3 ms·
This is just one of a constant stream of stories from the Guardian that boil down to "people are sheep and their opinions are formed by a sinister conspiracy to
by mike_hearn 10y ago
This is just one of a constant stream of stories from the Guardian that boil down to "people are sheep and their opinions are formed by a sinister conspiracy to manipulate them". It is a fundamental part of their worldview, which is why they're so against referendums to begin with.
Indeed, the entire premise of this article is that people make up their mind based on what they see on Facebook, although Leave voters trend old (i.e. the people least likely to heavily use Facebook). The idea that it's sinister and scary comes from an academic "expert". This way of thinking has been pushed so hard by the left wing and pro-EU segment of media and society:
• Trust experts, not yourself.
• People who disagree with us are merely influenced by lies.
• It should be (pro-EU) MPs, not a referendum result, that decides what happens.
• When courts overrule referendums, that's democracy.
• Referendums are a bad idea because the outcome is pre-determined by whoever lies the most/spends the most money/is best at manipulation/etc.
It's a worldview that dehumanises anyone who disagrees and makes fools of anyone who adopts it, as the endless shrill cries of "what about the £350 million for the NHS" make clear - as if no lies were told by the Remain campaign! Emergency budgets that never happened, an insta-recession that never happened, Cameron saying he'd stay on and then immediately resigning, Obama saying the USA would shun the UK, the £4300/yr figure that was dropped the moment the Treasury produced it because it was clear this "expert prediction" was nonsense, the "we can stay in a reformed EU" despite the actual leaders of the EU saying that wasn't going to happen, etc etc.
But despite all that, only one side constantly harps on the idea that the vote wasn't reliable because of nonsense said by politicians: the side that never believed in voting to begin with.
- js8 10y agoI didn't downvote you, but I disagree strongly. I am leftist and my experience with other people on the left is that they overwhelmingly disagree with the points you ascribe to them. (Except perhaps the first one, I think it's quite sane to trust experts.) It's perhaps because you listen to "left-wing" politicians and people in power, and you're out of touch with people who have actual leftist opinions, that you get this impression. But it has nothing to do with being left-wing as it has it with being in power. So, I think you should stop labeling those things as leftist (they are not - democracy is in fact very much a leftist idea), you're only hurting your own cause, by seeing enemies where you could have allies.
- xd 10y ago"by seeing enemies where you could have allies." Ironically that's what we are seeing from the left, they see anyone that doesn't share their narrative as the enemy, in need of reeducating, and use the most abhorrent language to describe them, even going as far as comparing people to Hitler. And these "experts" you talk of, they're just as politically motivated as you are, think about that.
- js8 10y agoI have a hard time to understand your comment, in particular, what you mean by "narrative" and "we"? Could you give an actual example (quote) of what you consider to be bad from "the left"? Let me give you an opposite example, so that the discussion is not so abstract: Yanis Varoufakis disagrees with all those 4 points (see DiEM25) and he is a leftist. Experts are politically motivated, like everybody, yes. But that doesn't mean they don't give useful advice. I mean, your doctor is politically motivated, are you going not to trust him? Do you agree with: "Don't trust your doctor, only yourself"? In general, not trusting experts by default is a bad idea (maybe better would be to say: not trusting experts blindly is worse than trusting them blindly).
- xd 10y agoIf you don't understand my use of the word "we" as in the opposition/Right, or "narrative" as in political narrative; we are off to a bad start. A quick example of bad left would be their reaction to Brexit and anyone that voted in favor of it, which to them meant, overnight half the country became racist. Now, comparing a doctor, whom don't base their care on political opinions - to, say, financial experts that have something to gain from their "expert opinions" are two very different types of expert. But again, this is what we see coming from the left all the time, everything is black and white, there is no middle ground, you are either with us or a whole host of 'ism words. Funny thing is, doctors actually have to make shitty calls i.e. triage, and sometimes society can be so broken, that to fix things, shitty calls need to be made; something the left are utterly incapable of doing.
- 10y ago