4 ms·
Perhaps I'm just out of touch, but I'm not familiar with any of the alternative tools they mentioned. If we retire PGP (and its GNU clone), what widely availabl
by falcolas 10y ago
Perhaps I'm just out of touch, but I'm not familiar with any of the alternative tools they mentioned. If we retire PGP (and its GNU clone), what widely available tool should we use in its stead?
- gregoryrueda 10y agoSignal? Some paid services seem to be blossoming, see https://protonmail.com https://protonmail.com
- datatan 10y agoProtonmail uses PGP............
- falcolas 10y agoSignal is not much of a PGP replacement. There's a lot that PGP can do that Signal can't: signing, encryption of large blobs at rest, and key management. I use PGP as part of my backup solution, encrypting my backups at rest with an asymmetric key. I can't do that with Signal.
- tptacek 10y agoSignal does a better job of practically everything PGP does with regards to message encryption. Yes, PGP is more useful for encrypting files or signing updates. I agree that it's too early to write of PGP for those applications. But people should use Signal instead of PGP for message encryption.
- Tharkun 10y agoHow would that work? Last I checked, Signal used Signal servers for key exchange (or whatever the equivalent in their lingo is). Is there any way to use Signal without relying on their servers?
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Signal does a better job of practically everything PGP does with regards to message encryption." Except for endpoint security. The ultra-portable, self-contained implementations of PGP can run on countless configurations of desktop or embedded system. Transport methods also vary if they're funning messages or files through other apps. All sorts of hardening or isolation techniques can be applied. Remote attackers have a lot to look at trying to break or bypass GPG for an arbitrary user. Whereas, vast majority of Signal use relies on one app with two OS's. The extra security tech and obfuscation you can layer on PGP/GPG is still an advantage in its favor until competition gets that.
- falcolas 10y ago> But people should use Signal instead of PGP for message encryption. I won't disagree; when your usecase is in Signal's wheelhouse, by all means, use it. But as someone who uses PGP regularly; the limit of how I could use Signal instead of PGP is limited to the occasional transfer of PII, passphrases, and private keys (something I couldn't use Signal for, since these are typically sent between GUI-less hosts). A very tiny fraction of my PGP usage.
- Freak_NL 10y ago> But people should use Signal instead of PGP for message encryption. Signal the protocol or Signal the service? There does not appear to be a mature FOSS toolchain for the former that can replace gnupg and Thunderbird/Enigmail, and the latter is only available on Android and IOS smartphones.
- tptacek 10y agoDon't use email to send secret messages.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoAny chance you could elaborate on this? What about email is inimical to secret messages? Why are they less secret over email than through some other medium?
- mstef 10y agoopmsg does masquerade as gnupg on the cli, if you take this further you could create a gnupg chameleon which detects what keys are available or what the input is based on auxillary info and then invoke the appropriate tool (which might be gnupg, or something else). on a different note: gnupg is not widely used, signal is.
- datatan 10y agoSignal is for text messaging and fails as an email replacement. It also does not work for signing code and it requires you give over your contacts list to a third party to work. Signal is not fit for PGP's use case.
- dublinben 10y agoSignal is actually quite sufficient as an email replacement. You can send media attachments, and even include several recipients. It is unquestionably a better encrypted messaging system than PGP.
- tapoxi 10y agoUnless you actually need to send email with Signal, or want to be anonymous, since Signal uses your phone number.
- mstef 10y agopgp does not provide anonymity at least not in the widely accepted form. every message has the recipient keyid in plaintext, unless you --throw-keyids but then you run into incompatibilities and inconveniences that make the whole exercise user unfriendly and widely unsupported.
- falcolas 10y ago> pgp does not provide anonymity Not quite true. > every message has the recipient keyid in plaintext The keys are not required to be centralized in any particular location. There is no way to tie a key to an individual, unless that individual wants to be associated with that key id. It's common practice to post anonymous, encrypted messages on mailing lists or newsgroups. All you can really tell in those cases is that the recipient is a member of that mailing list or subscribes to the newsgroup (though it's not for sure, with the use of remailers, etc).
- skrowl 10y agoQuite a few listed here - https://alternativeto.net/software/gnupg/ https://alternativeto.net/software/gnupg/
- tptacek 10y agoThis is an unvetted list of random programs that claim to perform this- or that- cryptographic operation; it's not really helpful.
- twothamendment 10y agoThere are quite a few things listed there, but I fail to see one that looks like a replacement for PGP. Many are some form of PGP compatible encryption - some different platforms Android(AGP), Windows(GPG4Win, Fort) Apple(GPG Suite for apple mail). Some will only encrypt files with a password, others encrypt your disk. There might be some good software there, but I don't see anything that can replace PGP/GnuPG. Using PGP/GnuPG isn't always easy, but it works for so many things. Signing code, encrypting files, emails, signing messages - replacing it is a fairly high bar. I'd love to see encryption easy and used everywhere, but a few popular apps don't add up to replacing this old work horse.
- mstef 10y agocheck out opmsg how it achieves compatibility with gnupg and imagine a tool that actually looks like gpg but figures out which crypto backend to call.
- falcolas 10y agoInteresting project, but I'd personally want to see a lot more involvement and vetting from the crypto community at large. Especially when it creates new protocols like DH key exchange over email.
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>but I'm not familiar with any of the alternative tools they mentioned. The tinfoil hat part of me has been seeing this push for the Signal protocol straight out of nowhere and am a little worried its being done by a state level actor who knows something about it that we don't. Its much younger than PGP and as such has had less eyes on it. I also don't think Moxie Marlinspike, the founder of Signal's owner - Open Whisper, has the cred and trust Phil Zimmerman had, at least not yet. Its particularly worrisome as he seemingly is only known by a pseudonym. I also would consier S/MIME, which is baked into most feature-heavy email clients including iOS, a practical alternative to PGP when the use case is email encryption. You and a friend can get certs easily, put them in your client via GUI, and be done with it. No command line skills needed if ease of use is the big complaint here. For the less technically inclined its a pretty good solution, pun intended.
- mstef 10y agoif you knew the story you'd know that Phil did actually an abysmal implementation which had to fixed by others.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoI think I've read about Phil's shortcomings, but in the end he made it happen both technically and politically. I'm ok with software being a community effort and the less talented being helped by the more. Its a group effort to me and I don't believe in the coder superman mythos is required for good software. Not everyone can be a Linus or a Carmack.