4 ms·
Why? I mean, you took two paragraphs to write "I disagree", but you forgot the ", because".
by skrebbel 10y ago
Why? I mean, you took two paragraphs to write "I disagree", but you forgot the ", because".
- notamy 10y agoNot gp commenter, but I think the point is that while yes, having more women (or <insert group here> for a different discussion) would be a good thing, they shouldn't simply be put into these positions by virtue of the "minority" (quoted for lack of a better word) traits ALONE. Rather, would it not be better to have people with <whatever trait> who are incredibly competent / qualified / etc. who would be a better role model to those with <whatever trait> who want to get into the field?
- projektir 10y agoIncredibly competent is a very high bar to place on a group of people that already has trouble breaking in. That seems like a very good way to keep that group out. I think we already have this problem: it sometimes seems like nobody really wants women unless they are insanely competent. I'm sorry, that's not how it works. You don't get to keep a giant population down and then just extract the occasional diamonds and ignore the rest. You need to pull the entire thing if you want those diamonds to be created. > they shouldn't simply be put into these positions by virtue of the "minority" (quoted for lack of a better word) traits ALONE Why do people always state this as if it's the only possible reality? You go from "on minority basis ALONE" to "incredibly competent" in one fell swoop. I seriously hope you don't have people in your organization that are so incompetent that the only reason you could think of promoting them is because they're in an underprivileged group. Because otherwise, your statement doesn't make any sense. It's like you are already signing up for a reality where members of underprivileged group cannot possibly be the kinds of members you'd very much want to have. That's not what we're saying. What we're saying is that among the group of cool people that you have in your organization, maybe notice the women sometimes. And don't expect them to be "incredibly competent". Just competent enough. The same way you treat everyone else.
- notamy 10y agoAlright, I just wanna say that, as a college student, I probably have no idea what the hell I'm talking about, so take it with a truckload of salt :) That being said, I do agree with what you say. I was guessing at what the (ggg)gp comment meant. I'm sure I could have worded it better, but I don't have much experience with any of this. Seriously, thank you for explaining it to me.
- zigzigzag 10y ago, because ... it's obvious. Promoting incompetent people because they have a vagina is not a policy that will promote harmony between the genders, nor will it magically make meetings vaguely better. It will however lead to resentment and distrust amongst men, who will always wonder if their female boss got where she did by being good, or simply by being a woman.
- stale2002 10y agoThe status quo is the opposite. Incompetent men are getting promoted because women are getting driven out of the industry. I agree with making the industry more meritocratic. And the way to do this is to support diversity efforts, and stop promoting incompetent men.
- sctb 10y agoIf you're going to participate in discussions on Hacker News it has to be more civil and substantive than this.
- zigzigzag 10y agoAre you objecting to the use of the word vagina? It seems base, uncivil and shocking doesn't it? It's also a statement of cold fact. That is exactly the policy being advocated by Pike and too many people in this discussion thread: promote and hire people simply because of their anatomy. Your shock at my language is not the result of me being uncivil, but at an uncivil policy stated clearly and without linguistic obfuscation.
- sctb 10y agoYou continue to attack straw men on a controversial topic, and that is what is uncivil and against the guidelines of this site. Worse, we've seen these scarecrows a million times before and they predictably fail to ever bring us any closer to any insight on the topic.
- 4ad 10y ago> Why? Why what? Why do I fight injustice and sexism? Or why do I think sexism branded as feminism is a such a colossal problem? The former is pretty obvious, I think few people in the west think sexism is a good idea, personally I subscribe to a pretty mainstream individualist moral stance. I wrote some thoughts about this in some parallel comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13737987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13737987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13737437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13737437 As for the latter, that's a much longer discussion for which unfortunately I do not have the time to get into sufficient detail. Nor do I think this is an appropriate forum for this discussion considering all the downvotes I am getting (no complaining, just stating a fact). Oxitendwe (in this thread) has briefly touched the crux of the issue, however. Mainly that is an attempt of a power grab over society, one that fundamentally has very little to do with women, and in the end it will cause more harm to women than men. I, and most likely my children and friends are directly affected by this power grab.