9 ms·
With almost 8 BILLION people on this planet soon, not everyone can meaningfully contribute to something that can't be done more efficiently by automation (which
by Razengan 10y ago
With almost 8 BILLION people on this planet soon, not everyone can meaningfully contribute to something that can't be done more efficiently by automation (which is also cheaper for everyone and easier on the environment) or done away with entirely. See [1], [2], [3] for examples from our not-so-distant past.
You just cannot expect everyone to "earn" money while expecting technological progress to continue unabated.
Don't want so many people? Mandate reversible sterilization at birth.
Don't want so many disgruntled and unemployed people? Endorse some form of guaranteed income, or incorporate basic housing, meals, healthcare and internet into the list of undeniable human rights.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamplighter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamplighter
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link-boy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link-boy
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchboard_operator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchboard_operator
- alexryan 10y agoAs long as important problems remained unsolved and human desires remain unfulfilled there will be opportunities to contribute.
- cannonpr 10y agoI do wonder about the "not everyone can contribute" perhaps they can't contribute in building cars, but with a cultural shift and education, well there are a lot of avenues of research and mathematics that only require thought and basic tools like chalk. I tend to view an unemployed human as an awful waste of computational resources. This ofcourse assumes we haven't figured out strong AÍ or we don't want to, cause that's an entirely different chat.
- manmal 10y agoYes. We are made to be active (non-passive), so most people will choose to do _anything_ anyway. Might as well something that furthers our objectives.
- jsemrau 10y agoI have been building houses in Indonesia and other parts of South East Asia and there is ample need for people who can build stuff and teach things.
- adrianN 10y agoare you honestly suggesting that a large part of the population can be trained to become research mathematicians?
- cannonpr 10y agoAre you honestly suggesting there is anything other than education preventing them from it ? That asides, research mathematics is only a small subset of mental tasks available to humans. There are a lot of areas that could benefit from "computation" Laws, philosophy, literature, sociology, psychology. We seem to have forgotten how much of our society is based on how our thought is applied to knowledge. Thought rather than Praxis has been relatively neglected in our age.
- adrianN 10y agointelligence and mathematial ability can't be taught very well
- powertower 10y ago> Are you honestly suggesting there is anything other than education preventing them from it? Yes. The aptitude of higher abstract thinking varies greatly among different people and groups. If you are really curious, check out the IQ test about pulling info from a sports column. After that, your question becomes similar to asking why every short person can't be taught/trained to do well on a professional basketball team.
- flocial 10y agoElevating educational standards of society as a whole, especially the poor, has nothing to do with whether all disenfranchised groups have the native intelligence to become academics or well paid knowledge workers. The number of active NBA players is in the hundreds and their careers are short. Education is a very effective weapon against multi generational poverty and the focus of international aid organizations for a reason. Someone from an impoverished background is much more likely to live a better life with more education than someone without.
- sewercake 10y ago> I tend to view an unemployed human as an awful waste of computational resources This feels like a pretty strong over-application of the computational metaphor, my friend.
- cannonpr 10y agoGuilty.
- douche 10y ago> I tend to view an unemployed human as an awful waste of computational resources. If we extend the metaphor, there are 4004s and there are i7s. You need a lot of 4004s to equal the output of one i7. That many 4004s use a lot more watts than the one i7, and at some point the value isn't there.
- cannonpr 10y agoI see your point, however these humans are alive, thinking, using power you might say anyway. There is a nearly infinite task in improving our society and science, and we have strong evidence that humans become self destructive or just destructive when not actively engaged in something they enjoy doing.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoWhat do you propose that we do with the 4004s?
- ue_ 10y ago>I tend to view an unemployed human as an awful waste of computational resources. Is this a joke? It sounds like something so detached from the reality of humanity that it's something only an engineer or computer scientist would say. An unemployed human isn't a 'waste' of anything; the fact that the human does not need to be employed but is still suffering at the hands of capitalism is horrible.
- ezy 10y agoIf you have an IQ of 89 or below in a first world country, you might be able to barely complete high school, but are not going to become a math professor. IQ (g) is normally distributed. The only hope here is that there is some extrinsic element, similar to nutrition, but as yet undiscovered, that will improve human IQ for those on the left-hand side of the curve in a real way. Otherwise, no, not everyone can contribute in the same way.
- omegaworks 10y ago>Don't want so many people? Mandate reversible sterilization at birth. So... they tried a little something like that back in the 30s and a lot of people didn't like it.
- watt 10y agoThere was 2 billion people on Earth then. It's 7 now and will be 8 by 2024 if nothing changes.
- omegaworks 10y agoTurns out, if you raise people's standards of living, make it possible to invest in their kids, they stop having so many kids. In fact, in Japan and about 48% of the world they're not having enough kids to replace the existing population. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility Seems a lot more humane than sterile-by-default until magical government bot decides it's ok for you to continue your genetic lineage. But we're technologists right? We don't care about that fluffy duffy humanity thing. Politics is not worth our time. Sign here to add yourself to the baby waitlist. Party members get priority, of course.
- solidsnack9000 10y agoThey can fight each other for control of the robots.
- bennettfeely 10y ago> Mandate reversible sterilization at birth. This sounds like an absolutely atrocious idea ripe for corruption. It would be only a matter of time before those programs target the poor, those who whose political views, religious views, or ethnic origins are unwanted or inconvenient.
- thehardsphere 10y agoPeople used to do this during the original "Progressive era" im American history. The people who ended up targeted were poor and black. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization
- flocial 10y agoIf you look at current incarceration statistics I'd say it's still happening.
- thehardsphere 10y agoI don't know if it's the same, because I don't know if that's happening with the same sort of pre-meditated malice. Like, I don't think the people behind the incarceration soad "Let's jail all the poor black people" up front, whereas that was the explicit goal of some of these Progressive-era sterilization programs. Then again, the intentions ultimately don't matter if you're on the receiving end of it.
- eternalban 10y agoIf you are willing to go that far, why not "mandate" no robots?
- fwn 10y agoBecause this is the nogo alternative of a false dichotomy designed to support the other presented route.
- 10y ago
- greyman 10y ago> not everyone can meaningfully contribute to something that can't be done more efficiently by automation I don't know if this statement is true, but a lot more jobs could be created in the area of teaching, caring for elderly and ill people, etc.
- rorykoehler 10y agoI wonder if compulsory national service in these areas for individuals who don't contribute over x% or $yy.. in personal income tax a year would work?
- coldpie 10y agoThe last person I want teaching or caring for my old body is someone being forced to do so. Rather, we should increase the incentive for people to train in those areas by increasing their wages.
- rorykoehler 10y agoMy idea is more an incentive to get the wealthy to pay their fair share of taxes so we can find initiatives like you suggest.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoStill it's reasonable to expect the transition to a post scarcity society within the next two generations, at least not globally in the first phase but the growth boom will cause a new wave of hyperexpansionism to secure the growing lands and resource depots. Jobs as care worker won't be enough and not everyone is good/motivated in them and I don't think you don't realize how bad it is for the cared to have a spiteful worker There's a huge issue looming as the current mainstream libertarian model is ill suited for a post scarcity society plus there's gonna be a huge problem with migrations ready to compound with internal strifes. Nothing impossible to solve with preparation but seems we gonna reach that point fastly and badly.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoThat's a very classist attitude founded on a view of economic activity that pertained to human history only over a short period of tube and otherwise is a completely unrealistic view of the human condition. Humans are amazing creatures. Moreover there is no limit to the work that can be done, there is always something else that can or should be done should the labor become available. I can assure you, people will not run out of valuable, substantive work to do. People got much more efficient at farming (by orders of magnitude), that didn't lead to people stopping working it led to people finding other things to do such as crafts, art, and later manufacturing. Now that the save thing has happened with manufacturing people are again finding other things to do.
- coding123 10y agoWhile I dont agree with everything this comment or said, I definitely see that most people in the US (because that's where I live) are typically either tellers, paper pushers, execs... Hardly anyone does anything actually meaningful it seems. There is like 3% that seems to be in endeavor fields like science, exploration, invention... But most of what I see is completely meaningless drone work.
- thehardsphere 10y ago"Meaningless drone work" needs to get done just as much as "science, exploration and invention." Just because it's work that seems tedious and boring to you doesn't mean it's not valuable to either the person paying for it or the person doing it.
- state_less 10y agoDoes it though? Look at the health insurance industry, Aetna pulls in $15B and has $3B in overhead. Couldn't automation cut out (nearly) all the people involved in that overhead. They spent $20 million pulling levers to get a better deal for themselves in Washington alone. This is worse than drone work, it's drone work that kills people.
- zouhair 10y ago> Don't want so many people? Mandate reversible sterilization at birth. Jesus fucking Christ, let's just round up all that don't have jobs and kill them all it'll go faster.
- dorfsmay 10y agoMoney has worked really well to share limited resources in a fairly peaceful way. Making decisions about how to share limited resources in a post-work world is one of the most difficult problem we are going to face, and yet it isn't discussed. Instead, we'd rather claim that Basic Income pixie dust is going to solve all problems.
- zouhair 10y agoYou know why people in rich countries don't have a lot of kids? It's because when you give people everything they to have a decent life they start to think about other things than just having tons of kids, kids are the retirement fund for poor people, give them enough to have a decent retirement fund and suddenly they will stop having ton of kids. Overpopulation is not the problem in itself, the problem is that people do not have enough to survive, all when we as humans are producing more wealth per capita than any other time in history.
- dorfsmay 10y agoOr is it because bringing up kids responsively in industrial countries is really expensive?
- scruple 10y agoThis has been my wife and I's experience. It's very common among the majority of our friends and family who are, like us, childless well in to their 30s (mostly in the pursuit of "career").
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>You know why people in rich countries don't have a lot of kids? Because we can't afford a spare bedroom to put them in.
- sametmax 10y agoYou don't need mandatory sterilizatiion. Men are scared enough of unwanted pregnancy. Just offer free VASALGEL procedure on and off for anybody and the problem will solve itself. Now we just need the procedure to become legal in the us, but i'm very eager to use it myself and have high hopes for it.
- kayoone 10y agoBirth rate in western countries is hardly the problem.
- sametmax 10y agoI disagree. I think our quality of life would improve if we could half our population, once passed the painful periode where society adjusts.
- EliRivers 10y agoWhy? What's magical about halving the population in the typical Western industrialised country? That's not an order of magnitude change. I don't see any reason why this would have some kind of magical effect. We'd still need pretty much the same kind of society. We'd need pretty much the same kind of infrastructure. Given that wealth in the typical industrialised, Western country isn't generated by natural resources, it wouldn't be the case that suddenly there's simply more stuff to go around. Why would halving the population of the place improve quality of life?
- sametmax 10y agoTraffic jams, pollution, loads of wastes, material consumption, needs to administrate all that, size of the cities, ability for justice to be served, hospital facilities, availability of pre-schools, number of children in class rooms... People think overpopulation is a problem when you reach a certain cap, but I don't think there is a cap. I think it's progressive. Plus with our current population size, we are bound to certain kind of systems and can't try alternatives. We have to normalize, we have to batch, we have to have pyramids, a chain of command to manage things. This is great to produce and consume a great quantity of goods, but not so much for education, progress as a society, as a specie and even for something simpler such as producing goods of great quality. But even if you disagree with any of that, and my whole population size theory, great birth control would solve one current major problem: unwanted pregnancy by men. I'd say about half of my male friends became parents unwillingly for a lot of different reasons and scenarios. It does not make them great fathers because they didn't want to be one at this time of their life in the first place. I think a global solution for a safe, non invasive and permanent procedure to keep one sterile at will would improve immensely the quality of life, eduction, and growth of children. Because the ones being here would be the ones wanted. Which means basically shaping a better future.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoWhat reverses sterilization? Money? The possession of a certain ideology? Do you trust government in creating ideal criteria for which germ lines should live on - when the human genome project was such a failure?
- Razengan 10y agoIt could just involve the signing of a simple document that says you and your partner are ready to raise a child together, and preemptively agreeing on who will get custody and who will pay how much should you divorce in the near future. The only criteria a government needs to check is whether the couple has lived together for a certain amount of time (say 1 year) without an incident of domestic abuse etc. or a past criminal record involving child abuse.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoAnd you trust the government to keep it simple and not push any other legislation into it besides the simple "just live together for a year without incident"? What's the punishment for having a kid before you've lived together for a year?
- apozem 10y ago> Don't want so many people? Mandate reversible sterilization at birth. No. Forced sterilization is eugenics, and we've seen what happens with that [1]. Eugenics is unconscionable for moral, ethical, legal and humanitarian reasons. When you give government or the private sector or any human being the ability to control other humans' reproduction, that power is ripe for horrific abuse. We know this because that's exactly what happened last time [2]. Not to go full Godwin on you, but eugenics is literally the philosophy behind the Nazis (see [1]). Overpopulation will be an issue eventually. Better to solve it through more creative means, like becoming a 2+-planet species. [1]: http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/1796 http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/1796 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics_in_the_United_States#Compulsory_sterilization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics_in_the_United_States#...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- brianwawok 10y agoThere is a range between eugenics and no population control. I.e. free birth control, no tax breaks past 2 children, etc. Even a small change in birth rate makes a big change in 200 years.
- rimantas 10y agoOverpopulation will not be an issue. IIRC we are already past "peak child".
- tasuki 10y agoSource: https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies
- blamestross 10y agobeing a 2+ planet species wont help local overpopulation. it is too much more effective to ship a highly diverse sampling of frozen sperm and ova manufacture most of your people onsite. Moving that many people just does not make sense when you have more cost effective alternatives. plus adding planets inside the solar system only gives you 2 real targets (mars and venus) mining asteroids to build spinning habitats is a much more viable colonization target.
- Razengan 10y agoParent poster here. Just to make it clear, I am not advocating eugenics or anything, just saying that some form of basic income seems to be the only option if we want the human race to flourish and science/technology to advance.
- cylinder 10y agoHow does the left wing reconcile its push for UBI, more redistribution to compensate for automation job loss, etc., with an unquestioned belief in immigration or even open borders? You cannot have UBI due to lack of jobs but then also have the US' current family-based immigration system. It would be a different situation if we were specifically targeting skilled robotics engineers and AI coders from around the world, but we put those people through the ringer to favor an unskilled third world immigrant because his brother is a US citizen.
- stmfreak 10y agoSimple, the leftists believe you pay for UBI from the limitless resources confiscated from the "rich." /s
- locopati 10y agoYou mean taxes paid by the wealthy to support a stable system that enables them to create wealth and enjoy it. Please ask yourself, do a small handful of people need to possess as much wealth as half of the USA? More wealth than they could ever possibly spend in a hundred lifetimes? We are all in this together and those that have benefit by helping those that do not.
- ue_ 10y agoIs this serious? The solution to fewer people needing to work is reversible sterilization at birth? Not bringing down the system that puts people in destitution, poverty and at risk of death beacuse they cannot find a job? Capitalism is the cause of the inequality, not overpopulation. There are more than enough resources.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> With almost 8 BILLION people on this planet soon, not everyone can meaningfully contribute People keep saying this, but why is it true? Why can't you just have 4 billion people making boutique food for the other 4 billion who are making boutique clothing in return? Why can't you have 8 billion people making TV shows for each other while robot housekeepers keep them alive? Mental health care alone would seem to me to be an almost infinite market in need of labor. Is there some economic law that defines an upper limit on how much work there is to be done? I see seemingly infinite undone tasks around me.
- nrdwavexe 10y agoin order to believe this is possible, you have to believe in some group that has decided---a priori---to arrogate to themselves to decide what is a "meaningful contribution to something that is essential or impossible to automate" and furthermore you have decided that the situation is hopeless and that this group is ABSOLUTELY DETERMINED to discard AT LEAST SOME PEOPLE as INCAPABLE of MEANINGFUL CONTRIBUTION. In reality, all you have is a bunch of people who periodically go around looking for troublemakers and deciding on which justifications to use to push them around. I don't like you, so I'm going to arrange things so that if anyone gets the notion that you are making a meaningful contribution, I will hurt them. That way no one will say that the troublemakers are making a meaningful contribution.