4 ms·
What is magical about 1880-1910 as the implied "normal" average baseline? Why not 1600? 1400? 2500 BC?
by ams6110 10y ago
What is magical about 1880-1910 as the implied "normal" average baseline? Why not 1600? 1400? 2500 BC?
- corradio 10y agoYou shouldn't care about what reference is taken. The point is that compared to any reference, the curve is increasing.
- sageikosa 10y ago800 million years ago is my reference point
- karl11 10y agoThat doesn't make sense. What if the reference is 5 minutes ago?
- euyyn 10y agoIf we're talking about annual average temperature, what doesn't make sense is thinking about 5min ago.
- corradio 10y agoTake the reference that is 5min ago, call it T0. You will still observe that temperatures (i.e the sequence of measured temperatures minus T0) are increasing. Changing the reference changes the y-scale of a graph, but does not change the derivative (the speed at which it changes, i.e. increases or decreases).
- joatmon-snoo 10y agoDid you look at the graph? The local derivative is most definitely not indicative of a general trend. For comparison, I throw a ball down at the ground, and for the first 0.1 seconds it's moving down - can I conclude that the ball is going to keep moving down, even when it hits the ground? That's your logic.
- stale2002 10y agoI don't think you know what baseline means. Baseline is just the starting point of the x-axis. It doesn't matter. Personally I'd set the baseline to 0 degrees. Because thats how temperature works. But you can pick whatever you want. It does not matter what you x-axis starts at. It doesn't change the data. Or you could just have no baseline. Just remove the X-axis line from the graph.
- sanderjd 10y agoWhat? Just because it's daytime (in the US) right now? In a few hours when it's dark, the temperature will definitely be going down when compared with a baseline of 5 minutes in the past. I don't think you've thought this through...
- stale2002 10y agoThen you could still look at the graph from 10 years ago, and compare it to your baseline of 5 minutes ago. "baseline" just means the line that defines the 0 point on the X-axis. It is just a flat line across the bottom graph It doesn't matter.
- bsbechtel 10y agoThat's ridiculous, of course you need a baseline for any sort of evaluation. Your comment implies any sort of warming, regardless of absolute levels, is bad.
- stale2002 10y agoOk, then, how about this. The baseline is 0 degrees, because that is the lowest that temperature can be. Would that be a fair baseline?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- corradio 10y agosorry for not being clear enough. I meant that the speed of warming is of interest here. That speed is independent of the baseline chosen. And that speed is what is worrying.
- gaius 10y agoThe point is that compared to any reference, the curve is increasing But that in and of itself doesn't mean anything - the Earth has warmed from two ice ages that we know of. The baseline absolutely determines what conclusions can be drawn from the data.
- conistonwater 10y agoBeyond a certain time, data collection wasn't common enough, so my understanding is that people pick a baseline from a period of time when people were already collecting data in substantial amounts. I guess 2nd half of 19th century, with all the industrialization, was when people both had enough resources, and were also interested in trying to actually collect it. I think this is similar to how the baselines for all satellite-measured data (like arctic sea ice, I think) start in the 70s. But the other comment is right too, which baseline doesn't matter so much, so long as the choice is reasonable, and used consistently. This is because, in the end, absolute values aren't meaningful on their own, only differences between them (similar to how one always reads about global temperature anomalies, rather than global temperature).
- Shivetya 10y agosee another comment because it is a period that lends itself to showing a stronger increase than exist. the simple truth is that nearly every model still shows more warming than has occurred. there were some wonderful events in the 1880s, including one of the most amazing snow storms the NY area ever saw, can you imagine fifty foot drifts? still there is a lot of warming but when we focus on per capita it allows many of the true violators to escape notice (Read Asia (china/india/etc)). plus looking at many sources the impact of C02 ranges from 10 to 30% so how can you factor in somethings whose range is so great. I still think a lot of industrialized raising of livestock isn't fairly accounted for as methane is more dangerous than CO2 just for fun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_of_1886%E2%80%9387 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_of_1886%E2%80%9387 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_1886_blizzard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_1886_blizzard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Blizzard_of_1888 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Blizzard_of_1888 though Buffalo would again see thirty to forty foot drifts in 1977