4 ms·
> The current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design Seriously? Perhaps I'm biased because I own one, but it's pretty much the most
by pmarreck 10y ago
> The current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design
Seriously? Perhaps I'm biased because I own one, but it's pretty much the most awesomely-designed desktop computer ever IMHO, at least from a hardware/cooling/looks perspective. The real problem, I thought, is that Apple seems to have left desktops behind to rot
- fake-name 10y agoSure, it's pretty, and if you want an completely un-upgradeable appliance, it's probably wonderful. The point is, most professionals upgrade the same computer multiple times over it's life, particularly for fast-moving components (the GPU, in this case). Making them basically completely impossible to upgrade significantly reduces the long-term value of the mac pro.
- Lio 10y agoThe thing is that they could be upgraded if Apple had released new GPU or SSD cards since the current Mac Pro launched. Alternatively they could have used industry standards in the first place, certainly for the internal SSD connection. It doesn't help that they've also failed to keep either their openGL, openCL or Metal drivers competitive either.
- pmarreck 10y agoUpgrading components has never been a Macintosh thing. Arguably because simply upgrading 1 component just exchanges 1 bottleneck (graphics) for another one just behind it (motherboard or memory clock speed etc.) It's better and far more long-term cost-effective to simply upgrade the entire system at once IMO. I believe you're vastly overestimating the number of professionals who upgrade individual components (other than memory or hard drive which were always upgradable on Macs).
- kalleboo 10y agoWhy did they make the PowerMac G3/G4 series so easy to open you could do it with one finger if upgrading components "wasn't a Macintosh thing"? To dust the machine out?
- acdha 10y agoSome pros expect to upgrade but many replace systems for simplicity: if you make money off of your computer, spending a few grand every couple of years just isn't that significant. If you have a 4 year old system break after years of heavy (i.e. heat-generating use) the downtime cost can quickly hit the same amount and it's less predictable compared to simply budgeting n-thousand a year as a business expense just like you do with a desk, coffee, etc. The problem is that Apple has chosen not to put any resources into non-portable devices and so the problem isn't an expense but an absolute lack of options other than switching platforms.
- kalleboo 10y agoI agree the hardware design is amazing. Product design is more than the hardware - it's where does this fit in in the market? Who's the customer? What's the roadmap?
- pmarreck 10y agoYeah. Those answers are apparently 1) Nowhere 2) A small band of die-hard enthusiasts 3) End-of-lifed :/ The Mac Pro is probably one of the last Apple products to have Jobs' fingerprints on it, too
- Fomite 10y agoI think from a design standpoint it was interesting, and might have been forgivable if there had been slightly more diversity in the GPU lineup and if they had kept it up to date. The latter one is the big one. You can't just leave an unupgradable professional focused machine sitting on the shelf rotting.
- astrodust 10y agoThe real problem is people aren't buying desktops like they used to, and as a percentage of Apple's revenue they're almost non-existent. They're in a bit of a bind here. They can't cater to every niche need, they're not going to make these quirky, narrow-use spec machines. They can't compete on price compared to hand-built. They can't compete on performance compared to the ultra-high end workstations from other vendors. Maybe if they opened up a limited licensing program for macOS on desktop machines to a handful of premium vendors that are willing to adhere to certain constraints they'd have a way out of this jam.