3 ms·
I can see build-out requirements being a big issue to picking a next city, but I don't see it as the reason for why it looks like Google appears to be slowly st
by WorldMaker 10y ago
I can see build-out requirements being a big issue to picking a next city, but I don't see it as the reason for why it looks like Google appears to be slowly stopping all efforts across the board in existing cities. OTMR fights hint that Google may be losing a war of attrition with the entrenched monopolies to inflated costs and infrastructure battles.
«If OTMR ordinances are really what drive fiber rollout, why not fight that battle on its home turf?»
I don't know much of nuance of geopolitics here, but I would assume that the cities that have started the OTMR battles think they are particularly underserved by incumbents, but more importantly may have more political jurisdiction in their respective states to pass OTMR ordinances/legislation within city limits. While Google has been the biggest suggestion influence and has been helping to fight the OTMR battles, it certainly seems like thus far the onus and a great majority of the work has been the cities themselves trying to reign in monopoly control incumbents. (Most of the cities even seem to be fighting for OTMR in spite of anti-regulationist-controlled state legislatures and public utility boards, where such a change might more naturally be easier.)
I think the question is more why hasn't the Bay Area tried to fight for OTMR ordinances than why hasn't Google tried to get the Bay Area to fight for OTMR ordinances.
As to why Google doesn't include the Bay Area at the top of its priorities, I'd assume it's economic as much as anything: they seem to be prioritizing places they can most easily compete against incumbents, and their values seem focused on "floating the most boats" for now by finding the cities that are most currently underserved. You may personally think the Bay Area isn't adequately served by Comcast, but have you seen some of the rest of the country that doesn't have millions of technical workers living in it? (Spoiler alert: we all have it terrible. Our for-profit infrastructure monopolies don't have our best interests in mind and most of our regulations and oversight has been defanged or destroyed.)
- rayiner 10y agoPlaces like Austin, Atlanta, Provo, etc., were not "underserved" relative to Bay Area cities before Fiber. I lived in Atlanta in 2007--we had the same Comcast packages you could get anywhere else. The difference between Atlanta and Menlo Park is not that Comcast had better service in Menlo Park. It's that Atlanta is in a low-regulation red state and was willing to give tons of concessions and waive requirements it imposes on everyone else. Moreover, deployment in most Fiber cities has gone forward without litigation. There was no major litigation in Kansas City, Provo, etc. I think the OTMR lawsuits are stupid, but pointing to them as the reason why Google is pulling back on fiber is willful blindness to the obvious. Google is pulling back on fiber because there isn't enough money in it.
- WorldMaker 10y agoSorry, I was using the OTMR lawsuits as a proxy/definitive example for why there isn't enough money in it. I agree, the big problem is that there isn't enough money in it, I just disagree that build-out requirements are the big reason there isn't enough money in it. I may not have made that clear enough. It's hard to control costs when the incumbents are doing everything in their power to delay and inflate costs. OTMR is one attempted solution to one particular angle in which the incumbents have a power to delay and inflate project costs. The OTMR lawsuits are emblematic of how far the incumbents are willing to go to continue to delay and inflate costs (to years in court and years of legal fees) and how much "defense depth" they have to accomplish it (the parties involved in the court cases are different incumbents in each jurisdiction). Build-out requirements can be estimated in the fixed capital costs of a project, assuming no other interference. The need for OTMR and the current OTMR lawsuits are proof that the interference exists and is not easily contained/constrained and quite probably not even possible to estimate as they will be different in every city in the country. I use OTMR as an example because it is the most visible example. I mostly suspect it is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of cost issues into a project like Google Fiber.