9 ms·
It would be interesting to see a breakdown of WHAT Bitcoin are being trading for (e.g. pure investment, black market goods, standard commercial goods/services).
by Someone1234 10y ago
It would be interesting to see a breakdown of WHAT Bitcoin are being trading for (e.g. pure investment, black market goods, standard commercial goods/services).
Without a good understand of what drives Bitcoin's use it is hard to tell if this is an investment bubble or legitimate organic growth. I will say I don't run across all too many sites that support payment via Bitcoin, I know they exist, but it hasn't expanded to be commonplace.
But I've read the drug market on e.g. Tor is alive and well. So maybe that drives a lot of this trading.
- bookbinder 10y agoSites that support Bitcoin don't usually make a big deal about it. For example, Microsoft.com accepts bitcoin.
- mrb 10y ago"So maybe that drives a lot of this trading" No data supports this. For some reason articles occasionally still make this claim, but no sources support this. In fact I am aware of a study that reports the opposite: that Bitcoin commerce is no longer driven by "sin" activities but instead by legitimate enterprises: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers2.cfm?abstract_id=2808762 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers2.cfm?abstract_id=2808762
- mathattack 10y agoI've seen anecdotally a lot of use for cross-border payments. (Try wiring $500 to grandma, and see how many middlemen take a share)
- awa 10y agowell, there are bunch of services which make it easy (e.g. xoom.com) and allow tracking of transactions and verification of transfers etc.
- alanfalcon 10y agoUnrelated: I remember when xoom.com was an e-mail service provider with free web space back in 1999. Feels weird to see URLs recycled like this. http://web.archive.org/web/19990508170650/http://www.xoom.com/home/ http://web.archive.org/web/19990508170650/http://www.xoom.co...
- arturmakly 10y agoxoom rocks this
- Someone1234 10y agoI just use TransferWise. Works great. I used to use Xoom but every six months when I'd go to do a transfer they'd need more security verification and it got tiresome. Although that was a few years ago, maybe it is better now.
- digitalronin 10y agoServices like TransferWise and Xoom are great, provided both parties have access to good banking services. But, a lot of the remittances market is people working in a foreign country sending money back home to people who may well be unbanked. Some of the startups targeting that market, using bitcoin as the transfer layer, are pretty interesting.
- josu 10y agoMost of the people around me are using it as a speculative investment / store of value. If my sample is not biased and this is the case for the whole universe, that alone should be driving the price up. The amount of new bitcoins that are being made available is just 12.5 every 10 minutes, this is a mere 1,800 BTC a day, or around USD 2 million. If the main use for bitcoin is store of value or long investments, the available "old" bitcoins are not going to be that many. In my opinion this is the main driver of the price.
- nosuchthing 10y agoKnowing there's continual advancements in all the alternative cryptocoins, one has to wonder why anyone would find it viable to "store value" in a system that may at any moment become objectively obsolete. More noteworthy is the assumption people have that BTC (or any other early-adopter-deflationary-investment-coin) is able to serve as a currency ecosystem when it's inherently deflationary, thus discouraging the usage of it for anything but speculative hording (which assumes there is a demand by something other than hoarders..) - or rapid short term use, which has proven ineffective and untimely for micropayments [1]. http://www.coindesk.com/lightning-duplex-scalable-bitcoin-micropayments/ http://www.coindesk.com/lightning-duplex-scalable-bitcoin-mi...
- wmf 10y agoBitcoin has been "objectively obsolete" for a while (Ethereum, Monero/ZCash etc.) yet its value increases. Maybe people are investing for some other reason such as network effects.
- problems 10y agoYeah, I have to imagine that a lot of the practical use cases would be better on Monero or ZCash where cryptographic anonymity can be had. Especially in black market type transactions this is hugely beneficial. That said, a lot of the infrastructure is only on the Bitcoin front still - only a few exchanges offer other cryptocurrencies.
- eip 10y agoBy far the majority of it's use is to escape currency controls in fiat currencies. Mostly from China.
- Exofunctor 10y agoPersonally, I've done a lot of dev work for Bitcoin for foreign nationals. It gets real annoying real fast to deal with PayPal or traditional international money transfer systems when you're talking contract work levels of money for a small company (too much for shitty remittance services, too little to make the overhead of more complicated bank-managed mechanisms worth it). And yes, I do pay taxes on my Bitcoin payments. It's somewhat annoying to keep track of everything, but my accountant mostly takes care of it for me. I probably end up losing ~2% to overhead (very little of which is due to Bitcoin itself), which is unfortunate but comparable to even the cheapest traditional services.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- disposableteen2 10y agoCould you elaborate how you find clients like this? Do you specifically look for clients who are willing to pay in bitcoin or work on bitcoin-related projects?
- Exofunctor 10y agoClients mostly find me. I'm honestly not sure how to optimize for that, it's usually pretty random. I guess for those clients I do seek out, they'll post about wanting developers in forums or mailing lists or whatever.
- legulere 10y agoYou forgot all the disk encryption malware that asks for bitcoins to decode your files again.
- mr_green_tea 10y agoI'm pretty sure active trading with BTC is mostly regarding drug dealing through dark net market places. And the conversion mostly dealers selling BTC for USD to consumers, which buy drugs with BTC and those BTC will be sold back to the consumers for USD. As far as I can tell there is simply nothing else to do with BTC as of now ... sure you can use it in some shops and you can buy plane tickets from Air Baltic with BTC - but those purchases are always actually more expensive to cover for the volatility of the BTC value and of interest only for users who think its fun to actually use BTC in the real world. Probably it will either establish as an illegal clandestine super-national currency or it will be hijacked by banks for whatever weird theoretical purpose.
- hisabness 10y agoI know plenty of people who buy and hold it for no other reason than it's deflationary. What is wrong with that? Why do people need to transact?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoYou can really only speculate, but I think it's safe to say that the strong majority of trading is for speculation. The darknet markets certainly bring some demand, but it's high-velocity. You don't need to hold BTC, only transact in it. The remittance market does seem to be there, but it's still in its infancy. Maybe only a small fraction from this. Similarly, actual e-commerce is quite limited. Bitcoin offers few advantages over PayPal and credit cards for the large majority of consumers. There's only a subset of international transactions and other fringe situations where it makes sense. I think the other significant market, after the speculators, are those that are ideologically motivated to hold Bitcoin.
- gozur88 10y ago>The darknet markets certainly bring some demand, but it's high-velocity. You don't need to hold BTC, only transact in it. Except that if you're doing something illegal you pretty much do need to hold onto it unless you have a way of laundering it to a national currency.
- wmf 10y agoIt seems kind of pointless to engage in crime if you can never spend the profits.
- gozur88 10y agoYou can, but you have to spend them in bitcoins. There might even be enough of a legitimate bitcoin economy you could mostly do it, assuming you weren't a really big time criminal. Those guys have ways to launder the profits anyway.
- wslh 10y agoSome of our customers in this sector pay us in bitcoins in exchange for services. They are well known in the sector, so no connected to the dark web.
- dkincaid 10y agoI'm seeing it more and more. I just saw recently that you can buy gold and silver from Provident Metals using Bitcoin.
- thomasthomas 10y agoCheck out Jim Epstein's article on how its used in Venezuela. Pretty great use case. As long as there are a few intermediary companies, i'm not sure it matters that most companies don't take btc. Like many bitcoin users, Alberto, the miner who makes $1,200 daily, imports food from the U.S. through Amazon's Prime Pantry service. This would be impossible with bolivars because almost no one outside of Venezuela accepts them as payment, and the growing scarcity of U.S. currency has made purchasing foreign goods with dollars increasingly difficult. Though the Seattle-based retail giant doesn't accept bitcoins itself, plenty of intermediary companies do. Alberto purchases Amazon gift cards through the cryptocurrency-friendly website eGifter, using software to mask the location of his computer, and then routes his orders through a Miami-based courier service. http://reason.com/archives/2016/11/28/the-secret-dangerous-world-of http://reason.com/archives/2016/11/28/the-secret-dangerous-w...
- gmcmullen 10y agoThere's a great discussion of that article in Russ Robert's interview of Epstein on the Feb 13 episode of EconTalk. http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/jim_epstein_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/jim_epstein_on.html