7 ms·
The current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design, it will be really curious to see if they will walk it back, or just drop the pro
by kalleboo 10y ago
The current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design, it will be really curious to see if they will walk it back, or just drop the pro market completely.
I wonder what thinking lead to that product. Did they think the pro market would be worth it to them to keep investing in keeping the product up to date and then it turned out not to be worth the investment? Although, even before then the Mac Pro was only updated sporadically... Was it all just Jony Ive design hubris? Who is the Mac Pro designed for?
- xt00 10y agoSeems like almost assuredly they will just drop it.. basically I can't imagine any engineer at Apple that is or was working on it is super excited about something that probably made a grand total of like 50 million USD during the mac pro lifetime compared to like 80 billion on iPhone sales per quarter...
- spamizbad 10y agoConsidering Apple's significant profits and cash in the bank... Apple is well-suited to fund a loss-leader products that bolster their cachet in the professional community -- putting their platform on the front-lines of culture creators. Furthermore, today's demanding professional are tomorrows Joe Schmoes: having the hearts and minds of pioneers would them better see what's coming on the horizon. It just seems silly not to invest money to keep the power-user niches happy.
- bluejekyll 10y ago> Apple is well-suited to fund a loss-leader products that bolster their cachet in the professional community They could do this, but they have yet to prove that they will do it. Ever since Jobs, Apple has been hyper fixated on focused, profitable product lines. The Pro is out of step with that, and I bet with laptops making up the bulk of their computer sales, we'll start seeing them move away from the iMac too. My only guess right now is that they still feel they need the Pro to maintain their computer business, but I fear they are slowly becoming just a gadget company and will forget their roots.
- murukesh_s 10y agoI wish Apple management folks read the sentiment here. Because, I believe if not for Apple, the industry wouldn't have progressed this far, at least in the build quality department (We had Sony, Dell and IBMs pro laptops but they never had the combination of price/build quality/looks nailed).
- tlow 10y agoI think this is a very interesting perspective. If I understand correctly, your argument is that a Mac Pro product need not be a direct profit maker so long as it perpetuates Apple's position as a top end computer manufacturer. Have I understood correctly? Or are you perhaps prognosticating a change in market demands rendering such a product less relevant?
- spamizbad 10y agoYou got it. It's a strategy employed by the automobile industry as well: high-end loss leaders that "signal the brand" and cultivate loyalty among enthusiasts. Apple's claim is staked on high-margin products, so it needs an elite cachet much more than say... Xiaomi or Dell. And you can signal that to consumers with one-of-a-kind high-end products that operate on the absolute cutting-edge of various creative, technical, and scientific niches.
- blumentopf 10y agoPorsche for instance isn't earning any money with their LMP1 race cars. They need them to sustain the illusion that they're a sports car company, despite the majority of their sales being SUVs (Cayenne, Macan) and sedans (Panamera).
- graeme 10y agoThat, plus also the effect that people in the market for pro computers tend to be infleuntial. They creatd software and influence the purchasing decisions of others.
- true_religion 10y agoI think its a bad idea to drop things based on how excited your engineers are. If you go that route, then plenty of companies producing boring software and industry specific products will just die.
- xt00 10y agoYea totally agree in general -- in this case I just mean that its so obvious right now how much focus Apple puts on their money making products that engineers at Apple would see the writing on the wall and they too would not be that interested in pushing the product forward -- likely the people who worked on it if they were smart tried to bail out of that group long ago. So if both the management and the engineers both don't want to work on something, then both the money and effort is dropped on the product and its dead. When Jobs was alive, people could get Jobs to approve it as a pet project and they would get money and people on it and it would move along. But nobody seems to be pushing those pet projects at Apple anymore.
- tmsldd 10y agoYou got the point.. all Apple want to its pro line is having enough computing power to develop apps for mobile... For Apple, developing laptops systems/applications is not economically interesting anymore. All said, Apple wants pro developers as long as you are a mobile pro developer.
- ajmurmann 10y agoThat's incredibly short sighted. This way they will lose many of their pro users which might not matter. But then they will tell their friends when asked what to buy to not get a Apple computer. I believe pro users is what made Apple big and it's a large part of what their success stand on.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoI think - sadly - you're right about this. There doesn't seem to be anyone at Apple speaking for creatives any more. Certainly no one who gets really excited about working with musicians, artists, film directors, and so on, almost as an equal. Cook has the mindset of an accountant who is a media and trinket consumer, not the mindset of an inventor with creative aspirations. Likewise the rest of the executive team. To be fair, there aren't many people like that around. But it would cost Apple virtually nothing to host some product focus groups with creative talent to ask "What do you want...?"
- Lio 10y agoTotally agree. It's like the company actually decided to stop standing for something real.
- mozumder 10y agoThe Mac Pro design itself is great - Xeon CPU, dual GPUs, infinite storage expandability via Thunderbolt 2.. the problem is that they never upgraded it. The GPU is 4 years old now, for example.
- jwatte 10y agoA new version every year, and space for multiple internal SSDs, would have made it desirable. However, Apple is now milking the old glory and failing to build tomorrow's glory. It's the classic beam counter mistake. It's probably time to short Apple soon.
- bluejekyll 10y agoYeah. It was awesome when it came out...
- kalleboo 10y agoRight, you either choose an integrated design, and commit to expending the resources to keeping it upgraded right there on the bleeding edge, or you build an expandable machine and let your customers do that work for you. But even before the integrated Mac Pro, they regularly let it go two years between updates of the pro model. They must have known when designing the machine that they wouldn't be keeping it up-to-date and that it would quickly become obsolete? Apple also has the issue of trying to align their releases to their PR schedules. When a component (like a CPU generation) slips, it really messes with their update cycles (see: MacBooks). This doesn't matter so much to consumer devices, but pros are more sensitive to this, and letting pros upgrade their machines mitigates this to some extent.
- Fomite 10y agoEven when it was new, the GPU was a problem for me. Now it's both a problem and old, which is not a good combination.
- nottorp 10y agoExcept the GPUs were crap even on release. And there are like 3 applications that can use both? So unless you were in that niche, you'd end up paying a ton of money for two dubious GPUs of which you could only use one.
- jobu 10y ago> Was it all just Jony Ive design hubris? Who is the Mac Pro designed for? Apple consistently chooses form over function, but they don't usually let the scales tip this far. The last time they fucked up this bad was the Mac Cube, but back then Apple was proactive enough to kill the Cube within 6 months. It really surprises me that Apple hasn't come out with something to replace the current Mac Pro. Microsoft realized that the niche creative-type markets that Apple has historically owned tend to be broad-market influencers, and they've started to target them with products like the Surface Pro and Surface Studio. Competition is great, and it will be interesting to see if Apple will rise to it or fade away.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoThe Cube didn't replace the Power Mac. It was sold in addition to it. If you compared them on specs alone the Power Mac was cheaper and faster so literally the only reason to buy the Cube was because it looked nice. (Or maybe because your desk was really small.) The current Mac Pro replaced the old Mac Pro, though. That's the difference. If you don't like it, your only other choices are iMac (built in monitor) or Mac Mini (horrifically underpowered). Apple could kill the Cube without consequence, but the current desktop Mac lineup is so limited there is no alternative.
- nottorp 10y ago[quote] iMac (built in monitor)[/quote] It's not the built in monitor that's the problem, is the overheating with the assorted noise and possibly thermal throttling if you use it for something that actually maxes out the CPU/GPU. Well, and the lack of expandability. While the portable MacBook Pro equivalents are about the same thing (look at Dell XPS 13 pricing), Apple right now has nothing for developers/power users on the desktop side.
- intoverflow2 10y ago> with the assorted noise and possibly thermal throttling if you use it for something that actually maxes out the CPU/GPU. Yeah it's worth pointing out that the trashcan runs silent at full pelt, while the iMac sounds like a jet engine. Keep this in mind when you imagine a row of 10 3d/video artists rendering away all day.
- pmarreck 10y ago> The current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design Seriously? Perhaps I'm biased because I own one, but it's pretty much the most awesomely-designed desktop computer ever IMHO, at least from a hardware/cooling/looks perspective. The real problem, I thought, is that Apple seems to have left desktops behind to rot
- fake-name 10y agoSure, it's pretty, and if you want an completely un-upgradeable appliance, it's probably wonderful. The point is, most professionals upgrade the same computer multiple times over it's life, particularly for fast-moving components (the GPU, in this case). Making them basically completely impossible to upgrade significantly reduces the long-term value of the mac pro.
- Lio 10y agoThe thing is that they could be upgraded if Apple had released new GPU or SSD cards since the current Mac Pro launched. Alternatively they could have used industry standards in the first place, certainly for the internal SSD connection. It doesn't help that they've also failed to keep either their openGL, openCL or Metal drivers competitive either.
- pmarreck 10y agoUpgrading components has never been a Macintosh thing. Arguably because simply upgrading 1 component just exchanges 1 bottleneck (graphics) for another one just behind it (motherboard or memory clock speed etc.) It's better and far more long-term cost-effective to simply upgrade the entire system at once IMO. I believe you're vastly overestimating the number of professionals who upgrade individual components (other than memory or hard drive which were always upgradable on Macs).
- kalleboo 10y agoWhy did they make the PowerMac G3/G4 series so easy to open you could do it with one finger if upgrading components "wasn't a Macintosh thing"? To dust the machine out?
- vegabook 10y agoJony Ive has become too senior to be effectively challengeable by more engineering types. That's why all the Mac hardware since he was elevated to his current position, always errs in favour of design at the expense of high end functionality.