This comment is insightful and is in line with Mina bissels views. The immediate questions when someone tries to replicate a study is... How hard did they try?

This comment is insightful and is in line with Mina bissels views. The immediate questions when someone tries to replicate a study is... How hard did they try? Did they go to the lab and spend one year of their life learning the technique? Or did they try it once and didn't think hard enough about being careful?