Somehow I thought this was going to be more like the barber question. "There are only two barbers in town. One is neatly trimmed, smooth shaven, professional,

Somehow I thought this was going to be more like the barber question. "There are only two barbers in town. One is neatly trimmed, smooth shaven, professional, and is sweeping up after his last customer. The other has a wild appearance, terribly-cut hair, his shop is messy and has no customers. Which do you go to?" I wasn't quite sure how it would work with surgeons, though... "One has perfectly-sutured incisions all over his body, the other has organs flopping out..."