3 ms·
> The law’s original intent was to patent mature discoveries, things like a genetically modified crop, or biofuel-farting yeast. Over the years, however, univer
by dmix 10y ago
> The law’s original intent was to patent mature discoveries, things like a genetically modified crop, or biofuel-farting yeast. Over the years, however, universities started filing patents further upstream—on everything from protein structures to bits of DNA. This frenzy of molecule-grabbing can actually work counter to Bayh-Doyle, locking up promising discoveries that don’t need help getting commercialized. “Crispr totally epitomizes that,” says Michael Eisen, a Berkeley biophysicist and long-time advocate of open science. “Everybody in the universe is chomping at the bit to use it. But patents are an obstacle to that happening right now.”
I recently read "Basic Economics" by Thomas Sowell and each chapter highlighting an economic concept included examples of government policy relevant to the subject. Such as rent control, price controls in agriculture, zoning, industry licensing, etc. Almost all of them had similar unintended side effects as seen here (ie, rent controls intended to reduce rent prices resulted in a shortage of affordable housing for poor people in NYC, Toronto, etc). They almost always create an imbalance where the negative side effects largely outweigh the intended benefits.
I'm not sure leaving such highly technical debates, such as whether or not you can patent a low level protein, should be left for random courts to decide.
How do we solve such a prevalent problem? Should the legislation then become more specific to make sure it has it's intended purpose? Or would that ultimately lead to endless complexity in law? Creating loopholes and increased difficulty/cost to implement?
The easy answer that some people take is that government should largely not be involved in this type of stuff but I'm always interested in exploring alternatives. But otherwise this stuff is largely ignored outside of the usual generic complaints about regulations coming from business groups each year, yet it continues to persist as a black/white issue in politics.
CRISPR is such a critical and important technology, it'd be a shame if it was held back by unintentional interpretations of law.
- djsumdog 10y agoI feel like the original supreme court decision that allowed the patenting of DNA needs to be overturned. The suit was brought by General Electric for an organism they didn't even use. Now the entire farming industry is radically different with companies like DuPont, Monsanto and BASF controlling the seed supplies for many major crops.
- Cpoll 10y ago> Monsanto The corporation everyone loves to hate. On the flip-side, I haven't heard any compelling way for Monsanto to recuperate the costs of R&D on their engineered crops. I'm sure a lot of people would be happy to see GM crops go away altogether, but I don't think that's a compelling solution.
- djsumdog 10y agoI listed the two others too, yet you focused on the one. Why did we need them in the first place? Prior to seed companies, seed stock was bread by farmers, universities and done in a way that was more open an accessible. We have been in overproduction of corn, grain and rice for over a decade. They haven't saved the world from hunger. Hunger still exists and has always been a distribution problem. In 2008, the food crisis was caused because investment companies started trading in grain futures and wouldn't let go (where as a food producer invests in a grain future because they plan on buying it in x months in order to make cereal or pizza crust or whatever). There was plenty of food though. The food shortage was literally manufactured. > any compelling way for Monsanto to recuperate the costs of R&D on their engineered crops It wasn't a problem that needed to be solved. On the flip side, now we have all this corn and grain that needs to be sold. Sure some of that can be turned into fuel, but a lot of it is pushed out in starchier food. We're consuming so much starch and sugar that we're now in an obesity epidemic. The food industry keeps pushing out advertising so people consume more of it. It's a cycle that's not been beneficial for many people.
- technotony 10y agoPlant patents [1] and Plant Variety Protection Rights [2] are totally reasonable ways they can protect their crops without blocking at the technology level with patents. Which to use depends on sexual vs asexual reproduction of the crop. [1] https://www.uspto.gov/patents-getting-started/patent-basics/types-patent-applications/general-information-about-35-usc-161 https://www.uspto.gov/patents-getting-started/patent-basics/... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Variety_Protection_Act_of_1970 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Variety_Protection_Act_o...
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y ago
- gwern 10y ago"tragedy of the anti-commons" is the phrase you're looking for here.