4 ms·
If people are concerned about the geographic link that too can be solved. E.g. Norway uses proportionality within regions, and counts votes per party list and
by vidarh 10y ago
If people are concerned about the geographic link that too can be solved.
E.g. Norway uses proportionality within regions, and counts votes per party list and then keeps track of how many "wasted" votes each party has.
Then a small fixed number of seats are allocated in descending order of remaining wasted votes (each allocation removes an equivalent number of votes from that party-lists pool) from the region where that party had the most wasted votes.
There's also a 5% threshold in the national vote to be able to receive seats from that pool.
It both gets relatively close to proportional, still makes it possible for very popular independent candidates to get elected directly, and the seats used to even out are also linked to regions. The areas are just a bit larger.
Even 2-3 seats per district plus a few seats used to even out representation would give dramatic improvements in proportionality.