4 ms·
If you were designing Reddit today what would you do to prevent this kind of stuff?
by mrfusion 10y ago
If you were designing Reddit today what would you do to prevent this kind of stuff?
- codingdave 10y agoTiered subreddits. You would need to earn credibility in open discussions, and earn your way up into more serious discussions. So there would end up being multiple layers of credibility, with only vetted accounts participating in the highest levels.
- wcarron 10y agoThis approach is probably the most reasonable. Stackoverflow seems to have implemented it fairly well.
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoI can't agree. Stackoverflow does some things well, but there are reasons that it hasn't caught on outside a certain cohort who were either there first, or who are very dedicated to cultivating their karma. HN user jfc said it better here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7650975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7650975
- wcarron 10y agoI have to disagree. Those invested solely in cultivating karma are the reason to institute systems like "earned privileges". Any forum with a voting system will always be misused and abused by those who don't have the priority of the community in mind. Moreover, jfc has valid points about negativity and unhelpful responses, but it remains anecdotal. As a counter, my own anecdotal experience has largely been positive on SO, and I rarely run into those problems. I am definitely not part of the cohort that was there first, and think it's a rather fair system. For example, preventing downvotes until a certain level of reputation is reached is a small check on those looking to farm karma by blanketing out competing answers. Obviously it isn't foolproof, but it at least ensures that you have actually contributed to the community at least a few times. Perhaps his comment speaks more to the quality of the userbase than to the efficiency of the voting system?
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoI'll grant you that there are many high quality answers / discussions at SO. I also have no problem asserting that SO is infested with karma whores. They also have terrible moderation, and chippy pithy users with all manner of unproductive discussion habits. In other words, they suffer the same types of faults as other forums. I'm glad for you that you that you've had a positive experience on SO, obviously some users do; so have I, to the extent that I don't bother engaging in discussion, but rather just use the place to find the answer I want, and then just leave as soon as I am done with my research. As far as the anecdotes in that HN thread I posted earlier go, jfc isn't alone, there are pages of similar anecdotes in the same thread in addition to plenty of similar criticism elsewhere in the internet.
- jessriedel 10y agoSure, this is an OK scheme for finding higher quality discussion, but it's just not what the market wants. After the initial adopters had been outnumbered, but long before reddit was popular enough to attract legions of professional marketers, popular subreddits were dominated by puns, memes, highly biased politics, emoting, etc. It's what people upvote, and it doesn't require a reputation system.
- uremog 10y agoDo you think something like this could overcome the effects of say, the 50 Cent Party[1]? Or would they eventually end up being 80% of the "vetted accounts"? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
- codingdave 10y agoIn my mind, nothing like that should ever get vetted - only vetted accounts would be able to approve other accounts to get vetted. And with multiple layers of vetting, even if mistakes happen, it just won't go very high. Worst case scenario, if a group does infiltrate a layer, you just demote the whole layer. It might be a temporary frustration for real people, but that is better than perpetuating shills. People who are picturing crowds coming in and messing up such a system aren't really getting the idea -- it is a closed system. Above the lowest layer, it is read-only to the public, unless you are given permission to contribute. The other commenter who said people don't want a system like this may be correct... but that might be a good thing. Catering to the crowds isn't the goal here. Finding the much smaller groups that are willing to put in more work to manage themselves, and engage in meaningful dialogue is exactly what might make places like /r/politics meaningful.
- benologist 10y agoAnyone serious should start with HN's guidelines and try and steal dang from YC lol.
- clamprecht 10y agoMy idea is for reddit to make as much of the users' posting history available for anyone to download and analyze, but while respecting the privacy of their users. I'm not sure how this can be done (I don't know their terms of service). But the idea is to allow researchers to use reddit's data to find manipulation. I certainly don't expect reddit to solve the problem on their own.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fnordfnordfnord 10y agoNot so fast. You think up your own million dollar business ideas!
- sfaxon 10y agoThere have been a few articles claiming bots are being used on Twitter to impact trending topics. One solution I talked to a friend about was having a yearly subscription fee to make it less cost effective to create hundreds of fake accounts. Of course hitting a critical mass of users would be very difficult. And even if the service did become wildly popular, and trusted, it would only increase the value for companies to game the system. I think the general population is becoming more aware of how intrusive ad networks are, possibly moving the needle on making a pay service more viable. But I don't think I know any non-tech people that would be willing to pay for a Twitter/Facebook/Reddit type service today. So, I have no good solution. But I sure hope someone figures out a good solution. The whole concept of "pick your own truth" has some terrifying consequences.
- kneel 10y agoReddit's voting/karma system needs an overhaul. Karma does absolutely nothing on that site yet it's the only metric of value on that site (people do crazy things for meaningless reddit karma), that and having an ancient account but old accounts only matter to mods/admins for the most part. Give an allowance of votes per day/week. More can be bought for very cheap, like 2 cents? Votes are a commodity that can be accumulated and used to vote others. The more popular your posts are the more votes you have pooled to use on others. Votes are slowly dissipated over time to prevent hoarding. You'd have to find a way to deal with shills/bots. No easy solution here, invite only will stifle growth. Collecting too much personal info will stifle growth. Maybe extreme blacklisting techniques for anyone found to be manipulating? If you could pull it off then advertisers would actually have to pay to manipulate your site, not perfect but better than reddit's free accounts to manipulate thing they have going on now.
- Crosseye_Jack 10y ago> Give an allowance of upvotes per day/week. More can be bought for very cheap, like 2 cents? Every time a "what would kill off Reddit" thread comes up limiting up/downvotes and paying for more comes up. I feel it would kill off Reddit. (But I'm not a Reddit fan so I wouldn't stand in their way if they wish to add it).
- kneel 10y agoYeah I think if the idea took off it could work but the actual payment screen and entering cc info would turn off >99% of users.
- CamelCaseName 10y agoAnd the 1% of users it doesn't deter will be the ones who were previously manipulating results and can now do so for much cheaper.
- paulpauper 10y agoReddit has a lot of features to stop vote spam..they implemented an overhaul in late 2015 I know. Until then, newly made accounts could affect rankings..now they don't. . Mods are also pretty good at deleting spam, unless they are being paid off. The mods of major subs have enormous power, so it would not surprise me if this is going on still
- Slackwise 10y ago1. Make the website invite-only. 2. Give out X invites to everyone. 3. Every user now has a reference pointing to who invited them. 4. Require that you must vouch for the behavior of the people you invite, and their behavior may impact your participation. 5. Use tree traversal and analysis for pruning bad sections of the population of users. (i.e. If you see a series of bad users, go up the tree to find the source and prune it there.) 6. Work on algorithms and moderator tools to improve said analysis. 7. Give merit and incentive to those who contribute. (See: Slashdot and Everything2 systems.) 8. Add anonymous meta-moderation. (Again, see Slashdot.) 9. Give ranks and small power to users based on their merit and participation, and somewhat based on their invited friends. I can keep going. It's a bit harsh, but I feel it'd work. I've considered making an example app, but the hard part would be getting a critical mass of users and content. Reddit, for example, faked posting content for their first few years to seed their community. It's hard to grow a new community, if even possible. P.S. If anyone has a lobste.rs's invite, lemme know. Curious to see how their invite-only website has progressed.
- CamelCaseName 10y agoSounds a lot like how most private trackers work. As you mentioned, it is too difficult to get off the ground with an invite system, but it may be interesting if an existing community became invite-only. Unfortunately the high risk of torpedoing your business is a deterrent.
- ben174 10y agoThis actually sounds like it could work. If you do decide to build it, I'd love to help.