap the damn quotas and targets. The only targets should be relevant capabilities, traded off against cost of course.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoPlease don't turn thoughtful conversation into angry ranting on HN, especially not about classic flamewar topics. It takes the site in exactly the opposite of its intended direction. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13741232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13741232 and marked it off-topic.
- OJFord 10y ago> Please don't turn thoughtful conversation into angry ranting on HN, ... [we have] marked it off-topic. I understand your decision. Respectfully, though, I think this sub-thread about the relative prospects candidates (and how it relates to culture more generally) is on-topic for the discussion here on considering enrolment in coding 'boot camps'. As always however, your call. :)