3 ms·
Thanks for the thoughtful and respectful comments, I hope my answer manages to stay in that spirit, too. > I think the same is true for Christianity too Disag
by FabHK 10y ago
Thanks for the thoughtful and respectful comments, I hope my answer manages to stay in that spirit, too.
> I think the same is true for Christianity too
Disagree, concerning the Abrahamic religions, as what is good is rarely original, and what is original is rarely good:
1. What is good (golden rule, some of the 10 commandments) is not very original. The golden rule has appeared in ancient Greece (Thales), China (Confucius), etc. half a millennium before Christianity, and other places independently. By contrast, Stoa and Buddhism were, I'd venture, among the first to arrive at and codify certain substantial insights that constitute large parts of their teachings.
2. What is original is mostly fairly absurd, if looked at dispassionately. If you strip Christianity of the superstitions, its essence is basically gone.
Just as a small example: it is still current position of the Catholic Church that the eucharist is actual transformation in substance of wine and bread into actual blood and flesh of Christ. (There was a (possibly apocryphal) case in Germany of a vegetarian asking whether he could participate in the communion, and he was told that he could not as a vegetarian, because it IS flesh.) If you erroneously believe that it's purely symbolic, you'd be subject to the punishment of anathema (which is worse than excommunication), if the Church were consistent with its teachings.
> religions offered a way of life that attempted to reduce violence, illness and suffering.
Yes, at the time. But not today.
> what would you speculate if you didn't have the knowledge of how the universe, the planets and life, including us, developed? In that case, a creator provides the fewest assumptions.
Yes, at the time. But not today.
In that sense, Stoa and Buddhism have aged better than the Abrahamic religions, maybe because they were more empiric.
- jwdunne 10y agoWith regards to one, just because it was not original does not discount its value. That only supports my point that it was an attempt to present a way to live - a failed attempt given hindsight. I never said it was original nor entirely good. That's why we can both recognise the good parts as generally good advice. 2. I'm not preaching. I was brought up Catholic and learned enough to reject it. Catholicism and the actions of that church and other splinters are fundamentally at odds with what Jesus actually preached - love your neighbour. Somehow, it was ok to burn your neighbour alive if they did not believe Jesus was God, which the rule did not mention. I am not a Catholic today - there is too much hypocrisy. My assertion was that these, regardless of what we know now, were misguided hypotheses that had mixtures of valuable advice along with ideas that we now know are wrong. The structure built on top of that is perhaps a hypothesis taken too seriously. My thinking is that what originally was the equivalent of Aristotle to some Newton was misunderstood and taken to the extreme. I share your sentiments exactly. > Yes, at the time. But not today This was exactly my point. Your English is very good, by the way. If I didn't know better, I'd mistake your German directness as rude and blunt. I would agree. Perhaps not empiric but more practical which lends itself better to empirical study.
- FabHK 10y ago> I never said it was original nor entirely good. True, you didn't, I had said it ("... there is still a lot of original wisdom and substance left"), to which you replied, that's why I focused in on it. > I'm not preaching. Fair enough, I try not to... :-) > If I didn't know better, I'd mistake your German directness as rude and blunt. Nailed it, thanks for the benefit of the doubt. Edited to add: This (mostly) works on HN, but lamentably not many other sites...
- jwdunne 10y agoWow, you're right. Sorry about that. Yeah, clearly not original. I do agree. I'm British - I will apologise if you bump into me.
- taway_1212 10y agoOne of the big new concepts of Christianity (when compared to Judaism, from which it originated) was that it was universal, whereas Judaism is a religion for Jews only.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoI don't think Judaism has ever been a closed faith. I may have missed some interval of time where it was only by birthright or something. This being said, I don't think conversion is sought as it is in Islam and Christianity.
- codr4life 10y agoThe cannibalistic reenactment that the catholic church is pushing so hard has very little to do with Christianity; it's anti-Christian if anything; it's sole purpose is to paralyze the subconscious with shame, guilt and despair; conditioning by trauma is a very effective way to turn people into helpless victims.