7 ms·
Disclaimer: I've sold stuff via FBA. Not much - just enough to "try it out". Probably made about $100/mo during my experiment. >That's almost certainly a hard
by BeetleB 10y ago
Disclaimer: I've sold stuff via FBA. Not much - just enough to "try it out". Probably made about $100/mo during my experiment.
>That's almost certainly a hard business to make money on - if you're doing common off-the-shelf items of any value, Amazon can simply add those themselves, and they're probably getting a better price on them with bulk purchases than anyone doing FBA can get.
But Amazon does not really want to get into all product categories. Much of what many of us buy from Amazon is FBA, where Amazon themselves are not selling it. People who do not know FBA often do not realize they are not buying it from Amazon.
Regarding the Cat Scam: I completely disagree that it is a scam. In fact, the Planet Money journalist himself implied he felt it was a legitimate business: The people were providing value, and were making the FBA person's sales go up. He hurt himself by pulling the product from Amazon.
There is a reason Amazon allows drop shipping. It brings everyone money. Amazon, the FBA seller, eBay and the eBay seller. People try to paint it as exploiting unwary consumers, but that's true any time you have a price difference between retailers.
Effectively, the drop shipper provided the FBA seller access to another market (eBay), with a higher return rate. It was a net profit, not a net loss.
It may just be that for this one person it was reducing his profits, but in general, this strategy increases revenue, not decreases it.
- joemi 10y agoMiddleman sellers might not technically be a scam, but it's not often beneficial to all parties. I've spent some time working for a bookstore that has decent quantity of sales on Amazon, so that's where my perspective comes from. Some issues with middlemen: - First, a lot of middlemen ALWAYS email the seller after placing an order, expecting the seller to omit any mention of the seller and how much the product cost on Amazon. Further, they request that the seller send a separate email with the tracking info for their orders. While this is probably find for random small sellers on Amazon, for larger ones like the one I was at, honoring all the middlemen's requests would cause HUGE shipping delays for all products, middleman or regular, just to deal with all the emails and special requests. - Often they'll email again ("angrily", though it's just a canned response) if an item hasn't arrived 3 or so days after they placed the order. Even if the order was on a Friday night. And even if it's going from one side of the country to the other via the cheapest/slowest shipping method offered. So that's more needless emails to waste the seller's time. - If there's an issue with the order, the middlemen often do not pass on details of the issue to the seller. Instead they just say (effectively) "There was an issue. I demand a full refund." Often issues can be resolved with exchanges or returns, but so many middlemen just demand full refund with no returns. - Due to poor listings wherever the middlemen are relisting the Amazon products, the middlemen's customers often aren't aware of all the details of what they order. We'd regularly get things sent back and the complaint was "it's a used book" when that's exactly what was listed on Amazon. - Some middlemen sellers are A-z Claim happy... Threatening to file a claim in their very first email to the seller, when they ask for no invoice or reference to the seller. We dealt with a few who would ask that you'd print out their own packing slip to send with the order and that you'd write their name on the return address of the package instead of your own. - Often, middlemen include "(NO INVOICE)" somewhere in the shipping address, as a further instruction to seller to omit pricing info. Removing that part from a more automated shipping process (like larger stores use) adds processing time and increases possibility of mistakes. Plus Amazon requires that orders be shipped to the address provided, so I'm still not even sure if it breaks Amazon's policies or not to remove that from the address. - We would frequently get confused or angry emails or phone calls from customers who bought something from a middleman seller who in turn bought it from us, because they'd see that our return address wasn't the middleman's name, or we'd include a packing slip (middlemen don't always ask for it to be omitted, and we wouldn't always comply if they did anyway) with our info and they'd see the price it really cost. That means more customer service time spent on that, and an upset end customer.
- BeetleB 10y agoThis thread is about FBA, and I suspect you're referring to non-FBA sales here. >First, a lot of middlemen ALWAYS email the seller after placing an order, expecting the seller to omit any mention of the seller and how much the product cost on Amazon The order is fulfilled by Amazon, and the seller has no control over this. The middleman can email all he wants, but it's no use. I don't think the middleman even has the ability to contact the seller easily. How exactly can they get the person's email address? >Often they'll email again ("angrily", though it's just a canned response) if an item hasn't arrived 3 or so days after they placed the order. Fulfilled by Amazon. The middleman is in entire control on the shipping. They want it faster? They should select faster shipping. >If there's an issue with the order, the middlemen often do not pass on details of the issue to the seller. Instead they just say (effectively) "There was an issue. I demand a full refund." Often issues can be resolved with exchanges or returns, but so many middlemen just demand full refund with no returns. This is Amazon policy for FBA. It is no different from you buying from Amazon or some other store and returning without an explanation. When you sell via FBA, you are required to accept this as a consequence. This has little to do with middlemen. I myself have had perfectly functioning items returned as defective, and I have no recourse. >Due to poor listings wherever the middlemen are relisting the Amazon products, the middlemen's customers often aren't aware of all the details of what they order. We'd regularly get things sent back and the complaint was "it's a used book" when that's exactly what was listed on Amazon. I too get pointless returns. As do almost all retailers out there. Why do you expect things to be different? As long as you sell via Amazon FBA, Amazon has a return policy you need to accept. I could go on and on about your other bullets, but it is clear you are complaining about a different problem from the one in this thread. Most of these issues are non-issues with FBA. Customers will not get your contact info via FBA. Middlemen do not get it either. If a middlemen puts "No Invoice" on an FBA order, Amazon will deal with it (likely by literally shipping to that address). Now getting to your case, where you are likely a business selling via Amazon, but not having them fulfill your orders, the larger thread is very relevant to you. If a big chunk of your business is dependent on Amazon's existence, you are vulnerable. It is hard for me to sympathize with you. At the end of the day, you list on Amazon because Amazon is creating value for you - despite all these annoyances. You are seeing all the annoyances of middlemen, but you likely do not know how much business they are generating for you. 2 questions: 1. For orders like (No Invoice), would it be beneficial for you to just cancel the order and not get the money (assuming Amazon gave you that option, with no repercussions to your Amazon rating)? If not, you are benefiting. 2. How can you tell which of your orders that go smoothly involve middlemen? If you cannot, you have no idea if it is benefiting you or not.
- ckib16 10y agoI'm in the same boat @BeetleB. Sold a line of private label toys on FBA. Not a run-away success but definitely a great introduction to the market. My family members are also FBA sellers. The thing that most people don't realize is that Amazon is moving away from selling everything itself. As stated by Ben Thompson in his excellent "Stratechery" blog (paywall): > "...I wrote about the ongoing transformation in Amazon’s e-commerce business: while Amazon was originally a traditional retailer that bought products from manufacturers and wholesalers and then sold them on to customers, the company has been shifting to a marketplace model, wherein 3rd-party retailers sell to users on Amazon’s site through a program called Fulfillment by Amazon." For some direct proof, check out the highlights from the 2016 Q4 earnings report: - Sellers on Amazon’s marketplace accounted for 49% (!!!) of units sold during the fourth quarter - Fulfillment by Amazon delivered more than 2 billion items on behalf of sellers in 2016 and the number of active FBA sellers increased by 70 percent. In short, Amazon is in a good spot by creating the marketplace. They own the audience. Sellers on FBA "borrow" that audience & Amazon logistics in return for storage and sales fees. No need for Amazon to sell everything. FBA sellers do that for them. FYI for any online sellers out there: if interested, I curate an eCommerce newsletter for the small-scale seller covering Shopify, FBA etc. at http://www.privatelabelweekly.com http://www.privatelabelweekly.com Sources 1. https://stratechery.com/2017/planet-of-the-apps-deleteuber-amazons-earnings/ https://stratechery.com/2017/planet-of-the-apps-deleteuber-a... 2. http://l.goodbits.io/l/l64vu14d http://l.goodbits.io/l/l64vu14d
- petra 10y ago>> Amazon is moving away from selling everything itself This is a 2 sided story. Yes Amazon is moving away from selling stuff itself - but they are building a platform that would make it easy and more affordable for manufacturers to sell directly to customers, and most of the jobs FBA entrepreneurs do today won't require expensive entrepreneurs to do. For example: Logistics:Amazon is working on an end-2-end logistic solution, from china to the US, fit for small and medium manufacturers. Financing:Amazon, using their sales data etc, will offer credit to manufacturers, similar to a service done by alibaba today. Marketing:Amazon has the customers, the software skills, and can build labor platforms that easily enable chinese manufacturers to hire more affordable marketers(cheaper than entrepreneurs), maybe similar to affiliates in skills and investment . Product improvement:more than anything, it's a decision by manufacturers/entrepreneurs, the tools/data are already there. Also Amazon could build platforms for manufacturers to gauge demand and value of new features more easily, maybe similar to kickstarter Returns and warranties: Fedex bought a company that does that(as a service) pretty well a few years ago, So Amazon will probably copy or outsource. Sure, it will take some time, but i think FBA entrepreneurship is mostly a temporary thing.