4 ms·
You know, a sufficiently smart person would probably most likely know when their actions are ethically questionable, despite feigning ignorance when caught. The
by pm90 10y ago
You know, a sufficiently smart person would probably most likely know when their actions are ethically questionable, despite feigning ignorance when caught. These people act the way they do not because they are unaware, but they know they can get away with it. So they are most likely able to fly through any ethics puzzles.
It is a difficult problem and I'm not sure what the solutions are. Perhaps that is why referalls are generally given so much weight by employers: I've always thought of that as a chain of trust starting with the founders and extending right down to lower-level employees. However, a colleague/friend that you know well to be amazing to you might still have rather questionable views on gender/race/nationality etc. which you don't know so even this chain of trust isn't unbreakable...
- fancy_pantser 10y agoI am reminded of reading The Prince in college and hearing about virtù. Although you may think it's simply translated as "virtue", it's actually a very loaded concept in his works. Machiavelli employs "virtù" to refer to the range of personal qualities that the prince will find it necessary to acquire in order to “maintain his state” and to “achieve great things,” the two standard markers of power for him. This makes it brutally clear there can be no equivalence between the conventional virtues and Machiavellian virtù. Machiavelli expects princes of the highest virtù to be capable, as the situation requires, of behaving in a completely evil fashion. The managers probably thought their actions were in the "raison d'État". To extend Levy's simile from the article, the male engineers wore the leather jackets with the élan of fighter pilots and the virtù of The Prince.
- anigbrowl 10y agoIt's the reasoning process rather than the conclusion that you're testing for - many good ethics puzzles admit of more than one answer.
- FT_intern 10y agoNo, no one actually thinks they can get away with it given the current media climate. Donglegate is a reminder for everyone that even the smallest comment can bring the heat on you
- pyre 10y agoSo you're claiming that a manager at Uber thought it was ok to buy jackets for the guys, but to not get anything for the women because there was no bulk discount? What idiot thinks this line of thought: "It would unfair to the men if we paid more for the women's jackets, so we'll just give the men jackets and the women nothing. That seems more fair, right guys"? makes any sense?
- urahara 10y agoI think the solution requires to stop allowing harassers to get away with harassment and ensure punishment. Still there are many questions about how this can be organized and maintained.